Britain is not a superpower

2003-03-20 Thread Chris Burford
Britain is not a superpower. Our interests are best protected, not by unilateral action, but by multilateral agreement and a world order governed by rules. Well articulated by Robin Cook (not one of my former comrades!) on his resignation from the UK government. Strictly an imperialist

Re: the nature of the war

2003-03-20 Thread Dan Scanlan
Title: Re: [PEN-L:35785] the nature of the war Yesterday, I had a conversation with a friend who's been on the left for about 55 years. He suggested that Bush's war may actually be against the collective interests of the ruling class, the product of a small clique within that class. I suggested

Re: Paul Eluard

2003-03-20 Thread Sabri Oncu
The poem looked good but I did not have any clue about what it said. Could you please post a Korean translation of this so that I can understand? Mongolian will do just fine too. They are all sister languages of my language. Best, Sabri

Re: Re: Re: 535 members of Congress and ...

2003-03-20 Thread Robert Scott Gassler
Point taken. What about Korea? At 10:20 19/03/03 -0800, Eugene Coyle wrote: Isn't it the point that BOTH in Vietnam and now, the Congress didn't have family and friends in the enlisted ranks? Gene Coyle Robert Scott Gassler wrote: I'm sorry but I cannot make too much of that. I remember the

Re: Re: Paul Eluard

2003-03-20 Thread Bill Lear
On Thursday, March 20, 2003 at 02:17:25 (-0800) Sabri Oncu writes: The poem looked good but I did not have any clue about what it said. Could you please post a Korean translation of this so that I can understand? Mongolian will do just fine too. They are all sister languages of my language. Best,

Re: Re: Re: Paul Eluard

2003-03-20 Thread soula avramidis
Thanks I was hoping for one although that translation is prety wicked to say the least. I think the korean looked better. Bill Lear [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Thursday, March 20, 2003 at 02:17:25 (-0800) Sabri Oncu writes:The poem looked good but I did not have any clue about what itsaid. Could

Human Rights in Iraq

2003-03-20 Thread soula avramidis
20 March 2003 HIGH COMMISSIONER FOR HUMAN RIGHTS APPEALS TO PARTIES IN IRAQ CONFLICT TO RESPECT HUMAN RIGHTS AND HUMANITARIAN LAW The following statement was issued today by United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights Sergio Vieira de Mello: As hostilities begin in Iraq, I appeal to the

Re: The politics underlying the war

2003-03-20 Thread Louis Proyect
Chris Burford wrote: We will see how the peace movement responds and evolves, and we can each make our personally minuscule contribution to the debate. Peace now, or Cease fire now, may remain the main slogans, but a purely pacifist position will isolate the movement from its wide hinterland,

Re: the nature of the war

2003-03-20 Thread Ellen Frank
The problem with trying to figure this out is that nobody can figure out why we want war so badly. What is the objective? To distract attention from the economy until Nov, 2004? To get control of Iraq's oil? To assert US power? To bring democracy to the Middle East? Certainly, the ruling

RE: RE: Re: Martin Feldstein??

2003-03-20 Thread Brown, Martin - ARP (NIH/NCI)
Title: Message He is also President of the National Bureau of Economic Research, a very presitigous private economic research organization. They have the official word, for some reason, on announcing whether the country is in a recession or not. More importantly NBER status determines

re: the nature of the war

2003-03-20 Thread Devine, James
Title: re: the nature of the war There are two aspects to the question. First, there's the ruling elite that Dan writes about (the Clump), the one that's currently led by the Bushists. But I was also talking about the ruling class, a larger group that controls the means of production and

Re: Re: the nature of the war

2003-03-20 Thread k hanly
So you have given at least three key reasons why is it so difficult to figure out. The whole strategy is available in public domain sources, although some of it is a bit hidden in ideological fog. See this website, the Bible of the Hawks or at least one of the Holy sources.

profile in courage

2003-03-20 Thread Devine, James
Title: profile in courage I couldn't find the specific reference in today's L.A. TIMES, but on the front page there was a small picture of Bush with something like the following, from memory: President Bush showed his fist and said I feel great. Jim Devine [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: Re: Re: the nature of the war

2003-03-20 Thread Carrol Cox
What does PNAC, as in PNAC people, stand for? Carrol

Re: Re: Re: Re: the nature of the war

2003-03-20 Thread k hanly
Project for the New American Century. The first URL in my post takes you to their website. Many of the people involved have close ties to the Bush government. Here is an example of documents released by the PNAC. Notice all the big gun hawks involved Rumsfeld, Cheney et al... There was nothing

Critical Analysis of Bushspeak

2003-03-20 Thread k hanly
Or deconstruction for u PMscheers, Ken Hanly From the CASI discussion list http://www.wsws.org/articles/2003/mar2003/bush-m20.shtml The twenty lies of George W. Bush By Patrick Martin 20 March 2003 Monday night's 15-minute speech by President Bush, setting a 48-hour deadline

Re: Re: The politics underlying the war

2003-03-20 Thread Waistline2
In a message dated 3/20/03 5:10:34 AM Pacific Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: To the contrary, a "pacifist" (in the sense of being opposed to the right of the imperialists to make war) position is the only one that principled Marxists, radicals and progressives can put forward. As far

ICJ declares Iraq war illegal

2003-03-20 Thread k hanly
International Commission of Jurists (Geneva) http://www.icj.org/news.php3?id_article=2770lang=en Iraq - ICJ Deplores Moves Toward a War of Aggression on Iraq / La CIJ déplore l'annonce d'une guerre d'agression contre l'Irak / La CIJ lamenta los anuncios de una guerra de agresion contra Irak

Re: profile in courage

2003-03-20 Thread Bill Lear
On Thursday, March 20, 2003 at 09:16:50 (-0800) Devine, James writes: I couldn't find the specific reference in today's L.A. TIMES, but on the front page there was a small picture of Bush with something like the following, from memory: President Bush showed his fist and said I feel great. Sort

Re: Re: profile in courage

2003-03-20 Thread Doug Henwood
Bill Lear wrote: Sort of like Truman's exclamation that the day of the bombing of Hiroshima was the greatest day in history? And didn't Dean Acheson say the weeks following the beginning of the Korean War were the most glorious in history? Doug

Re: Re: Re: Re: 535 members of Congress and ...

2003-03-20 Thread Eugene Coyle
I don't know what the situation was during the Korean police action. It was close in time to WWII when romantic patriotism still ran high. And it was a time when the draft was scooping up in ways less preferential (though still preferential) than during Vietnam. And this is just a feeling,

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: the nature of the war

2003-03-20 Thread Alan Jacobson
Having looked at the PNAC website.. Man, oh man, talk about a cabal. Brings to mind the Stonecutters' Song from the Simpsons: Who controls the British crown? Who keeps the metric system down? We do! We do! Who leaves Atlantis off the maps? Who keeps the martians under wraps? We do! We do! Who

Pre-emptive attack against General Assembly meeting

2003-03-20 Thread k hanly
I have head absolutely nothing about this in the mainstream media... Cheers, Ken Hanly ZNet | Iraq Uniting For Peace Russian Duma, Many Others, Call For Un uniting For Peace by Jeremy Brecher; March 20, 2003 US LAUNCHES PREEMPTIVE ATTACK AGAINST UN GENERAL ASSEMBLY All over the world,

demonstration in London

2003-03-20 Thread Chris Burford
Parliament Square was packed this evening. The demonstration had been going on since midday, and with people coming and going there could have been tens of thousands who took part throughout the day. The Guardian reported 5,000 by 3:15pm. The mood was like that on Feb 15 but more serious.

Re: 535 members of Congress and ...

2003-03-20 Thread Devine, James
Title: Re: 535 members of Congress and ... Gene writes: this is just a feeling, but it seems Congress itself was more like the US, i. e. some real people and fewer blow-dried creatures of polls and corporate money. I'm afraid that back in the good old days, it was just a different kind

Re: Re: 535 members of Congress and ...

2003-03-20 Thread andie nachgeborenen
I'm afraid that back in the "good old days," it was just a different kind of a sleaze-bag, like the small-town businesscritter who's gone to Congress... people like Truman. And small businesspeople are most often _less_ progressive than the corporate types. Independence, MO (HTS's hometown and

Jazz corruption.

2003-03-20 Thread Devine, James
is there a correlation between corruption and jazz? it makes sense for Chicago and New Orleans... what is the explanation of this correlation, if it exists? why doesn't this correlation work for rock n roll, or does it? did it work for Baroque music, back when Bach was hot? If the

Re: Jazz corruption.

2003-03-20 Thread Gil Skillman
For what it's worth, I think the original connection went corruption--brothels and speakeasies and underground clubs--jazz and sometimes blues. A prominent source of corruption was Prohibition, during which jazz was the hot dance music of the day. Nowadays corruption has no particular

profile in courage (corrected)

2003-03-20 Thread Devine, James
Title: profile in courage (corrected) from today's [3/20/03] L.A. TIMES, page 3 (Decision comes at Marathon Meeting by Maura Reynolds): Just before he went on the air, as aides were applying makeup, Bush was seen pumping his fist and telling an aide, Feel good. Jim

Re: profile in courage (corrected)

2003-03-20 Thread Michael Perelman
Sounds like a beer commercial. On Thu, Mar 20, 2003 at 05:23:15PM -0800, Devine, James wrote: from today's [3/20/03] L.A. TIMES, page 3 (Decision comes at Marathon Meeting by Maura Reynolds): Just before he went on the air, as aides were applying makeup, Bush was seen pumping his fist and

paul craig roberts on Bush

2003-03-20 Thread Michael Perelman
http://www.washtimes.com/commentary/20030320-75800736.htm Roberts was a very conservative Reagan Treasury dept economist, who taught at Haavaaard I recall. -- Michael Perelman Economics Department California State University Chico, CA 95929 Tel. 530-898-5321 E-Mail [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Sacramento anti-war action, 3/20

2003-03-20 Thread Seth Sandronsky
March 20, 2003 7 p.m. PST Sacramento, CA Hi All, My wife and I just returned from a rally and demo against the U.S.-led attack on Iraq, held at 16th J Streets in Sacramento. About 500 people attended, including many youth of color. One group of students had attended an anti-war rally at

Re: profile in courage (corrected)

2003-03-20 Thread Dan Scanlan
Title: Re: [PEN-L:35826] profile in courage (corrected) from today's [3/20/03] L.A. TIMES, page 3 (Decision comes at Marathon Meeting by Maura Reynolds): Just before he went on the air, as aides were applying makeup, Bush was seen pumping his fist and telling an aide, Feel good. I always

RE: paul craig roberts on Bush

2003-03-20 Thread Max B. Sawicky
He's a combination of nativist, racist, isolationist, and free marketeer. He's also part of this weird VDARE site. I forget how I happened across it. http://www.vdare.com/ (take it away, Pugliese!) mbs http://www.washtimes.com/commentary/20030320-75800736.htm Roberts was a very

Re: RE: paul craig roberts on Bush

2003-03-20 Thread Michael Perelman
He also had a column in Business Week for years and was one of the mainstays of the Wall Street Journal ed. page during the heyday of supply side economics. -- Michael Perelman Economics Department California State University Chico, CA 95929 Tel. 530-898-5321 E-Mail [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: Re: RE: Re: Zizek's latest

2003-03-20 Thread Ian Murray
- Original Message - From: Louis Proyect [EMAIL PROTECTED] Devine, James wrote: BTW, I wish that people wouldn't attack this fellow Zizek as a way to attack other people on pen-l. This Aesopian way of writing produces such bizarre events as when I criticized Stalin a month or

Re: Re: RE: Re: Re: quiet... too quiet

2003-03-20 Thread Ian Murray
- Original Message - From: Peter Dorman [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, March 19, 2003 9:25 AM Subject: [PEN-L:35760] Re: RE: Re: Re: quiet... too quiet The big obstacle to overcome on the left is, to put it very bluntly, nationalism.

Norman Schwarzkopf meets Ghandi

2003-03-20 Thread Ian Murray
The loss of one human life is one too many 4 minutes ago on MSNBC

RE: Re: profile in courage (corrected)

2003-03-20 Thread Devine, James
Title: RE: [PEN-L:35827] Re: profile in courage (corrected) here's to good wars... -Original Message- From: Michael Perelman To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: 3/20/2003 5:56 PM Subject: [PEN-L:35827] Re: profile in courage (corrected) Sounds like a beer commercial. On Thu, Mar 20,

RE: Re: profile in courage (corrected)

2003-03-20 Thread Devine, James
Title: RE: [PEN-L:35831] Re: profile in courage (corrected) Dan writes: I always suspected Clinton of being something other than what he claimed to be, especially when he said he tried pot but didn't inhale. (The more significant question would have been, of course, Did you drop acid?)

Re: Re: Re: Saddam's apparatus of terror........

2003-03-20 Thread Ian Murray
- Original Message - From: Ian Murray [EMAIL PROTECTED] When I was eleven-twelve in '72-'73, living in San Diego at the US Naval Hospital at the edge of Balboa Park, my dad was in charge of receiving large numbers of Vets and making sure that they had a sympathetic welcome mat and

Marriage Made in Heaven

2003-03-20 Thread michael perelman
Richard Perle is now advising Global Crossing. http://www.nytimes.com/2003/03/21/business/21GLOB.html -- Michael Perelman Economics Department California State University Chico, CA 95929 Tel. 530-898-5321 E-Mail [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Politics of Oil for Food Account

2003-03-20 Thread k hanly
[ Presenting plain-text part of multi-format email ] http://www.moscowtimes.ru/stories/2003/03/20/042.html Thursday, Mar. 20, 2003. Page 7 Report: U.S. Plans to Tap $40Bln Iraq Account More than $40 billion from Iraqi crude sales are sitting in an escrow account controlled by the United

Re: Article on Illegality of Iraq war

2003-03-20 Thread Michael Pollak
On Wed, 19 Mar 2003, k hanly quoted a CESR report stating: It is the height of hypocrisy for the U.S. and U.K. to base war on Resolution 1441 when they are fully aware that France, Russia and China approved that resolution on explicit written condition that it could not be used by individual

Re: Politics of Oil for Food Account

2003-03-20 Thread Chris Burford
It was some consolation to hear Tony Blair in his speech to the nation on UK tv last night emphasise that Iraqi oil would be put in a trust fund for the Iraqi people. But there is a slight snag. This should be their resource anyway. Why should it be used to pay for the economic costs of a war

EU warns Turkey

2003-03-20 Thread Chris Burford
The EU has warned Turkey not to send troops into northern Iraq, where the Kurds have autonomy. This is an example of an imperialist move, for imperialist reasons, which in the concrete situation, is progressive. It is progressive because it reduces the risk of harm to the unity of the working

Re: The politics underlying the war

2003-03-20 Thread Chris Burford
At 2003-03-20 08:10 -0500, Louis Proyect wrote: Chris Burford wrote: We will see how the peace movement responds and evolves, and we can each make our personally minuscule contribution to the debate. Peace now, or Cease fire now, may remain the main slogans, but a purely pacifist position will

Re: Jazz corruption.

2003-03-20 Thread andie nachgeborenen
Jazz and corruption: Jazz (the term is old slang for sex, as in "jazz me baby") was originally New Orleans whorehouse music, based in the "protected" red light district of Storyville, shut down in an abortive effort at protective the morals of servicemen in WWII, thus distributing the music all

Old and new media

2003-03-20 Thread Louis Proyect
While coming back from a dental appointment on the number one train to Columbia University, I noticed somebody begin speaking in the middle of the car, Ladies and Gentleman, may I have your attention... Since he was dressed reasonably well, I wondered why he would be forced to beg--fully

Open Letter to G. William Domhoff

2003-03-20 Thread Louis Proyect
Dear Bill, I hope you don't mind me writing you out of the blue like this, but scruffy sans-culotte Marxists like myself don't have much other recourse besides the Internet when it comes to answering Professor Emeritus types like yourself. In the last few days you have come into my radar

G. William Domhoff replies

2003-03-20 Thread Louis Proyect
Bill Domhoff wrote: for a Marxist, you don't seem to have much appreciation for structure, except of course in the economyat least so I gather from reading your last paragraphthe recent I didn't waste my time on...but your arrogance is breath taking, of course, and what else is new, and