RE: [Vo]:Re: "Tooo" obvious for Detroit?

2008-03-10 Thread Jed Rothwell
Lawrence de Bivort wrote: My general proposition is that when systems, like corporations, become 'too big' that due to the internal dynamics of bigness they come to act overall at a mediocre level of intelligence. This does seem to be the case. This and other related problems are described in

RE: [Vo]:Re: "Tooo" obvious for Detroit? Oragnization and performance

2008-03-10 Thread Lawrence de Bivort
gist What do you think? Lawrence -Original Message- From: Robin van Spaandonk [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Sunday, March 09, 2008 5:21 PM To: vortex-l@eskimo.com Subject: Re: [Vo]:Re: "Tooo" obvious for Detroit? In reply to Lawrence de Bivort's message of Sun, 9 Ma

Re: [Vo]:Re: "Tooo" obvious for Detroit?

2008-03-09 Thread Robin van Spaandonk
In reply to Lawrence de Bivort's message of Sun, 9 Mar 2008 08:52:34 -0400: Hi, [snip] >Partly it is a matter of Reverting to the Mean, and partly a matter of there >being only so many genuinely brilliant leaders and with size their net >impact is diluted by the inevitable bulk of mediocre people

RE: [Vo]:Re: "Tooo" obvious for Detroit?

2008-03-09 Thread Lawrence de Bivort
re failures, until American management begins to study the dynamics I allude to. And, no, Ford and GM have not been clients of mine. Unfortunately. Cheers, Lawrence -Original Message- From: Jones Beene [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, March 05, 2008 12:39 PM To: vortex Subjec

Re: [Vo]:Re: "Tooo" obvious for Detroit?

2008-03-08 Thread Robin van Spaandonk
In reply to R C Macaulay's message of Sat, 8 Mar 2008 11:58:06 -0600: Hi, [snip] >Yep, Philip, > > >We have unit 3 & 4 nuke plant starting construction soon at Bay City Texas.. >part of the South Texas project. They are having their share of the problems >using a Jap design .. plus the environme

Re: [Vo]:Re: "Tooo" obvious for Detroit?

2008-03-08 Thread R C Macaulay
Yep, Philip, We have unit 3 & 4 nuke plant starting construction soon at Bay City Texas.. part of the South Texas project. They are having their share of the problems using a Jap design .. plus the environmental problems to overcome. The problem with Nukes are... They can operate some 40-50 ye

Re: [Vo]:Re: "Tooo" obvious for Detroit?

2008-03-08 Thread PHILIP WINESTONE
and his group, read "Disturbing the Universe" by Freeman Dyson. This is what you could call "one-dimensional thinking." P. - Original Message From: R C Macaulay <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: vortex-l@eskimo.com Sent: Saturday, March 8, 2008 8:33:41 AM Subject: Re: [Vo

Re: [Vo]:Re: "Tooo" obvious for Detroit?

2008-03-08 Thread R C Macaulay
al Message - From: "thomas malloy" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: Sent: Saturday, March 08, 2008 12:38 AM Subject: Re: [Vo]:Re: "Tooo" obvious for Detroit? Terry Blanton wrote: I can't allow the denigration of engineers in the automotive industry continue. I had a friend

Re: [Vo]:Re: "Tooo" obvious for Detroit?

2008-03-07 Thread thomas malloy
Terry Blanton wrote: I can't allow the denigration of engineers in the automotive industry continue. I had a friend who was an engineering manager in Detroit I agree, IMHO, it's the MBA's and the lawyers. --- http://USFamily.Net/dialup.html - $8.25/mo! -- http://www.usfamily.net/dsl.html

Re: [Vo]:Re: "Tooo" obvious for Detroit?

2008-03-06 Thread Terry Blanton
I can't allow the denigration of engineers in the automotive industry continue. I had a friend who was an engineering manager in Detroit and he said that the reason they built $hitty cars was management and marketing. The engineers battled constantly for design and manufacturing standards only to

[Vo]:Re: "Tooo" obvious for Detroit?

2008-03-05 Thread Jones Beene
--- Richard: > Howdy Vorts. It was not my intent to create an atmosphere of hostility among us by making the remark... Hey- no hostility. As usual on Vo, we are often arguing past each other anyway - while trying to squeeze in a relevant point or two ... which the other party doesn't necessarily

Re: [Vo]:Re: "Tooo" obvious for Detroit?

2008-03-05 Thread Mike Carrell
MC: Jones is a very sophistcated and clever man, author of thought-provoking posts. But he can missd the point in a very complex subject. People in general, including Jones, do the best they can within the vision that they have and organizations they work for. - ...even through in fairne

[Vo]:Re: "Tooo" obvious for Detroit?

2008-03-05 Thread Jones Beene
--- Lawrence de Bivort wrote: > Jones, in fairness, your truncation does miss my point. Repost with the full quotation beyond the '...' and I'll be glad to respond. Yes, no problem. I hate it when someone does this to me, even if I find myself agreeing with the strained point which they were mak

RE: [Vo]:Re: "Tooo" obvious for Detroit?

2008-03-05 Thread Lawrence de Bivort
Jones, in fairness, your truncation does miss my point. Repost with the full quotation beyond the '...' and I'll be glad to respond. Lawrence -Original Message- From: Jones Beene [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, March 05, 2008 11:07 AM To: vortex Subject:

[Vo]:Re: "Tooo" obvious for Detroit?

2008-03-05 Thread Jones Beene
--- Lawrence de Bivort wrote: > My sense is that everyone does the best they can - all the time. It is perhaps the greatest tragedy of mankind that we can see better ways of doing things... One the contrary, Lawrence, I strongly believe that this is absolutely wrong... so wrong that it is "not