Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-29 Thread Mecki Foerthmann
With other words nothing I really need like manipulating a U2 database. Does it make cups of tea too? Well, I don't like cups of tea, so why should I change? Steve Romanow wrote: Mecki Foerthmann wrote: It really boils down to this. What can you do with Python in a U2 database that I can't do

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-29 Thread Results
All, Please keep it polite. This is a civilized list. - Charles Barouch resu...@keyally.com ___ U2-Users mailing list U2-Users@listserver.u2ug.org http://listserver.u2ug.org/mailman/listinfo/u2-users

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-29 Thread Steve Romanow
Mecki, My apologies for being confrontational. This is a subject I care deeply about. I have worked in mv shops exclusively since 1994 (not bragging) and my point was primarily that the IT world has surpassed our tools by a large margin. I have written my last complicated F-correlative and

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-29 Thread Brian Leach
Hi I thought about adding code folding to mvDeveloper, but with Pick/Basic it doesn't really work in the same way. If you have a language that is function or member based, there is a very clear boundary for each function, e.g. private void doSomething{ code in here } which makes it easy to

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-29 Thread Steve Romanow
Brian Leach wrote: Hi I thought about adding code folding to mvDeveloper, but with Pick/Basic it doesn't really work in the same way. If you have a language that is function or member based, there is a very clear boundary for each function, e.g. Could a mild folding (fold the ones there

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-29 Thread Brian Leach
Steve I think you're possibly out of date in your view of the database - again, not wanting to be confrontational but this is an important point that you raise. I've also used MV for many years, but for the vast majority of that it has been as part of a client/server or similar platform. If

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-29 Thread Symeon Breen
Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History Steve I think you're possibly out of date in your view of the database - again, not wanting to be confrontational but this is an important point that you raise. I've also used MV for many years, but for the vast majority of that it has been as part

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-29 Thread kishor
Hi Brian, How about adding a folding option that you can manually set the start and end points and add your comments for the fold? I use mvDeveloper for U2 development and textpad for other MV databases. Kishor Quoting Brian Leach br...@brianleach.co.uk: Hi I thought about adding code

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-29 Thread Dawn Wolthuis
On Sun, Jun 28, 2009 at 4:32 PM, Steve Romanowslestak...@gmail.com wrote: Mecki Foerthmann wrote: It really boils down to this. What can you do with Python in a U2 database that I can't do with Pick Basic? Umm, real unit testing ala nosetest I realize this is the U2 list, but I thought I

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-29 Thread Steve Romanow
TY Dawn, Very cool post. You laid it out there very nicely. I hope to avoid the shiny new thing syndrome. I need to look up the book reference you made. WRT to the resurgence of mv-like data structures, no one will care that we've been mv when mv wasn't cool. Thanks guys for engaging me

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-29 Thread Brian Leach
Thanks guys for engaging me in this exercise. I'm usually not this outspoken. We *like* outspoken. It's better than leaving things unsaid grin. Brian ___ U2-Users mailing list U2-Users@listserver.u2ug.org

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-29 Thread Steve Romanow
Brian Leach wrote: Thanks guys for engaging me in this exercise. I'm usually not this outspoken. Look at the times of my posts. I should use Google's Beer Goggles. No posts over 5 lines between 2am and 7am. ___ U2-Users mailing list

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-29 Thread Anthony W. Youngman
In message 1fdb619c0906290746n2d553c0ao867cb5d64327b...@mail.gmail.com, Dawn Wolthuis dawnwolth...@gmail.com writes On Sun, Jun 28, 2009 at 4:32 PM, Steve Romanowslestak...@gmail.com wrote: Mecki Foerthmann wrote: It really boils down to this. What can you do with Python in a U2 database

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-29 Thread Charles Stevenson
Dawn Wolthuis wrote: Just my two cents. cheers! --dawn How come Dawn's two cents are always worth more than my two cents? Don't answer that. All, I've found lurking on this whole thread informative thought-provoking. Thanks. ___ U2-Users

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-29 Thread Allen E. Elwood
of the original comment, or something to that effect... Allen -Original Message- From: u2-users-boun...@listserver.u2ug.org [mailto:u2-users-boun...@listserver.u2ug.org]on Behalf Of David A. Green Sent: Friday, June 26, 2009 9:50 AM To: 'U2 Users List' Subject: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-28 Thread Ross Ferris
-Original Message- From: u2-users-boun...@listserver.u2ug.org [mailto:u2-users- boun...@listserver.u2ug.org] On Behalf Of Tony G Sent: Sunday, 28 June 2009 6:26 AM To: u2-users@listserver.u2ug.org Subject: Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-28 Thread Steve Romanow
Talking about never evolving pick basic. Can you imagine the posibilities if we just abandoned pick basic and used something like python as the data modeling language. It would be unstoppable. ___ U2-Users mailing list U2-Users@listserver.u2ug.org

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-28 Thread Mecki Foerthmann
It really boils down to this. What can you do with Python in a U2 database that I can't do with Pick Basic? And do I really need to be able to do that to do my job improving and maintaining commercial software in an SB+ Unidata environment any better? Do I get paid more if I write code in

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-28 Thread Steve Romanow
Mecki Foerthmann wrote: It really boils down to this. What can you do with Python in a U2 database that I can't do with Pick Basic? Umm, real unit testing ala nosetest real exception handling, umm, real inline documentation (the topic of this thread) Umm, access to thousands of trained

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-27 Thread Boydell, Stuart
: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History From: David A. Green I've always commented my program at the beginning, but some programs have many changes and when we have 300+ lines of comments it gets a little tedious to deal with embedded in the source code. I'm think

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-27 Thread Brian Leach
if you need to see what changed. Regards Brian -Original Message- From: u2-users-boun...@listserver.u2ug.org [mailto:u2-users-boun...@listserver.u2ug.org] On Behalf Of David A. Green Sent: 26 June 2009 17:50 To: 'U2 Users List' Subject: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-27 Thread Steve Romanow
Another option is to have an accompanying wiki/vcs setup where a lot of metadata about why and what can be stored outside of the code. With version control, you fight the need to comment out old code and leave it in. And the wiki can be as verbose as you want.

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-27 Thread Tony G
Ross - Your suggestion for folding on syntax is fine but it doesn't go far enough. The mainstream development world recognized what you're saying long ago, did it, and then improved upon it again. We're sort of two generations behind in this discussion. Yes, Visual Studio folds C++, C#, and

[U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-26 Thread David A. Green
I've always commented my program at the beginning, but some programs have many changes and when we have 300+ lines of comments it gets a little tedious to deal with embedded in the source code. I'm think of placing them in an external file and then doing a $INSERT in the source code in order

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-26 Thread Steve Romanow
That might cause you problems if you use the u2 debugger. ___ U2-Users mailing list U2-Users@listserver.u2ug.org http://listserver.u2ug.org/mailman/listinfo/u2-users

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-26 Thread Symeon Breen
: 26 June 2009 17:50 To: 'U2 Users List' Subject: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History I've always commented my program at the beginning, but some programs have many changes and when we have 300+ lines of comments it gets a little tedious to deal with embedded in the source

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-26 Thread David Jordan
Think about using xml for documentation in the source code, then some external tools can be used for documentation. *subRoutine to * modAdded to * mod Date . * mod Author Regards David Jordan ___ U2-Users mailing list

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-26 Thread Tony G
From: David A. Green I've always commented my program at the beginning, but some programs have many changes and when we have 300+ lines of comments it gets a little tedious to deal with embedded in the source code. I'm think of placing them in an external file and then doing a $INSERT

Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History

2009-06-26 Thread Ross Ferris
@listserver.u2ug.org Subject: Re: [U2] Program Comments/Documentation/Notes/Revision History From: David A. Green I've always commented my program at the beginning, but some programs have many changes and when we have 300+ lines of comments it gets a little tedious to deal with embedded