Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2021-03-08 Thread RobbH
d6jg wrote: > Looking at this another way your requirement is fulfilled partly by > creating a specific playlist of the pseudo album. > > Two things stop a playlist approach from working exactly as you would > want. > > 1) Playlists do not appear in your Album list - but I imagine that if a >

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2021-03-08 Thread RobbH
philchillbill wrote: > If you’re any good with scripting languages like bash or PowerShell or > even Perl or Python, this should be pretty easy to automate. Indeed, I'm working on a Bash script that simplifies the process. If I'm every satisfied with it, I'll share it, in case anybody else is

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2021-03-08 Thread d6jg
RobbH wrote: > You suggested that a few pages back, and I acknowledged at the time that > it was foolish of me to be offended by the inefficiency of that > approach. It still is, and I still am. > > But thanks for continuing to serve as a voice of sanity. It's helpful, > even when rejected.

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2021-03-07 Thread philchillbill
RobbH wrote: > Four months after I mentioned that LMS 8+ now supports cue files that > point to multiple audio source files, I have finally done a test with > encouraging results. IF your OS and filesystem both support symlinks, it > is now possible to have tracks in a box set appear in your

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2021-03-06 Thread RobbH
d6jg wrote: > Why not just have 2 copies of the files tagged as necessary? Storage is > hardly an issue these days. You suggested that a few pages back, and I acknowledged at the time that it was foolish of me to be offended by the inefficiency of that approach. It still is, and I still am.

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2021-03-06 Thread d6jg
RobbH wrote: > Four months after I mentioned that LMS 8+ now supports cue files that > point to multiple audio source files, I have finally done a test with > encouraging results. IF your OS and filesystem both support symlinks, it > is now possible to have tracks in a box set appear in your

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2021-03-06 Thread RobbH
Four months after I mentioned that LMS 8+ now supports cue files that point to multiple audio source files, I have finally done a test with encouraging results. IF your OS and filesystem both support symlinks, it is now possible to have tracks in a box set appear in your library in two places:

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2020-11-08 Thread BJW
As a one time radio DJ and collector I have spent countless hours, much like those of u reading this, listening to CD after CD, and I am often shocked to find a song on one CD release sounds clearly audibly different from the same song on another release. This presents a problem when building

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2020-11-04 Thread RobbH
RobbH wrote: > I still hope someone will find a way to make LMS work with > multi-file cue sheets, since that would be a much more satisfactory > solution. A recent changelog for LMS8 includes this item: PR #434 - Support for multiple FILE commands in CUE sheets (thanks oleg-kuh!) In my

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2019-09-28 Thread RobbH
Pauke wrote: > It is good news that you don't have same problem as I. Maybe I still > have hope. I must rethink if I made mistake somewhere. > Anyway, thank you for this great idea! Good luck to you! If you manage to get it to work for you, I hope you'll post about it here. I still hope

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2019-09-27 Thread Pauke
RobbH wrote: > I wish I knew enough to offer some advice, but I do not. All I can say > is that this is not what I'm seeing on Linux (Debian) with music on a > drive formatted as ext4. That's based on what I see under the "Artists" > and "Albums" items in the "My Music" menu, where I find both

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2019-09-27 Thread RobbH
Pauke wrote: > I tried this solution, but I could not get it work properly. I tried > this with Duke Ellington's Centennial edition box which contains 24 > CD's. CD #18 contains 13 tracks which are taken from 'Concert of Sacred > Music' album. So I created 13 cue files and executed complete

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2019-09-02 Thread RobbH
Continuing on the subject of using one cue file per track to create a separate album from the tracks included in a box set, one significant obstacle is the number of cue files that have to be created, especially if it's all done by hand. Being lazy, I have written a Bash script that assists in

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2019-09-02 Thread RobbH
What, nobody's excited about this? :p Never mind! I totally understand that this is a very niche subject. And may be my "discovery" is something that was already well known. But I didn't find any information about doing this when I searched. The one cue file per track method I described in the

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2019-08-29 Thread RobbH
Three months after my previous post, I have to say that the workaround I described then is not very satisfactory to me. If I do want to access the discs as released in the box set, they are available by browsing the music folder, as stated. However, it is not an easy or pleasant task to select

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2019-05-25 Thread RobbH
Clearly, having multiple copies of the identical file in different folders and with different album tags and different track numbers is the best solution. But the inefficiency of that offends me, for some reason. (It's not necessarily logical. It's not as though I'm remarkably efficient in

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2019-05-25 Thread w3wilkes
Seems that the easiest think would be 2 copies. One as individual albums, the other as a multidisc album. The multidisc would have all songs in the same folder with a common Album title. File names for the tracks would be something like "Disc# Track# Track title" and include Disc# in the tags.

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2019-05-24 Thread d6jg
RobbH wrote: > This old thread covers the question I was about to ask in a new thread, > but my emphasis is slightly different from the previous discussion. > > Consider a Mosaic box set, "The Complete Columbia Studio Recordings of > the Miles Davis Quintet 1965-June 1968." It contains the

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2019-05-24 Thread RobbH
This old thread covers the question I was about to ask in a new thread, but my emphasis is slightly different from the previous discussion. Consider a Mosaic box set, "The Complete Columbia Studio Recordings of the Miles Davis Quintet 1965-June 1968." It contains the following albums in their

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-21 Thread d6jg
w3wilkes wrote: > Sorry about OT. - Most excellent album! Didn't know there was a LP+, > what are the bonus tracks? It was in a recent ish box set containing all their studio albums iirc Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk *Pi3 with piCoreplayer music on QNAP TS419p via NFS*

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-20 Thread emalvick
iPhone wrote: > Yes and to my listening pleasure no. I didn't delete the original Red > Books until after listening to the interview where Ringo is discussing > the 24/96 Remasters and how the bass and drums are the way he wanted > them for the original recordings. So Yes the track lists are all

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-19 Thread w3wilkes
d6jg wrote: > I have 2 copies of Faces - Long Player CD. > One an early CD and the other a reissue / remaster with bonus tracks. > I ripped both > The first is tagged as "Long Player" the second as "Long Player +" Sorry about OT. - Most excellent album! Didn't know there was a LP+, what are

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-17 Thread iPhone
DJanGo wrote: > [/OT] > > > The Beatles 2009 remasters have more bass and they are louder than the > Red Book versions. > So you didnt have the "same" Albums you have two (in my case 3 cause i > still listen to the vinyl ones) -different -Versions. > [\OT] Yes and to my listening pleasure no.

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-16 Thread emalvick
My solution to the scenario described is to generally name the primary album tracks with the album title. The bonus tracks will then get an album title that is of the style "Album (extended)" usually named to match how it may popularly be identified elsewhere e.g. tack on a Limited Edition,

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-11 Thread d6jg
adamdea wrote: > I have to confess that I’m confused as to why having the track in > different folders matters. > I did suggest option 2, but in the end OOP decided to just rip twice. > > Anyway I’m really grateful to everyone for their helpful contribution. Separate Folders - only because I

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-11 Thread adamdea
DJanGo wrote: > *lol* wash me - but dont make me wet... > > > There is no way to add a album into an m3u. How about the other way round? I think it might be useful to be able to incorporate eg a Spotify playlist as an album I have another email potential use case. I have the Hyperion

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-11 Thread adamdea
d6jg wrote: > In your actual use case you could use one of these scenarios > > Rip the reissue then > > 1. separate the tracks into two folders - one containing the "original" > and the other the "extras" and retag however you wish > or > 2. leave the tracks in one folder but retag the

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-11 Thread adamdea
atrocity wrote: > I realize you've already gotten answers, but I'm curious if you're using > Foobar2000 as your tagger. I was using the tagger in dBpoweramp and I tried the same thing using // in mp3tag. adamdea's

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-11 Thread atrocity
adamdea wrote: > I tried this using a ; separator (as per the same entry) but it did not > work. The album was listed with a slash (/) between the two title > suggesting that on some level the separator was recognised, but it still > only appears as one album in the list of albums. > > what is

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-11 Thread DJanGo
[/OT] iPhone wrote: > I deleted the ripped Red Book CDs (why do I need them now that I have > remasters in hires format?) The Beatles 2009 remasters have more bass and they are louder than the Red Book versions. So you didnt have the "same" Albums you have two (in my case 3 cause i still

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-11 Thread d6jg
iPhone wrote: > . > I have all the Beatles Albums on CD and ripped them to my server, then > years later I purchased the 24/96 remasters. So before loading the 24/96 > albums to the server, I deleted the ripped Red Book CDs (why do I need > them now that I have remasters in hires format?). This

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-11 Thread iPhone
. I have all the Beatles Albums on CD and ripped them to my server, then years later I purchased the 24/96 remasters. So before loading the 24/96 albums to the server, I deleted the ripped Red Book CDs (why do I need them now that I have remasters in hires format?). This immediately prevents any

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-11 Thread d6jg
Actually I have just realised I have this scenario myself in a few instances An example I have 2 copies of Faces - Long Player CD. One an early CD and the other a reissue / remaster with bonus tracks. I ripped both The first is tagged as "Long Player" the second as "Long Player +" *Pi3 with

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-11 Thread d6jg
adamdea wrote: > Thanks everyone for your contributions > > This arose out of a request made by someone else on another forum who > wanted to be able to have two albums appearing one the original album > and the other being the reissue with the "extras". He wanted to be able > to do so having

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-11 Thread DJanGo
adamdea wrote: > One other suggested option was to use a playlist, but the OOP didn't > want this unless the playlist would appear as an album. Is it possible > to make a playlist appear as an album. *lol* wash me - but dont make me wet... official M3U directive wrote: > > #EXTINF

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-10 Thread adamdea
Thanks everyone for your contributions This arose out of a request made by someone else on another forum who wanted to be able to have two albums appearing one the original album and the other being the reissue with the "extras". He wanted to be able to do so having simply ripped the reissue. He

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-10 Thread karlek
How about a playlist for the compilation? It would be what TE wanted, if one could handle (some) playlists as virtual albums. karlek's Profile: http://forums.slimdevices.com/member.php?userid=64321 View this thread:

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-10 Thread emalvick
I've seen the case of multiple albums tagged discussed elsewhere (other software), and I think it is something that just isn't handled well by software because it is a bit abstract. In theory it is possible, but I think that a lot of software just doesn't support it. I think the expectation is

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-10 Thread kidstypike
It doesn't work using a separator for Album titles. I changed the Album tag for the track "Mellow Yellow" by Donovan to "Easy Like Sunday Morning;Mellow Yellow" and rescanned. The track is no longer listed under the album "Easy Like Sunday Morning" but appears as a single track in it's own album

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-10 Thread d6jg
adamdea wrote: > Let's suppose that I want to create (or recreate) the compilation album. > [Or I want to save the space]. > > Can we move on? The short answer is no. Although you can tag with multiple albums the way the scanner works is that it looks in folders which typically would be

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-10 Thread adamdea
slartibartfast wrote: > But you only ripped one of them? > > Sent from my SM-G900F using Tapatalk Let's suppose that I want to create (or recreate) the compilation album. [Or I want to save the space]. Can we move on?

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-10 Thread slartibartfast
adamdea wrote: > It's a bit of a long story, but for the sake of argument let's assume > that it might appear on both the orginal LP and a compilation album.But you > only ripped one of them? Sent from my SM-G900F using Tapatalk

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-10 Thread d6jg
d6jg wrote: > If you only collected tracks as opposed to albums i can see where this > might be appropriate. > > Example > Merry Xmas Everybody (Slade) - must be on numerous Xmas compilations as > well as numerous Slade albums BUT if you actually had two albums with it on then it wouldn't

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-10 Thread adamdea
slartibartfast wrote: > Maybe I am misunderstanding but how can a single track be on multiple > albums? > > Sent from my SM-G900F using TapatalkIt's a bit of a long story, but for the > sake of argument let's assume that it might appear on both the orginal LP and a compilation album.

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-10 Thread slartibartfast
adamdea wrote: > In the notes to settings/my music/separator for multiple items in tags > it claims that you can have multiple albums tagged for a track. > > I tried this using a ; separator (as per the same entry) but it did not > work. The album was listed with a slash (/) between the two

[SlimDevices: Ripping] multiple album for a track

2017-10-10 Thread adamdea
In the notes to settings/my music/separator for multiple items in tags it claims that you can have multiple albums tagged for a track. I tried this using a ; separator (as per the same entry) but it did work. The album was listed with a slash (/) between the two title suggesting that on some