Re: [Vo]:Revisiting The "Whipmag" All-Magnet Motor, saga

2011-08-14 Thread mixent
In reply to Harry Veeder's message of Thu, 11 Aug 2011 11:38:13 -0700 (PDT): Hi, [snip] >> Actually the old argument is correct, in concept, but wrong in magnitude. >> In order to come down in exactly the same spot (assuming a perfectly vertical >> jump), one would have to maintain the same angula

Re: [Vo]:Revisiting The "Whipmag" All-Magnet Motor, saga

2011-08-11 Thread Harry Veeder
- Original Message - > From: "mix...@bigpond.com" > To: "vortex-l@eskimo.com" > Cc: > Sent: Saturday, August 6, 2011 6:19:54 PM > Subject: Re: [Vo]:Revisiting The "Whipmag" All-Magnet Motor, saga > > In reply to  Harry Veeder'

Re: [Vo]:Revisiting The "Whipmag" All-Magnet Motor, saga

2011-08-06 Thread mixent
In reply to Harry Veeder's message of Mon, 1 Aug 2011 19:22:34 -0700 (PDT): Hi, [snip] >This reminds me of a pre 17th century argument that the Earth cannot be >turning. >As everyone knows if the Earth was turning then the ground would move away >from you whenever you jumped in the air. However 

Re: [Vo]:Revisiting The "Whipmag" All-Magnet Motor, saga

2011-08-01 Thread Harry Veeder
- Original Message - > From: OrionWorks - Steven V Johnson > To: vortex-l@eskimo.com > Cc: > Sent: Monday, August 1, 2011 5:39:36 PM > Subject: Re: [Vo]:Revisiting The "Whipmag" All-Magnet Motor, saga > > However, despite my lack of funding & no sho

Re: [Vo]:Revisiting The "Whipmag" All-Magnet Motor, saga

2011-08-01 Thread Terry Blanton
On Mon, Aug 1, 2011 at 5:39 PM, OrionWorks - Steven V Johnson wrote: > My initial interest was strongly biased towards speculating on whether > an asymmetry might begin to manifest in "Alsetalokin's" ROTOR/STATOR > configuration if everything could be carefully choreographed with a > customized g

Re: [Vo]:Revisiting The "Whipmag" All-Magnet Motor, saga

2011-08-01 Thread OrionWorks - Steven V Johnson
>From Terry: > Well, Clanzer, and others, built exact replicas to no avail. > I would not advise you to follow suit. I wasn't planning on it. My initial interest was strongly biased towards speculating on whether an asymmetry might begin to manifest in "Alsetalokin's" ROTOR/STATOR configuration

Re: [Vo]:Revisiting The "Whipmag" All-Magnet Motor, saga

2011-08-01 Thread Terry Blanton
On Mon, Aug 1, 2011 at 2:32 PM, OrionWorks - Steven V Johnson wrote: > As for me, I'm tapped out cash wise. ... the garage is a mess, too. Well, Clanzer, and others, built exact replicas to no avail. I would not advise you to follow suit. T

Re: [Vo]:Revisiting The "Whipmag" All-Magnet Motor, saga

2011-08-01 Thread Terry Blanton
> The thing that bugged me about the whipmag saga was that Al did > say, quietly, offhandedly, that no laws of physics were being > broken, but made the demo look as convincing as he could. Yes. Sounds like you were there for the whole stinking show. I have followed his posts on the Steorn forum

Re: [Vo]:Revisiting The "Whipmag" All-Magnet Motor, saga

2011-08-01 Thread vorl bek
> From Terrry: > > > The consensus at the time was it was driven with a > > compressed air nozzle. Al spun the small gear several times before he was able to get the device to start. Could the 'failed' attempts have been a cover for winding a spring? The thing that bugged me about the whipmag sa

Re: [Vo]:Revisiting The "Whipmag" All-Magnet Motor, saga

2011-08-01 Thread OrionWorks - Steven V Johnson
>From Terrry: > The consensus at the time was it was driven with a > compressed air nozzle. A reasonably educated guess. Nevertheless, I'm not yet ready to throw in the towel. (Or perhaps I'm not finished obsessing over... I mean amusing myself over the "Alsetalokin" matter.) ;-) The original "

Re: [Vo]:Revisiting The "Whipmag" All-Magnet Motor, saga

2011-08-01 Thread Terry Blanton
On Mon, Aug 1, 2011 at 11:35 AM, OrionWorks - Steven V Johnson wrote: > That may be so, but OC's "dream" variation is, IMO, categorically > different than what "Alsetalokin's" original configuration appears to > show. IMHO, OC "dream", specifically the dynamic animation displayed > out at the web

Re: [Vo]:Revisiting The "Whipmag" All-Magnet Motor, saga

2011-08-01 Thread OrionWorks - Steven V Johnson
>From Terry: > Actually, the animation is per OC's idea which came to him in a dream. >  The whipmag was a variation on the dream. That may be so, but OC's "dream" variation is, IMO, categorically different than what "Alsetalokin's" original configuration appears to show. IMHO, OC "dream", specif

Re: [Vo]:Revisiting The "Whipmag" All-Magnet Motor, saga

2011-08-01 Thread Terry Blanton
On Mon, Aug 1, 2011 at 10:36 AM, OrionWorks - Steven V Johnson wrote: > Regarding the animated graphic purporting to represent the "whipMag" > configuration in action, as shown out at: > > http://www.overunity.org.uk/cmps_index.php?pageid=whipmag1 > > this animation appears (to me) to have been a

Re: [Vo]:Revisiting The "Whipmag" All-Magnet Motor, saga

2011-08-01 Thread OrionWorks - Steven V Johnson
Terry, Some follow-up comments. > The present belief is that the whipmag was a hoax which got > way out of hand when the vid went viral. Al removed the vid > but it got copied by others. OC has since passed away and > Al seems to regret the whole incident from what little he > will say. Consid

Re: [Vo]:Revisiting The "Whipmag" All-Magnet Motor, saga

2011-08-01 Thread OrionWorks - Steven V Johnson
>From Stephen, > Please note that physics simulation packages are going to be based on > physical law, as currently understood, and the "conventional" E&M model of > magnetism is conservative.  As a result, the assumption of conservative > behavior is built into the modeling package. > > Consequen

Re: [Vo]:Revisiting The "Whipmag" All-Magnet Motor, saga

2011-08-01 Thread Stephen A. Lawrence
On 11-07-31 10:10 PM, OrionWorks - Steven Vincent Johnson wrote: Upon closer inspection, this counter-intuitive configuration is actually less bizarre to comprehend to those (such as me) who have studied magnetic characteristics, and who have performed countless Finite Element Method Magnetic

Re: [Vo]:Revisiting The "Whipmag" All-Magnet Motor, saga

2011-08-01 Thread Terry Blanton
On Sun, Jul 31, 2011 at 10:10 PM, OrionWorks - Steven Vincent Johnson wrote: > Back around 2008 I gather someone who went by the name of "Alsetalokin" > (that's Nicola Tesla spelled backwards) brought an unusual magnetic motor > configuration to the public domain's attention. He got the idea fro

[Vo]:Revisiting The "Whipmag" All-Magnet Motor, saga

2011-07-31 Thread OrionWorks - Steven Vincent Johnson
Changing the subject for a brief spell from the continuing Rossi saga I must confess the fact that I have recently found myself revisiting the "Whipmag" All-Magnet Motor incident. For those who might be curious you can read up on that recent period of history out at peswiki where a dedicated link e