[VIHUELA] who invented the guitar

2007-05-21 Thread bill kilpatrick
gleaned the following from a 5c. vihuela alert on
google in response to the question of who invented
the guitar? ... anything missing?:

1265 Juan Gil of Zamora mentions the early guitar in
Ars Musica.

1283-1350 Guitarra Latina  Guitar Moresca are
mentioned multiple times in the poems of the
Archpriest of Hita

1306 A gitarer was played at the Feast of
Westminster in England

1404 Der mynnen regein by Eberhard Von Cersne makes
reference to a quinterne.

1487 Johannes Tinctoris described the guitarra as
being invented by the Catalans. This refers to the
four course guitar. Each course represents one pair of
double strings.

1546 Tres Libros de Musica en Cifras para Vihuela by
Alonso Mudarra is the first publication to include
music for guitar.

1551-1555 Nine books of tablature were published by
Adrian Le Roy. These include the first pieces for 5
course guitar. The addition of the fifth course was
attributed to Vicente Espinel

1600-1650 Many publications of tablature for the
guitar. It's popularity begins to rival the lute.

1674 Publication of Guitarre Royal by F. Corbetta
increased the guitar's popularity. It was dedicated to
Louis XIV.

1770-1800 A sixth string was added to the guitar and
the courses were replaced by single strings.

1800-1850 Guitar enjoyed a large popularity both in
performances and publishing. Fernando Sor, Mauro
Guiliani, Matteo Carcassi and Dioniso Aguado all
performed, taught, wrote and had published their
compositions.

1850-1892 Guitar maker Antonio de Torres develops the
larger more resonant instrument we know today.

1916 Segovia performs at Ateneo, the most important
concert hall in Madrid. Before this it was thought
that the guitar did not have the volume for this type
of venue.

1946 Nylon replaces gut as a string material

http://earlymusiccharango.blogspot.com/


  ___
Yahoo! Answers - Got a question? Someone out there knows the answer. Try it
now.
http://uk.answers.yahoo.com/ 



To get on or off this list see list information at
http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html


[VIHUELA] Re: who invented the guitar

2007-05-21 Thread Monica Hall
I am afraid Google has got most of it wrong.

The term guitarra/quinterne etc, in medieval sources does not necessarily
refer to the figure of eight shaped instrument at all but to a type of small
lute.

I can't go into all the details but Tinctoris describes the guitar as 
follows


-a small tortoise shaped instrument invented by the Catalans which some call 
ghiterra, others ghiterna



The ghiterra is used most rarely, because of the thinness of its sound. 
When I heard it in Catalonia, it was being used much more often by women, to 
accompany their love songs, than by men.



In other words the instrument is a small lute or mandora.



The vihuela is described as



-an instrument invented by the Spanish, which both they and the Italians 
call the viola, but the French the demi-luth.


-this viola differs from the lute in that the lute is much larger and 
tortoise-shaped, while the viola is flat, and in most cases curved inwards 
on each side.



The relevant article to read is still



Lawrence Wright - The medieval gittern and citole : a case of mistaken 
identity



in Galpin Society Journal, Vol. 30, 1977, p.8-42.



Mudarra is indeed the first person known to have published music for the 
4-course guitar.



Only five of the books printed between 1550-1555 are by Leroy  Ballard. 
The rest are by Morlaye/Gorlier.   They do not include any 5-course music.



There is a lot missing from the rest of it but I haven't time to write a 
book on the subject at present..



Don't believe everything you find on the Internet.



Monica







- Original Message - 
From: bill kilpatrick [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To: vihuela@cs.dartmouth.edu
Sent: Monday, May 21, 2007 2:23 PM
Subject: [VIHUELA] who invented the guitar


 gleaned the following from a 5c. vihuela alert on
 google in response to the question of who invented
 the guitar? ... anything missing?:

 1265 Juan Gil of Zamora mentions the early guitar in
 Ars Musica.

 1283-1350 Guitarra Latina  Guitar Moresca are
 mentioned multiple times in the poems of the
 Archpriest of Hita

 1306 A gitarer was played at the Feast of
 Westminster in England

 1404 Der mynnen regein by Eberhard Von Cersne makes
 reference to a quinterne.

 1487 Johannes Tinctoris described the guitarra as
 being invented by the Catalans. This refers to the
 four course guitar. Each course represents one pair of
 double strings.

 1546 Tres Libros de Musica en Cifras para Vihuela by
 Alonso Mudarra is the first publication to include
 music for guitar.

 1551-1555 Nine books of tablature were published by
 Adrian Le Roy. These include the first pieces for 5
 course guitar. The addition of the fifth course was
 attributed to Vicente Espinel

 1600-1650 Many publications of tablature for the
 guitar. It's popularity begins to rival the lute.

 1674 Publication of Guitarre Royal by F. Corbetta
 increased the guitar's popularity. It was dedicated to
 Louis XIV.

 1770-1800 A sixth string was added to the guitar and
 the courses were replaced by single strings.

 1800-1850 Guitar enjoyed a large popularity both in
 performances and publishing. Fernando Sor, Mauro
 Guiliani, Matteo Carcassi and Dioniso Aguado all
 performed, taught, wrote and had published their
 compositions.

 1850-1892 Guitar maker Antonio de Torres develops the
 larger more resonant instrument we know today.

 1916 Segovia performs at Ateneo, the most important
 concert hall in Madrid. Before this it was thought
 that the guitar did not have the volume for this type
 of venue.

 1946 Nylon replaces gut as a string material

 http://earlymusiccharango.blogspot.com/


  ___
 Yahoo! Answers - Got a question? Someone out there knows the answer. Try
 it
 now.
 http://uk.answers.yahoo.com/



 To get on or off this list see list information at
 http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html




[VIHUELA] Re: who invented the guitar

2007-05-21 Thread bill kilpatrick
your goodselves and google are all i've got!

inaccuracy on the internet is bad enough but coupled
with a failing memory ... it's a real problem ... to
wit:

i remember reading ... somewhere ... that the canary
island timple was introduced to the islands by arab
miners brought from n. africa to work the mines there.
 it's possible that the figure 8 shape could have
traveled back to the maghreb from iberia but i suspect
the opposite is more likely.

could a half-section of an hour-glass gourd be the
source of the figure 8 shape?

- bill
 
--- Monica Hall [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

 I am afraid Google has got most of it wrong.
 
 The term guitarra/quinterne etc, in medieval sources
 does not necessarily
 refer to the figure of eight shaped instrument at
 all but to a type of small
 lute.
 
 I can't go into all the details but Tinctoris
 describes the guitar as 
 follows
 
 
 -a small tortoise shaped instrument invented by the
 Catalans which some call 
 ghiterra, others ghiterna
 
 
 
 The ghiterra is used most rarely, because of the
 thinness of its sound. 
 When I heard it in Catalonia, it was being used much
 more often by women, to 
 accompany their love songs, than by men.
 
 
 
 In other words the instrument is a small lute or
 mandora.
 
 
 
 The vihuela is described as
 
 
 
 -an instrument invented by the Spanish, which both
 they and the Italians 
 call the viola, but the French the demi-luth.
 
 
 -this viola differs from the lute in that the lute
 is much larger and 
 tortoise-shaped, while the viola is flat, and in
 most cases curved inwards 
 on each side.
 
 
 
 The relevant article to read is still
 
 
 
 Lawrence Wright - The medieval gittern and citole :
 a case of mistaken 
 identity
 
 
 
 in Galpin Society Journal, Vol. 30, 1977, p.8-42.
 
 
 
 Mudarra is indeed the first person known to have
 published music for the 
 4-course guitar.
 
 
 
 Only five of the books printed between 1550-1555 are
 by Leroy  Ballard. 
 The rest are by Morlaye/Gorlier.   They do not
 include any 5-course music.
 
 
 
 There is a lot missing from the rest of it but I
 haven't time to write a 
 book on the subject at present..
 
 
 
 Don't believe everything you find on the Internet.
 
 
 
 Monica
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 - Original Message - 
 From: bill kilpatrick [EMAIL PROTECTED]
 To: vihuela@cs.dartmouth.edu
 Sent: Monday, May 21, 2007 2:23 PM
 Subject: [VIHUELA] who invented the guitar
 
 
  gleaned the following from a 5c. vihuela alert
 on
  google in response to the question of who
 invented
  the guitar? ... anything missing?:
 
  1265 Juan Gil of Zamora mentions the early guitar
 in
  Ars Musica.
 
  1283-1350 Guitarra Latina  Guitar Moresca are
  mentioned multiple times in the poems of the
  Archpriest of Hita
 
  1306 A gitarer was played at the Feast of
  Westminster in England
 
  1404 Der mynnen regein by Eberhard Von Cersne
 makes
  reference to a quinterne.
 
  1487 Johannes Tinctoris described the guitarra as
  being invented by the Catalans. This refers to the
  four course guitar. Each course represents one
 pair of
  double strings.
 
  1546 Tres Libros de Musica en Cifras para
 Vihuela by
  Alonso Mudarra is the first publication to include
  music for guitar.
 
  1551-1555 Nine books of tablature were published
 by
  Adrian Le Roy. These include the first pieces for
 5
  course guitar. The addition of the fifth course
 was
  attributed to Vicente Espinel
 
  1600-1650 Many publications of tablature for the
  guitar. It's popularity begins to rival the lute.
 
  1674 Publication of Guitarre Royal by F.
 Corbetta
  increased the guitar's popularity. It was
 dedicated to
  Louis XIV.
 
  1770-1800 A sixth string was added to the guitar
 and
  the courses were replaced by single strings.
 
  1800-1850 Guitar enjoyed a large popularity both
 in
  performances and publishing. Fernando Sor, Mauro
  Guiliani, Matteo Carcassi and Dioniso Aguado all
  performed, taught, wrote and had published their
  compositions.
 
  1850-1892 Guitar maker Antonio de Torres develops
 the
  larger more resonant instrument we know today.
 
  1916 Segovia performs at Ateneo, the most
 important
  concert hall in Madrid. Before this it was thought
  that the guitar did not have the volume for this
 type
  of venue.
 
  1946 Nylon replaces gut as a string material
 
  http://earlymusiccharango.blogspot.com/
 
 
  

___
  Yahoo! Answers - Got a question? Someone out there
 knows the answer. Try
  it
  now.
  http://uk.answers.yahoo.com/
 
 
 
  To get on or off this list see list information at
 

http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html
 
 


http://earlymusiccharango.blogspot.com/


  ___
Yahoo! Answers - Got a question? Someone out there knows the answer. Try it
now.
http://uk.answers.yahoo.com/ 




[VIHUELA] Re: who invented the guitar

2007-05-21 Thread William Bartlett
Maybe all the people playing gourd  tub shaped instruments saw a female walk 
by and decided that would be a more visually acceptable shape.

bill kilpatrick [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:  your goodselves and google are all 
i've got!

inaccuracy on the internet is bad enough but coupled
with a failing memory ... it's a real problem ... to
wit:

i remember reading ... somewhere ... that the canary
island timple was introduced to the islands by arab
miners brought from n. africa to work the mines there.
it's possible that the figure 8 shape could have
traveled back to the maghreb from iberia but i suspect
the opposite is more likely.

could a half-section of an hour-glass gourd be the
source of the figure 8 shape?

- bill

--- Monica Hall wrote:

 I am afraid Google has got most of it wrong.
 
 The term guitarra/quinterne etc, in medieval sources
 does not necessarily
 refer to the figure of eight shaped instrument at
 all but to a type of small
 lute.
 
 I can't go into all the details but Tinctoris
 describes the guitar as 
 follows
 
 
 -a small tortoise shaped instrument invented by the
 Catalans which some call 
 ghiterra, others ghiterna
 
 
 
 The ghiterra is used most rarely, because of the
 thinness of its sound. 
 When I heard it in Catalonia, it was being used much
 more often by women, to 
 accompany their love songs, than by men.
 
 
 
 In other words the instrument is a small lute or
 mandora.
 
 
 
 The vihuela is described as
 
 
 
 -an instrument invented by the Spanish, which both
 they and the Italians 
 call the viola, but the French the demi-luth.
 
 
 -this viola differs from the lute in that the lute
 is much larger and 
 tortoise-shaped, while the viola is flat, and in
 most cases curved inwards 
 on each side.
 
 
 
 The relevant article to read is still
 
 
 
 Lawrence Wright - The medieval gittern and citole :
 a case of mistaken 
 identity
 
 
 
 in Galpin Society Journal, Vol. 30, 1977, p.8-42.
 
 
 
 Mudarra is indeed the first person known to have
 published music for the 
 4-course guitar.
 
 
 
 Only five of the books printed between 1550-1555 are
 by Leroy  Ballard. 
 The rest are by Morlaye/Gorlier. They do not
 include any 5-course music.
 
 
 
 There is a lot missing from the rest of it but I
 haven't time to write a 
 book on the subject at present..
 
 
 
 Don't believe everything you find on the Internet.
 
 
 
 Monica
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 - Original Message - 
 From: bill kilpatrick 
 To: 
 Sent: Monday, May 21, 2007 2:23 PM
 Subject: [VIHUELA] who invented the guitar
 
 
  gleaned the following from a 5c. vihuela alert
 on
  google in response to the question of who
 invented
  the guitar? ... anything missing?:
 
  1265 Juan Gil of Zamora mentions the early guitar
 in
  Ars Musica.
 
  1283-1350 Guitarra Latina  Guitar Moresca are
  mentioned multiple times in the poems of the
  Archpriest of Hita
 
  1306 A gitarer was played at the Feast of
  Westminster in England
 
  1404 Der mynnen regein by Eberhard Von Cersne
 makes
  reference to a quinterne.
 
  1487 Johannes Tinctoris described the guitarra as
  being invented by the Catalans. This refers to the
  four course guitar. Each course represents one
 pair of
  double strings.
 
  1546 Tres Libros de Musica en Cifras para
 Vihuela by
  Alonso Mudarra is the first publication to include
  music for guitar.
 
  1551-1555 Nine books of tablature were published
 by
  Adrian Le Roy. These include the first pieces for
 5
  course guitar. The addition of the fifth course
 was
  attributed to Vicente Espinel
 
  1600-1650 Many publications of tablature for the
  guitar. It's popularity begins to rival the lute.
 
  1674 Publication of Guitarre Royal by F.
 Corbetta
  increased the guitar's popularity. It was
 dedicated to
  Louis XIV.
 
  1770-1800 A sixth string was added to the guitar
 and
  the courses were replaced by single strings.
 
  1800-1850 Guitar enjoyed a large popularity both
 in
  performances and publishing. Fernando Sor, Mauro
  Guiliani, Matteo Carcassi and Dioniso Aguado all
  performed, taught, wrote and had published their
  compositions.
 
  1850-1892 Guitar maker Antonio de Torres develops
 the
  larger more resonant instrument we know today.
 
  1916 Segovia performs at Ateneo, the most
 important
  concert hall in Madrid. Before this it was thought
  that the guitar did not have the volume for this
 type
  of venue.
 
  1946 Nylon replaces gut as a string material
 
  http://earlymusiccharango.blogspot.com/
 
 
  

___
  Yahoo! Answers - Got a question? Someone out there
 knows the answer. Try
  it
  now.
  http://uk.answers.yahoo.com/
 
 
 
  To get on or off this list see list information at
 

http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html
 
 


http://earlymusiccharango.blogspot.com/


___
Yahoo! Answers - Got a question? Someone out there knows the answer. Try it
now.

[VIHUELA] Re: who invented the guitar

2007-05-21 Thread John Griffiths
What good humoured discussion!

I think that Pepe Rey hit the nail on the head in his book on Spanish  
plectrum instruments (Juan Jose Rey and Antonio Navarro, Los  
instrumentos de pua en Espa=F1a. Bandurria, c=EDtola y laudes espa=F1oles.  
Madrid: Alianza Editorial, 1993). His argument makes us realise that  
in looking for the identity of an instrument through its shape is  
only one of the possibilities. He suggests that the use of the term  
guitarra in Spain for figure of 8 instruments possibly comes from  
the late 15th century when the small 8-shaped instrument began to  
used to replace the gittern (also called guitarra in Spanish) as the  
upper instrument in the lute-gittern ensembles that were prevalent at  
that time. In other words, an instrument of different morphology took  
on the role of the guitarra and the name stuck because the function  
was the same. Without going into more detail here, there is  
considerable corroborating evidence to support this explanation.

The curves of the figure of 8 are to do, in my view, with the  
relationship with the fiddle. Medieval fiddles were oval in shape  
until players needed to be able to boy strings individually rather  
than all strings at once. This can be well documented through  
iconography. These instruments developed multiple performance  
practices, both bowing and plucking, then eventually separated into  
different streams.

That's what the evidence tells me, at least.
Greetings,
John


On 22/05/2007, at 7:17, Stuart Walsh wrote:

 Nowadays it seems that most people - following Laurence Wright - agree
 that the (medieval) gittern was a small, lute-like instrument. In
 Groves, Wright notes that,  in the sources, there is nothing to prefer
 gittern-variant spellings (such as gythron, gitterne etc. I haven't  
 got
 Groves to hand so I'm improvising here) over guitar-variant spellings.
 We just call the little instrument the gittern, but it was also
 sometimes referred to as guitar.

 So instruments known as guitars go back  a few centuries before the  
 mid
 1550s. And so Bill's question still stands: who invented the guitar?
 (Though it's not likely to get an answer!)

 I'm  fairly sure that Wright's view is that the small, figure-of-eight
 shaped' guitar' of the mid 16th century is a new form of the old
 'guitar' (gittern, quintern etc)...whereas the orthodoxy of the  
 last few
 decades has been to claim that it is futile to trace the guitar back
 before the mid16th century.

 But the (medieval) gittern seems to have a more promising Renaissance
 (and beyond) descendant in the mandore/mandora - a small lute-like
 instrument, rather than the figure-of-eight guitar.

 The way I interpret Wright's position is that the mandore/mandora sort
 of pops into existence in the late 16th century. But the guitar goes
 back into medieval times. On the other hand the current orthodoxy is
 that the guitar pops into existence in the mid 16th century. Neither
 view seems right.






 I am afraid Google has got most of it wrong.

 The term guitarra/quinterne etc, in medieval sources does not  
 necessarily
 refer to the figure of eight shaped instrument at all but to a  
 type of small
 lute.

 I can't go into all the details but Tinctoris describes the guitar as
 follows


 -a small tortoise shaped instrument invented by the Catalans which  
 some call
 ghiterra, others ghiterna



 The ghiterra is used most rarely, because of the thinness of its  
 sound.
 When I heard it in Catalonia, it was being used much more often by  
 women, to
 accompany their love songs, than by men.



 In other words the instrument is a small lute or mandora.



 The vihuela is described as



 -an instrument invented by the Spanish, which both they and the  
 Italians
 call the viola, but the French the demi-luth.


 -this viola differs from the lute in that the lute is much larger and
 tortoise-shaped, while the viola is flat, and in most cases curved  
 inwards
 on each side.



 The relevant article to read is still



 Lawrence Wright - The medieval gittern and citole : a case of  
 mistaken
 identity



 in Galpin Society Journal, Vol. 30, 1977, p.8-42.



 Mudarra is indeed the first person known to have published music  
 for the
 4-course guitar.



 Only five of the books printed between 1550-1555 are by Leroy   
 Ballard.
 The rest are by Morlaye/Gorlier.   They do not include any 5- 
 course music.



 There is a lot missing from the rest of it but I haven't time to  
 write a
 book on the subject at present..



 Don't believe everything you find on the Internet.



 Monica







 - Original Message -
 From: bill kilpatrick [EMAIL PROTECTED]
 To: vihuela@cs.dartmouth.edu
 Sent: Monday, May 21, 2007 2:23 PM
 Subject: [VIHUELA] who invented the guitar



 gleaned the following from a 5c. vihuela alert on
 google in response to the question of who invented
 the guitar? ... anything missing?:

 1265 Juan Gil of Zamora mentions the early guitar in
 Ars