Re: [volt-nuts] How can I make a 2000 V DC meter with an input resistance of at least 100 T ohms?

2018-03-23 Thread ed breya
Regarding making your own extreme high-value resistors - any object that has insulators and leads but with nothing connected inside will have some high R that can be perhaps be measured, but won't be stable against environment effects on the outer surfaces. There's not much point to carbonizing

Re: [volt-nuts] How can I make a 2000 V DC meter with an input resistance of at least 100 T ohms?

2018-03-23 Thread ed breya
I'm guessing the application relates back to your leaf electrometer project discussed earlier - trying to assess how the bias charge on the capacitor holds up from leakage and use of the instrument. If this is the case, then it's for a one-time use for design of the item, so shouldn't be too fa

Re: [volt-nuts] Bohnenberger electrometer

2018-03-16 Thread ed breya
Yes Hendrik, same principle as the butterfly disk style, but mine use cylinders - the field exposure is radial instead of axial.  Ed ___ volt-nuts mailing list -- volt-nuts@febo.com To unsubscribe, go to https://www.febo.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/vo

Re: [volt-nuts] Bohnenberger electrometer

2018-03-16 Thread ed breya
There is another kind of static electric field meter that was commonly used over the past few decades for monitoring charges/voltages in work areas dealing with sensitive semiconductors. It has a small motor spinning a hollow brass cylinder that has a radial hole or slot that alternately shield

Re: [volt-nuts] Bohnenberger electrometer DANGER

2018-03-08 Thread ed breya
Here's a simplistic view that may be sufficient. Some energy (in the form of charge redistribution, which includes current flow) has to come from the capacitor, and some from the input signal, to do the work needed to push the leaf against gravity. When the input signal is removed, some of the

Re: [volt-nuts] Vibrating reed electrometers

2018-03-08 Thread ed breya
Curiosity forced me to look around a little more for info on the 640. The first link includes some info on the 640 with pictures. The vibrating capacitor thing looks like a sort of vacuum tube. I thought maybe it was custom made by or for Keithley, but it seems to actually have been an off-shel

Re: [volt-nuts] Bohnenberger electrometer

2018-03-06 Thread ed breya
I looked at that link that Brooke put up about Bohnenberger's Electroscope. I don't know what your specific arrangement needs to be, but it appears you need a plus and a minus HV wrt ground in the most general form. If so, then this would mean having to split the voltage of a single cap, or hav

Re: [volt-nuts] Vibrating reed electrometers

2018-03-06 Thread ed breya
Another thing I noticed in these instruments - the highest R value used is E12, even though decades higher would have been appropriate in certain ranges. It shows that was about the practical limit for somewhat decent precision and cost. Filling in the desired higher ranges had to be done by ad

Re: [volt-nuts] Bohnenberger electrometer

2018-03-06 Thread ed breya
Oops - forgot to mention a detail about microwave oven caps. Sometimes they have built-in bleeder resistors, which would of course spoil this kind of application.  Ed ___ volt-nuts mailing list -- volt-nuts@febo.com To unsubscribe, go to https://www.f

Re: [volt-nuts] Vibrating reed electrometers

2018-03-06 Thread ed breya
Yup - Keithley 640 - that must be the one. This stirred my memory somewhat, and I just located info on the model 642 also, which was apparently newer. The 642 went to (or back to) ultra-low bias MOSFETs, while keeping sapphire insulation and a separate input head. The MOSFETs need all kinds of

Re: [volt-nuts] Bohnenberger electrometer

2018-03-06 Thread ed breya
For static bias, look up "electret" for ideas on some other possible options. I would recommend against your option 2 capacitor - that's a dangerous amount of energy to store in something that may be fooled around with experimentally. Also, even though it's a lot of C, being electrolytic, the

Re: [volt-nuts] Precision high resistance measurements / calibration of HP 4339B high-resistance meter.

2018-03-02 Thread ed breya
Oops - I think I didn't send this message properly yesterday - here goes again. Ed Yes, David, unless you go to very extreme measures, you won't see real R values that have any practical meaning beyond E12 ohms or so. Most practical insulation Rs may be around E12-E14 tops, unless you go to s

Re: [volt-nuts] Best way to measure micro Ohms

2017-10-03 Thread ed breya
Coincidental to all this micro-ohms and nanovolt talk, I've been doing some severe large scale garage cleaning to thin stuff out. I found that audio amplifier that I mentioned earlier, that is good for some LIA reference driver applications. I also found my low-level measurement notebooks, incl

Re: [volt-nuts] Best way to measure micro Ohms

2017-09-28 Thread ed breya
Hmm. Alternating the direction of the current repeatedly and processing the results - sure seems like that is fundamentally an AC measurement too, despite using DC measurement equipment. Ed ___ volt-nuts mailing list -- volt-nuts@febo.com To unsubscr

Re: [volt-nuts] Best way to measure micro Ohms

2017-09-27 Thread ed breya
I just noticed this discussion recently, so I'm late to the party, but that never stops me from adding my one-cent's worth. David, regardless of the aluminum and other material issues, I think your initial idea of using a lock-in analyzer is definitely the way to go. I'm very fond of LIAs, alt

Re: [volt-nuts] low emf solder

2016-10-28 Thread ed breya
I would recommend against trying to use cadmium - it's very toxic, which is why Cd-based solders are rare nowadays. They are probably still made, but for lab or industrial use with proper handling. If you try to alloy it with Sn yourself without proper handling, you could get poisoned. You can'

Re: [volt-nuts] Anyone know how to make stable inductors?

2015-08-21 Thread Ed Breya
Sorry about the previous double-posting - had email problems. There is another option that occurred to me last night, to get an equivalent inductor from an accurate reference capacitor by using an active circuit gyrator. The problem of course is that the circuit will add errors too, diminishin

Re: [volt-nuts] Anyone know how to make stable inductors?

2015-08-21 Thread Ed Breya
Haha, so it is legit - just a poorly described knock-off of the H-P unit. I had never heard of this unit, but it looks like good info to have, to replicate some equivalent reference inductors. Thanks for finding this document. Ed ___ volt-nuts mailin

Re: [volt-nuts] Anyone know how to make stable inductors?

2015-08-21 Thread Ed Breya
Haha, so it is legit - just a poorly decribed knock-off of the H-P unit. I had never heard of this unit, but it looks like good info to have, to replicate some equivalent reference inductors. Thanks for finding this document. Ed ___ volt-nuts mailing

Re: [volt-nuts] Anyone know how to make stable inductors?

2015-08-20 Thread Ed Breya
The method described in the document would not make an actual inductor - it apparently fools the 4-port machine by providing the equivalent signals that the inductance would have. You can avoid getting precision inductors, and just go with this method (which I think is pretty clever if it actua

Re: [volt-nuts] How are femto-amps measured?

2015-06-06 Thread Ed Breya
Yes, the input DC bias current can be compensated for, as long as it doesn't change too quickly, or isn't too big to make the input amplifier circuits run out of dynamic range. In a digital meter environment, all sorts of auto-zeroing and multi-sloping things and digital signal processing can b

Re: [volt-nuts] How are femto-amps measured?

2015-06-05 Thread Ed Breya
With modern digital readout meters, this can be very misleading in terms of actual useable capability. In this case, using the specified highest sensitivity 100 pA range, and six digits of digital resolution, gives E-10 A/E6 or E-16 A, which is 100 aA for the last digit. But, looking at the noi

Re: [volt-nuts] HP 3456A Input Impedance Check

2015-03-19 Thread ed breya
You should include the effects of input bias current - the maximum should be specified, and likely in the pA range at room temperature. Just put a very high resistance from input to common, and read the voltage to calculate the current at zero input. Likewise, you can connect the resistor to va

Re: [volt-nuts] OCD About My HP419A Attenuator Switch Gold Plated Contacts

2015-03-11 Thread ed breya
Forgot about the chopper assembly - washing would probably not be good for it. Ed Yes, you are being a little too OCD about this. Instrument washing issues come up often, and there are plenty of opinions available - here are some of mine: In the 419s that I have, the battery leakage crud ha

Re: [volt-nuts] OCD About My HP419A Attenuator Switch Gold Plated Contacts

2015-03-11 Thread ed breya
Yes, you are being a little too OCD about this. Instrument washing issues come up often, and there are plenty of opinions available - here are some of mine: In the 419s that I have, the battery leakage crud has not gone beyond the circuit boards or maybe the edge connectors. Cleaning the board

Re: [volt-nuts] HP 3456A -3 Fault

2014-12-28 Thread ed breya
I agree these caps are the most failure-prone parts in the 3456A, and also the 3455A. Sometimes they also cause damage to other parts like the associated three-terminal regulators. Don't be surprised if there's still more to fix after cap replacement - but usually easy to find. I had one where

Re: [volt-nuts] HP419A Meter Pegged to Right

2014-11-11 Thread ed breya
If you're talking about washing the board only, I'd say go for it. Just run the hottest tap water on it, and a little liquid dishwashing detergent, and scrub it thoroughly with an old toothbrush. Then lots of rinsing and drying - compressed air can knock out a lot water from parts that may trap

Re: [volt-nuts] current-nut question .. total waste of ones time type question

2014-04-30 Thread ed breya
I agree with John on this one - put in another meter socket downstream if you really want to experiment, and be sure to have a main disconnect besides the utility's meter. If you are changing the service entrance, you will likely have issues with the local permits for it, and with the utility

Re: [volt-nuts] 34401A Why 10M ohm default i/p resistance?

2014-04-10 Thread ed breya
Only specialized meters can provide virtually infinite input R at voltages above the 10 to 20 V or so native range of conventional amplifiers, so you have to use some kind of attenuator to cover the higher ranges anyway. 10 megs and 1 meg (and sometimes 11) are the traditional values used, with

Re: [volt-nuts] 34401A Why 10M ohm default i/p resistance?

2014-04-10 Thread ed breya
Only specialized meters can provide virtually infinite input R at voltages above the 10 to 20 V or so native range of conventional amplifiers, so you have to use some kind of attenuator to cover the higher ranges anyway. 10 megs and 1 meg (and sometimes 11) are the traditional values used, with

Re: [volt-nuts] Temperature controller for ovenizing and temperature cycling

2014-01-30 Thread ed breya
I think you'll get better stability by using a resistive thermistor as the sensor. As far as I know, all commercial oven circuits for OCXOs and the like use RTDs, and not IC sensors, for best performance. Ed ___ volt-nuts mailing list -- volt-nuts@fe

Re: [volt-nuts] monitoring LTZ1000 chip temperature

2014-01-28 Thread ed breya
<<< No Message Collected >>> ___ volt-nuts mailing list -- volt-nuts@febo.com To unsubscribe, go to https://www.febo.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/volt-nuts and follow the instructions there.

Re: [volt-nuts] monitoring LTZ1000 chip temperature

2014-01-28 Thread ed breya
If I understand what you're trying to do, I think you may be able to run the experiment backwards to more easily figure it out. I'd recommend focusing on junction to case characteristics first - the case to ambient will have a lot of variables. With the case attached to an "infinite" heat sink

Re: [volt-nuts] Cool looking old stuff

2013-08-09 Thread ed breya
Sometimes the old stuff is still the best. At room temperature, a mechanical chopper combined with a high-ratio step up transformer and high impedance follower amplifier is unbeatable for low noise, low impedance signal amplification. The solid state devices that replaced mechanical choppers in

Re: [volt-nuts] Semi-precision high resistance measurement

2013-06-21 Thread ed breya
This is now the third try at sending a message to the group. Here's what I wrote before: I sent this on the 18th, but it didn't show up, so here goes another try. I don't know if something's wrong with my email. Please excuse if the redundant original shows up too. Original message: Yes, it

Re: [volt-nuts] Data Proof 160A

2013-03-30 Thread ed breya
I believe you'll find that those are not special low-emf relays - they are also known as "printact" relays, used in some HP and Tektronix equipment of the era for signal switching. Since they latch in either state, no coil power is needed to keep it, so the temperature can stabilize at ambient,

Re: [volt-nuts] 7081 AC buffer *again*

2013-01-29 Thread Ed Breya
I agree with JL - it's either picking up an available frequency, or making its own. Oscillation can happen with transistors, especially any common-base amplifiers or emitter followers that don't have enough degeneration - but that is usually in the VHF range. For MHz-type oscillations, look for

Re: [volt-nuts] Some questions to zeners (1N823-1N829)

2013-01-27 Thread Ed Breya
Andreas, I think your expectations are not realistic - even if you could make such a reference, you could not transport its voltage to the ADC without thermoelectric effects causing error that would swamp the performance. To keep everything below the 1 ppm/deg C range you would have to put the

Re: [volt-nuts] Some questions to zeners (1N823-1N829)

2013-01-26 Thread Ed Breya
Don't bother with TC zeners, especially for battery operated equipment. There are lots of nice IC references available from Analog Devices, Maxim, Linear Technology, TI, an so on, that will run rings around TCZs - you probably haven't seen the right one yet. The TCZs will only provide near zero

Re: [volt-nuts] New Life of the Solartron 7081

2013-01-10 Thread Ed Breya
Yes, very impressive - Solartron should hire you as a consultant to design or improve their current products. Ed ___ volt-nuts mailing list -- volt-nuts@febo.com To unsubscribe, go to https://www.febo.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/volt-nuts and follow

Re: [volt-nuts] Datron 4000 DC/I/R Standard

2012-12-18 Thread ed breya
That seems like a nice piece of equipment if it works or is easily repairable. Why do you assume the displays are broken? If they used gas discharge displays, they would likely be Nixie or Panaplex type, which are pretty durable, and are still common enough to not be a problem with procurement.

Re: [volt-nuts] Solartron 7150plus - Chasing AC gremlins

2012-12-07 Thread ed breya
I would first look at the electromechanical aspects. Are there any relays or connectors in the signal path? Next would be any device sockets - they can be exercised by rocking the parts a little. Next would be to inspect carefully for bad solder joints, corrosion, and signs of physical damage.

[volt-nuts] How long can standard cells last?

2012-11-29 Thread ed breya
I just junked out a very beat up old Fluke 803 differential voltmeter, and found deep within, an old-school Cd/Hg standard cell. It was well protected in an aluminum box, and wrapped in foam and foil. It looks brand-new, and still measures around 1.018... V. I'd like to keep this one as another

Re: [volt-nuts] 731A output impedance

2012-11-28 Thread ed breya
If you do modify the circuit, you will probably want to decrease the series R. Even though the external loads are likely to be in the megohm range, the feedback load is significant, and likely the biggest part, except for fault conditions. For lowest noise and suppression of effects due to bias

Re: [volt-nuts] 731A output impedance

2012-11-27 Thread ed breya
I'm not sure how much elaboration is needed, but here's some: If you take all of the feedback from the output terminal, that's better for DC accuracy by eliminating the voltage drop of the series resistor, while still providing some overload protection to the opamp. But, it also decreases phas

Re: [volt-nuts] 731A output impedance

2012-11-27 Thread ed breya
The simplest way to drop the output impedance without adding much circuitry is to just change the series R to 100 ohms or so - that would still give pretty good isolation from capacitive loading. If the R is dropped to zero, the DC performance will be best, but you'll have to worry about the a

Re: [volt-nuts] Fluke 731B parts xref

2012-11-21 Thread ed breya
Current regulator diodes are typically JFETs with gate-source tied so that their Idss is more or less constant over a wide voltage range. Anything in the 1 mA to 50 mA range can be replicated by selecting common JFETs for the right Idss, up to 40 V or so, or by selecting one with slightly highe

[volt-nuts] HP 740A

2012-10-13 Thread ed breya
I recently acquired for cheap an old HP 740A DC standard/voltmeter of 1960s vintage. It seems to be pretty clean inside and complete except for missing a small bias cell. I'm trying to find a manual - found the "B" version one so far at hparchive. Before putting in much effort to fire it up, d

Re: [volt-nuts] HP 3458A DC current accuracy

2012-07-11 Thread ed breya
Yes, the effect can be estimated quite easily. Also, keep in mind that the 0.13 nV is the RMS noise, so the peak to peak excursions can be around six times that, or almost 1 nV p-p. If the FS is 1 mA, then it's about 1 ppm - one count on a six digit DVM, or ten times more with each additional d

Re: [volt-nuts] HP 3458A DC current accuracy

2012-07-11 Thread ed breya
That which is more fundamental to the problem is the unavoidable (at room temperature) noise from the resistors. Even a "perfect" resistor with zero tempco has noise, so if you use resistors to measure current with a high-precision voltmeter, eventually you reach a resolution where the noise be

Re: [volt-nuts] Help with 7081 AC buffer circuit

2012-06-08 Thread ed breya
Does that matter on the AC buffer in this case? Maybe that's the normal 1/f noise of the circuit down near DC. If it is problematic, then you may want to try reconditioning the low level signal relay contacts. You can rig up a circuit with a 9V battery and a 1 k or so ohm resistor, temporarily