I do not believe this policy will achieve its stated objective: to
accelerate IPv6 implementation.
Automatically delegating IPv6 address space to new and initial IPv4
requests, may increase the number of IPv6 delegations. But, the bar to get
an IPv6 delegation is already pretty low, and it is not
On Wed, Jan 24, 2024 at 9:49 PM Fernando Frediani
wrote:
>
> On Wed, 24 Jan 2024, 21:50 Christopher Hawker,
> wrote:
>
>> NIRs may well continue to exist and perform their administrative
>> functions under the umbrella of the RIR facilitating things in certain
>> economies and cultures.
>>
>>
Dear Mike and Fernando,
Mike:
I have been under the impression that the APNIC NIRs must adhere to APNIC
policies but could create their own policies if they don’t contradict those of
APNIC.
Yes. Please notice the policy proposals in APNIC sig-policy often have the
section of
Hello Fernando,
To resume my initial point there is no point in allowing NIRs to develop and
have specific policies, complicate and confuse things unecessarily.
It only complicates and confuses things for people who have no idea or
understanding what goes on and what they are talking about.
In the past I have had problems with the transfer policies of APNIC NIRs not
matching APNIC’s own transfer policies.
When those differences prevented a transfer I asked APNIC to intervene by
imposing the (governing, to my mind) APNIC transfer policies on the
recalcitrant NIR.
And that was
To resume my initial point there is no point in allowing NIRs to develop
and have specific policies, complicate and confuse things unecessarily.
Policies developed by the entire RIR community is more than enough in order
to regulate how IP addreess assignment is conducted as in all.other RIRs
Hi
On Wed, 24 Jan 2024, 07:39 David Conrad, wrote:
> Fernando,
>
> On Jan 24, 2024, at 4:19 AM, Fernando Frediani
> wrote:
> > No government should ever be able to mandate anything related to policy
> development and how they apply to IP space assignment and use.
>
> I’m actually curious: why
Fernando,
On Jan 24, 2024, at 4:19 AM, Fernando Frediani wrote:
> No government should ever be able to mandate anything related to policy
> development and how they apply to IP space assignment and use.
I’m actually curious: why do you believe you (or the RIRs) are able to tell
governments
