Office Documents

2010-07-28 Thread Madhavi
Hi, Is there a way to create Review Request for MS Office documents such as Doc, Xls etc ? -Madhavi -- Want to help the Review Board project? Donate today at http://www.reviewboard.org/donate/ Happy user? Let us know at http://www.reviewboard.org/users/ -~--~~~~--~~

Re: Office Documents

2010-07-28 Thread hero alfa
I have the same question, but not only for office docs, how the reviewboard would beehive if a binary file was changed? BR/Vincent 2010/7/28 Madhavi > Hi, > > Is there a way to create Review Request for MS Office documents such > as Doc, Xls etc ? > > -Madhavi > > -- > Want to help the Review B

Re: Office Documents

2010-07-28 Thread Jan Koprowski
All what I saw in ReviewBoard is checkbox that file is binary (somewhere in admin panel) but this is all. Maybe this is background to implement hexadecimal review mode. On Wed, Jul 28, 2010 at 11:25 AM, hero alfa wrote: > I have the same question, but not only for office docs, how the reviewboard

Re: Office Documents

2010-07-28 Thread Christian Hammond
Review Board was built around reviewing source code, not binary files or complex document formats. It must be something that can be represented in a diff file. If a binary file (whether an image, binary blob, XLS file, or whatever) is part of a diff, it won't actually be able to provide any informa

Re: Office Documents

2010-07-28 Thread Madhavi
Thanks Christian. What I am looking for is apart from reviewing the code, reviewing documents such as spec doc, design doc etc. So main requirement was for .doc files. Regards -Madhavi On Jul 28, 2:31 pm, Christian Hammond wrote: > Review Board was built around reviewing source code, not binary

Re: Office Documents

2010-07-28 Thread Jan Koprowski
Solution is use some document format using i/e markdown syntax or something. On Wed, Jul 28, 2010 at 11:46 AM, Madhavi wrote: > Thanks Christian. > > What I am looking for is apart from reviewing the code, reviewing > documents such as spec doc, design doc etc. So main requirement was > for .doc

Re: Office Documents

2010-07-28 Thread Stephen Gallagher
On 07/28/2010 05:46 AM, Madhavi wrote: > Thanks Christian. > > What I am looking for is apart from reviewing the code, reviewing > documents such as spec doc, design doc etc. So main requirement was > for .doc files. It sounds like what you really want to be doing is setting up a content manageme

How to push a review checked as "Submitted" to the main repository?

2010-07-28 Thread Diego G. Pasqualin
Hi, first of all thanks for the ReviewBoard, it is what I was looking for months! I work at C3SL (we are mirror of sourceforge.net, ubuntu and many others) and we have some projects with a large amount of patchs per day. You certainly know how difficult is to handle this using just e-mails. Well,

Re: How to push a review checked as "Submitted" to the main repository?

2010-07-28 Thread David Trowbridge
Review Board doesn't provide any way to push to the repository because it's actually a really hard problem (re: authentication credentials, ownership, and merging out-of-date patches). We expect that after a patch is reviewed, either the author or reviewer will then push it into the repository usin

Re: How to push a review checked as "Submitted" to the main repository?

2010-07-28 Thread Diego G. Pasqualin
I don't know about others versioning systems and I could be wrong, but I guess that with git this might not be so hard. For the authentication method and ownership a public key could be used and configured for each repository added to ReviewBoard. Also, git has their own way to merge patches, and a

Re: How to push a review checked as "Submitted" to the main repository?

2010-07-28 Thread Jan Koprowski
I'm working on rbshell project: http://github.com/jankoprowski/rbshell which should help applying patches from ReviewBoard to repository. Unfortunelty I don't have much time to end this project but I hope so soon I find few days to push forward. On Thu, Jul 29, 2010 at 3:10 AM, Diego G. Pasqualin