[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-11 Thread Caliban Darklock
On Thu, Jun 11, 2009 at 11:48 AM, Paul Kinlan wrote: > > You could do the "Stackoverflow" method of quietly silencing/ignoring the > users that are spamming/abusing the system which is why I suggested not > sending the "XYZ is now following you" email for people that look like they > are abusing t

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-11 Thread Nick Arnett
On Thu, Jun 11, 2009 at 12:07 PM, Dossy Shiobara wrote: > >> > As a human user, I can understand following making use easier. As a > software agent user, there's no reason to actually follow anyone - you > should be using the stream/follow or stream/shadow APIs, today. Fair point... I haven't

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-11 Thread Dossy Shiobara
On 6/11/09 3:52 PM, Nick Arnett wrote: I think you may not be considering legitimate automated systems that can quickly find a number of people who are discussing n emerging topic. My social network analysis does that - when it sees a topic becoming hot, it does some searches to see who is talk

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-11 Thread Nick Arnett
On Thu, Jun 11, 2009 at 11:28 AM, Dossy Shiobara wrote: > > following you" email for people that look >> like they are abusing the system. >> > > Absolutely. There should be a silent rate limit around following - normal > human activity shouldn't really be >1 follow per second, and no more than

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-11 Thread Dossy Shiobara
On 6/11/09 1:38 PM, Caliban Darklock wrote: If someone does something you don't like, and you unfollow them, they lose followers. That's what they wanted on Twitter in the first place, right? People following them? The problem though is the massive marketer circle-jerk of followings consumes

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-11 Thread Dossy Shiobara
On 6/11/09 2:48 PM, Paul Kinlan wrote: You could do the "Stackoverflow" method of quietly silencing/ignoring the users that are spamming/abusing the system which is why I suggested not sending the "XYZ is now following you" email for people that look like they are abusing the system. Absolutel

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-11 Thread Paul Kinlan
You could do the "Stackoverflow" method of quietly silencing/ignoring the users that are spamming/abusing the system which is why I suggested not sending the "XYZ is now following you" email for people that look like they are abusing the system. Paul. 2009/6/11 Caliban Darklock > > On Thu, Jun 1

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-11 Thread Caliban Darklock
On Thu, Jun 11, 2009 at 8:57 AM, Dossy Shiobara wrote: > > Without the potency of enforcement, what's the point? Social enforcement is more potent than legal enforcement. If someone does something you don't like, and you unfollow them, they lose followers. That's what they wanted on Twitter in th

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-11 Thread Caliban Darklock
On Thu, Jun 11, 2009 at 7:52 AM, Abraham Williams<4bra...@gmail.com> wrote: > > How would the CoH be social enforced? I think there's already social enforcement. You can "d spam @whoever" or just "@spam @whoever" to make your report. Developers of desktop clients might consider making a little ma

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-11 Thread Dossy Shiobara
Jun 2009 09:52:33 To: Subject: [twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read What if the Twitter community were to draft a code of honor that could be voted on by anyone with a Twitter account. Kind of like the Facebook ToS voting but actually community driven. A few questio

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-11 Thread Abraham Williams
What if the Twitter community were to draft a code of honor that could be voted on by anyone with a Twitter account. Kind of like the Facebook ToS voting but actually community driven. A few questions regarding this: Do you think it would be possible for the community to come to a final decision? W

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-11 Thread Paul Kinlan
Brant, As the developer of Twollo I take an exception to you saying Twollo is an abusive application and violates the TOS. We are do not exist to abuse the system, the number of user on our system is large and the vast majority of our users are "good" users who have a genuine interest in finding a

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-10 Thread Caliban Darklock
On Wed, Jun 10, 2009 at 11:23 AM, Dossy Shiobara wrote: > > It's obviously an incredibly thin line ... It's the same line you walk as a marketer. On the one hand, you want to provide value to your followers, so they will keep following you. On the other, you want to extract value efficiently from

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-10 Thread Dossy Shiobara
On 6/10/09 12:25 PM, Caliban Darklock wrote: A very real concern that should enter the heads of those who oppose "improper" use of Twitter is that there is a very real possibility that the Twitter team will need to monetize the application, and the single greatest opportunity to do that comes fr

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-10 Thread Caliban Darklock
On Wed, Jun 10, 2009 at 8:47 AM, Andrew Badera wrote: > > You should look up the definition of "ghetto" sometime. According to Wikipedia, it's "a portion of a city in which members of a minority group live; especially because of social, legal, or economic pressure" - and a minority group is "a so

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-10 Thread Andrew Badera
You should look up the definition of "ghetto" sometime. On Wed, Jun 10, 2009 at 11:42 AM, Caliban Darklock wrote: > > On Wed, Jun 10, 2009 at 8:21 AM, Andrew Badera wrote: >> >> Any >> neighborhood of a particular clustered minor demographic deserves to >> be patrolled? > > If the minor demogra

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-10 Thread Caliban Darklock
On Wed, Jun 10, 2009 at 8:21 AM, Andrew Badera wrote: > > Any > neighborhood of a particular clustered minor demographic deserves to > be patrolled? If the minor demographic in question is "criminals," yes. Any other qualities of the demographic are coincidental.

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-10 Thread Andrew Badera
Despite the poor, potentially offensive use of the term "ghetto" ? Any neighborhood of a particular clustered minor demographic deserves to be patrolled? Slick gents, slick. On Wed, Jun 10, 2009 at 11:12 AM, Cameron Kaiser wrote: > >> Having a known ghetto is useful: it helps you focus where to

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-10 Thread Cameron Kaiser
> Having a known ghetto is useful: it helps you focus where to patrol. .sig dibs! -- personal: http://www.cameronkaiser.com/ -- Cameron Kaiser * Floodgap Systems * www.floodgap.com * ckai...@floodgap.com -- FORTUNE: You will be hit with a lot of money. Avo

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-10 Thread Dewald Pretorius
Dossy, You are 100% correct. They will spam as long as there is some benefit for them doing so. Spamming is like shoplifting. It's part of the cost of doing business if you own a store. You put measures in place to try and prevent it, but you can never prevent it all. Dewald On Jun 10, 11:36 a

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-10 Thread Dossy Shiobara
On 6/10/09 9:55 AM, Dewald Pretorius wrote: It is a fact of life that, regardless of how benign or how powerful the tools are that you provide your users, 99% will use them in a sensible and responsible manner, and 1% will always try and abuse them. This is why I am ALWAYS very cautious about

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-10 Thread Andrew Badera
I think 1% is pretty kind given the huge volume of spammers on Twitter these days. And I'd even say that spam-friendly tools turn non-spammers INTO spammers, either inadvertently, or gateway style -- once they see how they "can" take advantage of the system, they "do." On Wed, Jun 10, 2009 at 9

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-10 Thread Dewald Pretorius
If someone runs through your neighborhood killing people with a chainsaw, should the government shut down Home Depot because they sell chainsaws? It is a fact of life that, regardless of how benign or how powerful the tools are that you provide your users, 99% will use them in a sensible and resp

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-09 Thread Justyn Howard
Thank you for the response Doug. I intended the post to be more curious than implicative ­ though it may have sounded more of the latter. In any case, we¹ve all grown to love the openness of the platform, and the platform itself as such a great opportunity to build. I just got nervous when I starte

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-09 Thread Developer In London
I second that. 2009/6/10 Justyn Howard > What are the chances that this new TOS will negate any of the hard work > we’ve done up until this point? Can you give us an idea of what will be > protected? It’s a little alarming to hear that Twitter might decide to > reserve functionality that the de

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-09 Thread Doug Williams
Obviously I can't address the impact since we don't have a document to deliver. Let me be clear, we are not thinking of taking functionality from the offering, but we are discussing how open we want to be moving forward. Most of the talks are around what we want to offer through the Streaming API a

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-09 Thread Justyn Howard
What are the chances that this new TOS will negate any of the hard work we¹ve done up until this point? Can you give us an idea of what will be protected? It¹s a little alarming to hear that Twitter might decide to reserve functionality that the developer network has built-on and enhanced in favor

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-09 Thread Caliban Darklock
On Tue, Jun 9, 2009 at 5:27 PM, Brant wrote: > > Williams, my point is why would a user need to rapidly remove or add > twitter followers? Turn that around: why should a user be FORBIDDEN to rapidly remove or add new followers?

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-09 Thread Doug Williams
The API TOS is currently in development. It is taking longer than hoped as we are still exploring what we want to give to developers and what we want to protect as business assets. For now, make sure that you understand the general TOS we have in place. We do work with developers if they are willin

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-09 Thread Jesse Stay
Doug, where is the developer API TOS? I think that's part of the problem - none of us are being required to enter into an agreement before developing, therefore we have no idea what we can and can't do with it. I also don't think most of us even know where any such TOS is, if there is one. I agr

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-09 Thread Brant
I agree with you Justyn. There are probably tons of applications, but these two were on the top of my head. If a large amount of users are getting banned for using a particular service then Twitter should recognize a pattern and give the service notification of the issue and give them some time

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-09 Thread Brant
Williams, my point is why would a user need to rapidly remove or add twitter followers? Mutuality even states that it is not responsible if your twitter account gets suspended for using their service. The underlying usage for these services is for abuse. I ordinarily wouldn't mind but the reaso

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-09 Thread Justyn Howard
I think it depends on what measures the site is taking to promote responsible use of the applications. Both applications could be used for good, or bad. I can think of one fairly popular site that is all but endorses spammy behavior and charges users for access to these spammy tools. I don¹t want t

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-09 Thread Doug Williams
Brant,Thank you for your concern. This is something that bothers us as well. Moving applications exclusively to OAuth-based authentication will certainly help in restricting applications that abuse the service. If you find a service that you think is violating our TOS, please email a...@twitter.co

[twitter-dev] Re: Twitter Application Usage Guidelines, Please Read

2009-06-09 Thread Abraham Williams
In briefly checking out Mutuality and Twollo I'm not sure what about them is abusive. Mutuality says it lets you rapidly modify who you are following to match who is following you and Twollo auto follows accounts it thinks you might be interested in. Those are both useful tools and if used as inten