[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-04 Thread Earl Grey
Yeah, I've heard/read that, too, somewhere, but it don't make sense to me. The brake bridge looks to me like a pre-manufactured piece that gets brazed in place after its holes have already been made. I assume that the frame gets held at some point by this brake bridge, but how one extra little

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-04 Thread Tim McNamara
My 1996 Waterford-built All-Rounder has a fender mount under the brake bridge, so the issue is not that they are not capable of doing it. If they are using a solid cast brake bridge, that may be the issue- there is nowhere for the end of the bolt to go. The bridge on my A/R is a bit of

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-04 Thread eflayer
can we say Grant is a marketing expert? And he creates fine bikes and he is not afraid to throw the noodles against the wall and see what sticks? 650B and double top tubes fit in there somewhere. To me the single sloping top tube, lugged Sam is the cat's pajamas...whatever that means. Richard

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-04 Thread mr.trout
i think i have a second generation sam. when i was ordering it i was talking to dave, i think, and we were talking about fit. i was trying to decide stem length and he mentioned that the top tube on this frame was a cm shorter than on the previous generation. if i measure the effective tt on

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-03 Thread Earl Grey
Not sure about the Sam forks. I think the Hunqa forks were supposed to be Toyo-built. That said, I have a first run (Taiwanese?) Sam (bought Sept 09), which has the 3 dot fork crown, slender fork blades, and cantilevers (but has the seatstay bridge with the hole underneath for direct fender

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-03 Thread Thomas Lynn Skean
Saw somewhere on the group that Waterford's frame-building process involved holding the frame in such a way as to make it difficult to drill and/or thread the fender 'boss under the bridge. Merely parroting; I don't know enough to know whether this makes sense. But I do like appearing

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-02 Thread Philip Williamson
Really? You can't tell that you have a full bottle on your bike? It feels like an extra pound. I feel it when I'm out of the saddle. I don't feel like a princess and the pea kind of rider, but my bike feels different with a full bottle. I can feel 175mm cranks, or 25mm tires instead of 28s. I

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-02 Thread Michael_S
I must be an insensitive lug then, because I certainly do not notice a 7.29 oz difference ( 28oz bottle 3/4 full vrs full) which is .45 lb. For me that is a .2% difference in total bike +rider weight. I still find the 2nd parallel top tube unappealing visually. Must be that aging SoCal hipster

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-02 Thread cm
I really like to double TT. I liked it when brought it in on the bigger bikes and like the function of it. I like it even more on the smaller bikes (56 SH) where it could be argued that there is no real function. What's cooler than a few extra lugs and a spare tt? I also really like that Waterford

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-01 Thread William
I'll vote (kind of). I'm surprised at how close the weights are. I think the double TT looks cool, and I'd find useful. On BART I have to grab hard on the seat tube to portage the bike up stairs, because I'd get a handful of frame pump if I grabbed the TT. A second TT would be a portage handle

Re: [RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-01 Thread Bruce
Did I read somewhere that the Maxway frame uses a Toyo built fork? Toyo did a fine job on prior forks, so one wonders why the one pictured by Bryan seems stockier. To be honest, both bikes look great to me. I like the paint on the Maxway a bit better, but agree that the Waterford crown is

Re: [RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-01 Thread Bill Connell
I also thought that someone else (not Maxway) was doing the forks, but can't remember who. Given that the lugs appear identical otherwise, i'm surprised in the differences in the forks, especially that the canti version seems to have narrower tapered legs. The fork bend looks the same on both,

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-01 Thread William
The Single TT one (Maxway?) has no BB cable guide installed!! Send it back! The Double TT one has a seatstay bridge that is not threaded underneath for a fender!! Send it back! On Sep 1, 12:14 pm, Bill Connell bconn...@gmail.com wrote: I also thought that someone else (not Maxway) was doing

Re: [RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-01 Thread Bill Connell
Indeed - I'd be happy to dispose of them properly, just email directly for my shipping address :-) Bill On Wed, Sep 1, 2010 at 2:35 PM, William tapebu...@gmail.com wrote: The Single TT one (Maxway?) has no BB cable guide installed!!  Send it back! The Double TT one has a seatstay bridge that

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-01 Thread bfd
On Sep 1, 11:04 am, Bryan @ Renaissance Bicycles renaissancebicyc...@gmail.com wrote: In the Shop we happen to have two 56cm Hillbornes.  One is the Taiwanese made Maxway, the other is the Waterford version from WI. Of course, we couldn't help but take

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-01 Thread bfd
On Sep 1, 11:04 am, Bryan @ Renaissance Bicycles renaissancebicyc...@gmail.com wrote: In the Shop we happen to have two 56cm Hillbornes.  One is the Taiwanese made Maxway, the other is the Waterford version from WI. Of course, we couldn't help but take

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-01 Thread William
but what's the purpose? obviously to protect the frame pump and to allow me to carry up the Bart stairs more easily Duh On Sep 1, 11:35 am, bfd bfd...@gmail.com wrote: On Sep 1, 11:04 am, Bryan @ Renaissance Bicycles renaissancebicyc...@gmail.com wrote: In the Shop we happen to have two

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-01 Thread Peter Pesce
I really don't know why Riv has to go and make multiple different versions of this bike. Yes, I know the only answer that matters is because Grant wants to but even HE has to expend lots of unnecessary energy explaining to people why one version is, allegedly, as good as the other. Just when he

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-01 Thread JoelMatthews
Alan at EcoVelo has a 60cm Maxway Sam with cantis and what will, now, forever hence be known as the nice fork; I have a 60cm Maxway Sam with sidepulls and what will forever hence be known as the crappy fork. What qualities of Alan's fork make it better than yours? On Sep 1, 4:12 pm, Peter

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-01 Thread cm
I dont think calling it a crappy fork is fair. I have a Bleriot (obviously Taiwanese) and I dont think there is a crappy thing about it. Riv had supply problems with taiwan and needed another builder. G goes into it in some detail on the site. Seems like a new builder would be a great time to try

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-01 Thread Michael_S
I own a 56cm Maxway canti Sam with the 3 spot fork crown and my bike is plenty stiff enough for off road endeavors. I originally had 70x40 knobbies on it and took it on very technical singletrack quite a few times... It never felt anything other than solid. and for the record... I like both

Re: [RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-01 Thread Bill Connell
It sometimes happens that a bike model will have changes over the run - the Romulus and Saluki are other examples where there was a change in brake type. The Sam is a little unusual in that it was caught in production issues just as it was ramping up, so there was undoubtedly some scrambling to

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-01 Thread Johnny Alien
I also prefer the fork crown on the double tt model. Although I tend to like sidepulls better than canti's. I also really like the trademark double tt look but sadly I ride smaller size frames and will never be able to own one. On Sep 1, 5:43 pm, Bill Connell bconn...@gmail.com wrote: It

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-01 Thread Peter Pesce
Sorry, I was being intentionally melodramatic with the crappy comment! Poor choice of words. I have been exceedingly happy with my bike, my first Riv, and actually had the option of getting a Waterford frame at the time. I liked the sidepulls and single top tube, so I took the Maxway. No

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-01 Thread William
is a feature, not a bug! you must work with software. haha. We say that all the time at work. I think the Maxway crown is really cool. I just fell in love with the curly crown on mine which is also on the Waterford. The fatter lower fork blades are what I thought was chunky, but even when I

Re: [RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-01 Thread Steve Palincsar
On Wed, 2010-09-01 at 16:43 -0500, Bill Connell wrote: It sometimes happens that a bike model will have changes over the run - the Romulus and Saluki are other examples where there was a change in brake type. If you're thinking of the Centerpulluki and the Cantiluki versions of the Saluki,

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-01 Thread doug peterson
Because I know people will ask ... the weight difference between the frames is 8 ounces. For perspective, that is about the difference between a full water bottle and one that is 3/4 full. Now that puts the weight in real terms. I defy anyone to tell the difference in how their bike performs

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-01 Thread EricP
My first run Hillborne has a different crown than either of those. Think it might have been the same as the Romulus. Otherwise, I do like the one on the Waterford made version. Then again, noticed that the Atlantis forks have changed over the years. While I do like the new ones, and have seen

Re: [RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-01 Thread Robert F. Harrison
I'm slower with an empty bottle because I'm looking around for someplace to fill up. Stands to reason! :-) Bob On Wed, Sep 1, 2010 at 2:34 PM, doug peterson dougpn...@cox.net wrote: Because I know people will ask ... the weight difference between the frames is 8 ounces. For perspective,

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-01 Thread EcoVelo
I think it's cool that these various iterations of the Hillborne are out there - keeps it interesting. Mine is a single top tube 60cm Maxway with cantis and the fork shown on the Waterford in Bryan's photos. It might be just a tad flexy for some people, but it feels just right under my 160 lb. I'd

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-01 Thread Angus
Beautiful pictures of two beautiful frames Bryan...thank you. Two or one...I'll take one thanks. Angus On Sep 1, 1:04 pm, Bryan @ Renaissance Bicycles renaissancebicyc...@gmail.com wrote: In the Shop we happen to have two 56cm Hillbornes.  One is the Taiwanese made Maxway, the other is the

[RBW] Re: 1 Toptube or 2 -- Comparing the Two Versions of the Hillborne

2010-09-01 Thread SFF
One more variable: I have a single top tube - 60cm - orange - Waterford with the 3 dot fork...but my three dots didn't get the offset color, they were painted orange. I think this was a very early Waterford with a painting error. Any others out there like this? Oh well. Joel On Sep 1, 8:44 pm,