Re: [vchkpw] Re: vpopmail does not like my 2nd domain
Hi Matthias, First: sorry for a mistake in my last mail, the 'egrep' command should have been executed on '/var/qmail/users/assign', but somthing went wrong with copy/paste. On Wed, 16 Jul 2003 21:09:57 +0200 Matthias F. Brandstetter wrote: Jep, both domains have their home dirs under /home/vpopmail. I added these two domains with ~vpopmail/bin/vadddomain. It should add all necessary entries into all necessary config files, shouldn't it? Update: I tried to delete my orig. domain (mx2.ebox.at) from vpopmails DB, now I get the following error when sending a mail to [EMAIL PROTECTED]: = - The following addresses had permanent fatal errors - [EMAIL PROTECTED] (reason: 553 sorry, that domain isn't in my list of allowed rcpthosts (#5.7.1)) = But: I *have* it in my rcpthosts file: = [EMAIL PROTECTED]:/var/qmail/control# cat rcpthosts mailtest.reinprecht.at = I first thought I might have one or two ideas on what goes wrong, but thinking about them I ended up with: this is nonsense. So it's debugging time. You have set up / done something _REALLY_ wicked. I don't know what yet, but it must be something from the outer limit :-) Therefore your have to do _real_ debugging right know: - figure qmail-smtpd PID (i.e.: figure the PID of 'tcpserver' or 'inetd' process that is bound to port 25) - attach 'strace' (I'm assuming you're running Linux; if you're on *BSD use 'truss') to this process: strace -tf -o /tmp/qmail-smtpd.log -s 4096 -p $PID_of_QMAIL_SMTPD - send a mail to '[EMAIL PROTECTED]' - after the mail has bounces kill the 'strace'. - post the file '/tmp/qmail-smtpd.log', compress before attaching it to a mail, send via PM if passwords might occur in the file (e.g. due to SMTP-AUTH used). Of course you can have a look at the file yourself and if your think you figured the cause of your problem you can drop a note about this in the message with attached file and present your theory, for us being able to confirm or decline. But _PLEASE_: don't alter the content of the file. Don't strip something out, don't anonymize. Do I have to insert this domain into another config file as well, so that qmail accepts it? 'rcpthosts' should be enough for the first acceptance, the error message you presented indicates the domain ain't found there. If it were and only delivery would fail the error you get back would be a different one. -- Ciao, Pit
Re: [vchkpw] Re: vpopmail does not like my 2nd domain
-- quoting Peter Palmreuther -- So it's debugging time. You have set up / done something _REALLY_ wicked. I don't know what yet, but it must be something from the outer limit :-) Therefore your have to do _real_ debugging right know: - figure qmail-smtpd PID (i.e.: figure the PID of 'tcpserver' or 'inetd' process that is bound to port 25) - attach 'strace' (I'm assuming you're running Linux; if you're on *BSD use 'truss') to this process: strace -tf -o /tmp/qmail-smtpd.log -s 4096 -p $PID_of_QMAIL_SMTPD - send a mail to '[EMAIL PROTECTED]' - after the mail has bounces kill the 'strace'. Ok then, finally I got it ... FINALLY :) *BIG* thanks to Peter Palmreuther for this great tip with strace. I can see in the trace that my mailserver (say: the sender, not the new one with this issue) replaced the virtual domain mailtest.reinprecht.at with mx2.ebox.at -- I think because of a wrong CNAME/MX record in DNS, I will investigate further... But when I telnet on port 25 to this new qmail server and send a mail manually, then everything works fine. So, thanks again to Peter and all the others who helped me out with this! Greetings, Matthias -- Matthias F. Brandstetter [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] now playing Groove Salad: a nicely chilled plate of ambient beats and grooves. [SomaFM]
[vchkpw] Re: vpopmail does not like my 2nd domain
Hello Matthias, On Wednesday, July 16, 2003 at 7:05:58 PM you wrote (at least in part): | qmail-showctl |grep '[vV]irtual' = virtualdomains: Virtual domain: mx2.ebox.at:mx2.ebox.at Virtual domain: mailtest.reinprecht.at:mailtest.reinprecht.at virtualdomains.lock: I have no idea what this file does. = OK, here I don't see two identically at second level domain entries. Are you talking about messages to '[EMAIL PROTECTED]' get delivered to '[EMAIL PROTECTED]' or vice versa? Or is your 'problematic' domain a different one not listed here? If the former: what's the output of egrep '(mx2.ebox.at|mailtest.reinprecht.at)' If the latter: what happens if you execute vadddomain -r NEWdomain.at again? Does the NEWdomain.at now show up in '/var/qmail/control/virtualdomains'??? Or is there any error message when you try to 'add' the domain again? qmail-showctl |grep 'locally.' there is no output for 'locally'. OK. So an accidentally both delivered to the same local can be excluded. -- Best regards Peter Palmreuther God gets boring when you let him have his way.
Re: [vchkpw] Re: vpopmail does not like my 2nd domain
-- quoting Peter Palmreuther -- = virtualdomains: Virtual domain: mx2.ebox.at:mx2.ebox.at Virtual domain: mailtest.reinprecht.at:mailtest.reinprecht.at virtualdomains.lock: I have no idea what this file does. = OK, here I don't see two identically at second level domain entries. Are you talking about messages to '[EMAIL PROTECTED]' get delivered to '[EMAIL PROTECTED]' or vice versa? Or is your 'problematic' domain a different one not listed here? *) If I send a mail to [EMAIL PROTECTED] (which is the FQHN of this machine), then it is delivered fine. *) If I send a mail to [EMAIL PROTECTED], then it is delivered to to [EMAIL PROTECTED] account. *) If I send a mail to [EMAIL PROTECTED] (which is an existing vpopmail account for this domain, but not on mx2.ebox.at), then I get this error in my logfile (and in my bounce mail): = delivery 4: failure: Sorry,_no_mailbox_here_by_that_name._vpopmail_(#5.1.1) = If the former: what's the output of egrep '(mx2.ebox.at|mailtest.reinprecht.at)' = [EMAIL PROTECTED]:/var/qmail/control# /var/qmail/bin/qmail-showctl | egrep '(mx2.ebox.at|mailtest.reinprecht.at)' bouncehost: (Default.) Bounce host name is mx2.ebox.at. defaulthost: (Default.) Default host name is mx2.ebox.at. doublebouncehost: (Default.) 2B recipient host: mx2.ebox.at. envnoathost: (Default.) Presumed domain name is mx2.ebox.at. helohost: (Default.) SMTP client HELO host name is mx2.ebox.at. idhost: (Default.) Message-ID host name is mx2.ebox.at. localiphost: (Default.) Local IP address becomes mx2.ebox.at. me: My name is mx2.ebox.at. SMTP clients may send messages to recipients at mx2.ebox.at. SMTP clients may send messages to recipients at mailtest.reinprecht.at. smtpgreeting: (Default.) SMTP greeting: 220 mx2.ebox.at. Virtual domain: mx2.ebox.at:mx2.ebox.at Virtual domain: mailtest.reinprecht.at:mailtest.reinprecht.at = If the latter: what happens if you execute vadddomain -r NEWdomain.at (I replaced NEWdomain.at with mailtest.reinprecht.at, because this is my NEWdomain) = [EMAIL PROTECTED]:/var/qmail/control# /home/vpopmail/bin/vadddomain -r mailtest.reinprecht.at Error: Domain already exists = again? Does the NEWdomain.at now show up in '/var/qmail/control/virtualdomains'??? (again, mailtest.reinprecht.at is now my NEWdomain.at) = [EMAIL PROTECTED]:/var/qmail/control# cat /var/qmail/control/virtualdomains mx2.ebox.at:mx2.ebox.at mailtest.reinprecht.at:mailtest.reinprecht.at = And my /var/qmail/control/locals file is empty. Is anything wrong with this configuration? Greetings and thx for your help, Matthias -- Matthias F. Brandstetter [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] now playing Groove Salad: a nicely chilled plate of ambient beats and grooves. [SomaFM]
Re: [vchkpw] Re: vpopmail does not like my 2nd domain
What does /var/qmail/users/assign look like? Could both domains be mapped to the same home directory? Is mail for mx2.ebox.at stored in ~vpopmail/domains/mx2.ebox.at? -- Tom Collins [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://sniffter.com/ - info on the Sniffter hand-held Network Tester
Re: [vchkpw] Re: vpopmail does not like my 2nd domain
-- quoting Tom Collins -- What does /var/qmail/users/assign look like? = [EMAIL PROTECTED]:/var/qmail/control# cat /var/qmail/users/assign +mx2.ebox.at-:mx2.ebox.at:89:89:/home/vpopmail/domains/mx2.ebox.at:-:: +mailtest.reinprecht.at-:mailtest.reinprecht.at:89:89:/home/vpopmail/domains/mailtest.reinprecht.at:-:: . = Could both domains be mapped to the same home directory? Is mail for mx2.ebox.at stored in ~vpopmail/domains/mx2.ebox.at? Jep, both domains have their home dirs under /home/vpopmail. I added these two domains with ~vpopmail/bin/vadddomain. It should add all necessary entries into all necessary config files, shouldn't it? Greetings, Matthias -- Matthias F. Brandstetter [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] now playing Groove Salad: a nicely chilled plate of ambient beats and grooves. [SomaFM]
Re: [vchkpw] Re: vpopmail does not like my 2nd domain
-- quoting Matthias F. Brandstetter -- Jep, both domains have their home dirs under /home/vpopmail. I added these two domains with ~vpopmail/bin/vadddomain. It should add all necessary entries into all necessary config files, shouldn't it? Update: I tried to delete my orig. domain (mx2.ebox.at) from vpopmails DB, now I get the following error when sending a mail to [EMAIL PROTECTED]: = - The following addresses had permanent fatal errors - [EMAIL PROTECTED] (reason: 553 sorry, that domain isn't in my list of allowed rcpthosts (#5.7.1)) = But: I *have* it in my rcpthosts file: = [EMAIL PROTECTED]:/var/qmail/control# cat rcpthosts mailtest.reinprecht.at = Do I have to insert this domain into another config file as well, so that qmail accepts it? Greetings, Matthias -- Matthias F. Brandstetter [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] now playing Groove Salad: a nicely chilled plate of ambient beats and grooves. [SomaFM]
Re: [vchkpw] Re: vpopmail does not like my 2nd domain
Matthias F. Brandstetter wrote: -- quoting Matthias F. Brandstetter -- Jep, both domains have their home dirs under /home/vpopmail. I added these two domains with ~vpopmail/bin/vadddomain. It should add all necessary entries into all necessary config files, shouldn't it? Update: I tried to delete my orig. domain (mx2.ebox.at) from vpopmails DB, now I get the following error when sending a mail to [EMAIL PROTECTED]: = - The following addresses had permanent fatal errors - [EMAIL PROTECTED] (reason: 553 sorry, that domain isn't in my list of allowed rcpthosts (#5.7.1)) = But: I *have* it in my rcpthosts file: = [EMAIL PROTECTED]:/var/qmail/control# cat rcpthosts mailtest.reinprecht.at = Do I have to insert this domain into another config file as well, so that qmail accepts it? Hi, Did you HUP qmail-send after making manual changes to the config files ? Regards, Rick
Re: [vchkpw] Re: vpopmail does not like my 2nd domain
-- quoting Rick Macdougall -- Hi, Did you HUP qmail-send after making manual changes to the config files ? Jep, I even tried to reboot my machine -- with no success :( I really have no idea left. I am searching for this on google the whole day now, posting to newsgroups and mailinglist, but nobody seems to have an answer (only things which I already have tried). So long... Matthias -- Matthias F. Brandstetter [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] now playing Groove Salad: a nicely chilled plate of ambient beats and grooves. [SomaFM]
