Re: [PERFORM] Adaptec/LSI/?? RAID

2005-06-03 Thread Cosimo Streppone
Stacy White wrote: We're in the process of buying another Opteron server to run Postgres, and based on the suggestions in this list I've asked our IT director to get an LSI MegaRaid controller rather than one of the Adaptecs. But when we tried to place our order, our vendor (Penguin Computing)

Re: [PERFORM] Adaptec/LSI/?? RAID

2005-06-02 Thread Andrew McMillan
On Wed, 2005-06-01 at 20:42 -0700, Stacy White wrote: We're in the process of buying another Opteron server to run Postgres, and based on the suggestions in this list I've asked our IT director to get an LSI MegaRaid controller rather than one of the Adaptecs. But when we tried to place our

Re: [PERFORM] Adaptec/LSI/?? RAID

2005-06-02 Thread Richard Welty
On Wed, 01 Jun 2005 22:00:09 -0700 William Yu [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I've previously stayed away from Adaptec because we used to run Solaris x86 and the driver was somewhat buggy. For Linux and FreeBSD, I'd be less worried as open source development of drivers usually lead to better

Re: [PERFORM] Adaptec/LSI/?? RAID

2005-06-02 Thread J. Andrew Rogers
I've got a bunch of mission-critical Postgres servers on Opterons, all with no less than 4GB RAM, running Linux + XFS, and most with LSI MegaRAID cards. We've never had a single system crash or failure on our postgres servers, and some of them are well-used and with uptimes in excess of a

Re: [PERFORM] Adaptec/LSI/?? RAID

2005-06-02 Thread Joshua D. Drake
It may be anecdotal, but LSI MegaRAID cards generally seem to work pretty well with Linux. The only problem I've ever seen was a BIOS problem between the LSI and the motherboard, which was solved by flashing the BIOS on the motherboard with the latest version (it was grossly out of date

Re: [PERFORM] Adaptec/LSI/?? RAID

2005-06-02 Thread Vivek Khera
On Jun 1, 2005, at 11:42 PM, Stacy White wrote: we find LSI does not work well with 4GB of RAM. Our engineering find that LSI card could cause system crashes. One of our customer ... has found that Adaptec cards works well on PostGres SQL -- they're using it as a preforce server with xfs

Re: [PERFORM] Adaptec/LSI/?? RAID (what about JBOD?)

2005-06-02 Thread mudfoot
I have a similar question about what to choose (either LSI or Adaptec U320), but plan to use them just for JBOD drivers. I expect to be using either net or freebsd. The system CPU will be Opteron. My impression is that both the ahd and mpt drivers (for U320 Adaptec and LSI, respectively) are

Re: [PERFORM] Adaptec/LSI/?? RAID (what about JBOD?)

2005-06-02 Thread Andrew McMillan
On Thu, 2005-06-02 at 14:02 -0700, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I have a similar question about what to choose (either LSI or Adaptec U320), but plan to use them just for JBOD drivers. I expect to be using either net or freebsd. The system CPU will be Opteron. My impression is that both the

Re: [PERFORM] Adaptec/LSI/?? RAID (what about JBOD?)

2005-06-02 Thread mudfoot
Thanks, Andrew. I expect to choose between HBAs with no RAID functionality or with the option to completely bypass RAID functionality--meaning that I'll hopefully avoid the situation that you've described. I'm mostly curious as to whether the driver problems described for U320 Adaptec RAID

[PERFORM] Adaptec/LSI/?? RAID

2005-06-01 Thread Stacy White
We're in the process of buying another Opteron server to run Postgres, and based on the suggestions in this list I've asked our IT director to get an LSI MegaRaid controller rather than one of the Adaptecs. But when we tried to place our order, our vendor (Penguin Computing) advised us: we find

Re: [PERFORM] Adaptec/LSI/?? RAID

2005-06-01 Thread Sven Willenberger
Stacy White presumably uttered the following on 06/01/05 23:42: We're in the process of buying another Opteron server to run Postgres, and based on the suggestions in this list I've asked our IT director to get an LSI MegaRaid controller rather than one of the Adaptecs. But when we tried to

Re: [PERFORM] Adaptec/LSI/?? RAID

2005-06-01 Thread William Yu
I've used LSI MegaRAIDs successfully in the following systems with both Redhat 9 and FC3 64bit. Arima HDAMA/8GB RAM Tyan S2850/4GB RAM Tyan S2881/4GB RAM I've previously stayed away from Adaptec because we used to run Solaris x86 and the driver was somewhat buggy. For Linux and FreeBSD, I'd