Re: [RBW] When to Abandon a Bike Project and Move On

2020-12-24 Thread Collin A
Thanks everyone for your thoughts and ideas. I think I will terminate the project, just trying to make too many things happen at once. I did have this bike built up before and it rode nicely, so there isn't too much of a need to do a "good enough" build for the time being. Luckily most of the

Re: [RBW] When to Abandon a Bike Project and Move On

2020-12-24 Thread Ryan M.
IMHO, when you start talking about adding canti posts, it's time for a different frame. On Wednesday, December 23, 2020 at 12:43:43 PM UTC-6 Collin A wrote: > Ok, so short story long: > > Bought a cool looking steel frame from a local shop that was built as part > of a small-batch of

Re: [RBW] When to Abandon a Bike Project and Move On

2020-12-23 Thread Philip Williamson
This is my thinking as well. Build up a rideable bike, and don’t worry about the “perfect.” When I saw you’d traded away a Minimoto, I thought, “Well there’s your problem right there.” If you went fixed, that’s all you’d even need. Cantis or Vs would be fine, brake levers and fixie wheels are

Re: [RBW] When to Abandon a Bike Project and Move On

2020-12-23 Thread Eric Daume
It doesn't seem like you're that far off, just a few hours of wrenching and you would have a rideable bike. Canti front, R559 rear, as a trial, and use an existing rear wheel (if you have it) with spacer for the single speed. Sometimes "good enough" is better than "just right." Eric On Wed, Dec

Re: [RBW] When to Abandon a Bike Project and Move On

2020-12-23 Thread Brian Witt
Wow! timely question! i am abandoning a project that stalled for a couple years. I collected parts and then sourced a used frame that just wont accommodate the running gear properly. and changes in my needs/ wants / physical abilities have now made the bike (even if finished) not very

Re: [RBW] When to Abandon a Bike Project and Move On

2020-12-23 Thread Jason Fuller
Thanks for the background; now it does sound like a square peg, round hole situation in terms of fitting your needs - and since you can find just about any combination of features you want these days in a steel frame, it does seem a bit like you're taking the scenic route. Still, could be cool to

Re: [RBW] When to Abandon a Bike Project and Move On

2020-12-23 Thread Garth
Well you know Collin that'd be like Me saying I'm quitting bike riding because it's winter and I don't feel like bike riding today. On Wednesday, December 23, 2020 at 11:57:18 AM UTC-5 Lucky wrote: > Well, you’ll have to tell us more about the project. > Also, thanks for the Cycle Cats rec! >

Re: [RBW] When to Abandon a Bike Project and Move On

2020-12-23 Thread 'Eric Norris' via RBW Owners Bunch
+1 on not trying to turn a sports car into a pickup truck. --Eric Norris campyonly...@me.com Insta: @CampyOnlyGuy YouTube: YouTube.com/CampyOnlyGuy > On Dec 23, 2020, at 11:26 AM, Jay Lonner wrote: > > Sounds to me like you’re trying to transform the bike into something it > isn’t, and I

Re: [RBW] When to Abandon a Bike Project and Move On

2020-12-23 Thread Jay Lonner
Sounds to me like you’re trying to transform the bike into something it isn’t, and I doubt that a new fork, adding canti posts, crimping the stays, etc. will alter that fundamental fact. I’d ditch it and start over with something that meets your needs without requiring such extensive

Re: [RBW] When to Abandon a Bike Project and Move On

2020-12-23 Thread Collin A
Scott, that's exactly why I am thinking about abandonment now...I've already spent so much time and effort and normally i'd think "what's a bit more" but I've been screwed by that approach in the past (which eventually prompted an involuntary career switch). Patrick/Jason, I agree that taking

Re: [RBW] When to Abandon a Bike Project and Move On

2020-12-23 Thread greenteadrinkers
Might be worth reading up on Sunk Cost Fallacy: https://time.com/5347133/sunk-cost-fallacy-decisions/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunk_cost Scott On Wednesday, December 23, 2020 at 1:43:43 PM UTC-5 Collin A wrote: > Ok, so short story long: > > Bought a cool looking steel frame from a local

Re: [RBW] When to Abandon a Bike Project and Move On

2020-12-23 Thread Patrick Moore
As someone who very easily gets frustrated when things don't happen fast, I've found that abandoning a project temporarily, say for 1 or 3 or 6 months, can bring me back with interest to the project. So the question is, is the project really valuable to you; IOW, would the result really be useful

Re: [RBW] When to Abandon a Bike Project and Move On

2020-12-23 Thread Collin A
Ok, so short story long: Bought a cool looking steel frame from a local shop that was built as part of a small-batch of prototypes for a project that never got off the ground. This was bought when I made the move from the hilly Bay Area to the flatlands of Sacramento, so I initially started

Re: [RBW] When to Abandon a Bike Project and Move On

2020-12-23 Thread Jason Fuller
Agree that knowing the project base would go a long way in understanding how good the potential end result would be! I am generally pretty impatient when I get a new project going but bear in mind there are still new-in-box Rivs from the mid-2000's popping up every now and again - there is no

Re: [RBW] When to Abandon a Bike Project and Move On

2020-12-23 Thread luckyturnip
Well, you’ll have to tell us more about the project. Also, thanks for the Cycle Cats rec! > On Dec 23, 2020, at 08:50, Collin A wrote: > > Short story, I have a frame and fork I want to build up, but with the COVID > supply issues, and the rising costs of the project to reach completion, I am

[RBW] When to Abandon a Bike Project and Move On

2020-12-23 Thread Collin A
Short story, I have a frame and fork I want to build up, but with the COVID supply issues, and the rising costs of the project to reach completion, I am starting to consider ending the project and selling the parts I have been saving it for to try and recoup some of the costs. For those that