Re: [Vo]:Rossi states his reason for not publishing Penon report

2016-04-13 Thread Axil Axil
"Anyway, as I said, I really do not understand why people here side with Rossi rather than I.H. " We we all thought how a refereed game is played. In all sports, the mutually agreed upon referee is the final authority in who has won the game. That is how games have been played since the beginning

Re: [Vo]:Rossi states his reason for not publishing Penon report

2016-04-13 Thread Blaze Spinnaker
Wow, Jed, not only are you an expert at calorimetry but you're also lawyer too. Quite the liberal arts degree you got there, where do I get one of those babies. On Wednesday, April 13, 2016, Jed Rothwell wrote: > a.ashfield > asked me a > reasonable question: > > >> Rossi stated that he wanted

Re: [Vo]:Rossi states his reason for not publishing Penon report

2016-04-13 Thread Jed Rothwell
Jack Cole wrote: > Now he says it will be published after it is disclosed in court. Probably > hoping that it won't be widely refuted before a decision is reached and > reducing the number of experts who could be called by IH to refute the > report. > That would not reduce the number of expert

Re: [Vo]:Rossi states his reason for not publishing Penon report

2016-04-13 Thread Jack Cole
Jed, Now he says it will be published after it is disclosed in court. Probably hoping that it won't be widely refuted before a decision is reached and reducing the number of experts who could be called by IH to refute the report. It can't think of any reason to do this beyond the fact that it wo

Re: [Vo]:Rossi states his reason for not publishing Penon report

2016-04-13 Thread Jed Rothwell
a.ashfield wrote: Jed. I do not know why. I wish they would. I do not want to ask them why, > because it is none of my business. I don't want to ask questions relating > to a lawsuit. I prefer to stick to technical questions. > > That didn't stop you speculating that Penon was an idiot . . .

Re: [Vo]:Rossi states his reason for not publishing Penon report

2016-04-13 Thread a.ashfield
AA.If the ERV report supports IH, why have they not released it? Jed. I do not know why. I wish they would. I do not want to ask them why, because it is none of my business. I don't want to ask questions relating to a lawsuit. I prefer to stick to technical questions. That didn't stop you sp

Re: [Vo]:Rossi states his reason for not publishing Penon report

2016-04-13 Thread Jed Rothwell
a.ashfield wrote: Jed. "The Penon report is way more likely to be flawed. The guy is a > certified idiot." > > That sounds libelous to me. Penon apparently got his Laureate degree with > full marks. > Don't be ridiculous. People accuse others of being idiots all the time, in both the real world

Re: [Vo]:Rossi states his reason for not publishing Penon report

2016-04-13 Thread Jed Rothwell
a.ashfield wrote: If the ERV report supports IH, why have they not released it? I do not know why. I wish they would. I do not want to ask them why, because it is none of my business. I don't want to ask questions relating to a lawsuit. I prefer to stick to technical questions. I have heard va

Re: [Vo]:Rossi states his reason for not publishing Penon report

2016-04-13 Thread a.ashfield
Jed. "The Penon report is way more likely to be flawed. The guy is a certified idiot." That sounds libelous to me. Penon apparently got his Laureate degree with full marks. You are sounding biased. I suspect one could trawl through your earlier comments and find where you have made mistakes.

Re: [Vo]:Rossi states his reason for not publishing Penon report

2016-04-13 Thread Craig Haynie
This is a good point. IH can just as easily release the report. It's not just Rossi's reluctance. Craig On 04/13/2016 06:08 PM, a.ashfield wrote: Jed, If the ERV report supports IH, why have they not released it?

Re: [Vo]:Rossi states his reason for not publishing Penon report

2016-04-13 Thread a.ashfield
Jed, If the ERV report supports IH, why have they not released it?

Re: [Vo]:Rossi states his reason for not publishing Penon report

2016-04-13 Thread Jed Rothwell
Lennart Thornros wrote: > Still to decide that they are proof for anything is jumping the gun > I do not understand who you mean is jumping the gun. Do you mean Rossi? Rossi has been saying for months that he will publish the report. Obviously he never intended to do that. It cannot be because hi

Re: [Vo]:Rossi states his reason for not publishing Penon report

2016-04-13 Thread Lennart Thornros
OK Jed, The reason provided might be false or misleading. Still to decide that they are proof for anything is jumping the gun On Apr 13, 2016 13:40, "Jed Rothwell" wrote: > Lennart Thornros wrote: > >> No Jed it is not incorrect to follow the advice of the lawyer you pay >> lots of money to . .

Re: [Vo]:Rossi states his reason for not publishing Penon report

2016-04-13 Thread Jed Rothwell
Lennart Thornros wrote: > No Jed it is not incorrect to follow the advice of the lawyer you pay lots > of money to . . . > No lawyer would tell him that. He made that up. It is nonsense. Anyone knows that you can submit previously published information as part of a lawsuit. Publishing does not ma

Re: [Vo]:Rossi states his reason for not publishing Penon report

2016-04-13 Thread Lennart Thornros
No Jed it is not incorrect to follow the advice of the lawyer you pay lots of money to, for the purpose of him advice ng you on legal issues. To quick conclusions. On Apr 13, 2016 13:03, "Jed Rothwell" wrote: > a.ashfield asked me a reasonable question: > > >> Rossi stated that he wanted to rele

[Vo]:Rossi states his reason for not publishing Penon report

2016-04-13 Thread Jed Rothwell
a.ashfield asked me a reasonable question: > Rossi stated that he wanted to release the report but had not on his > attorney;s advice. How dO you know better? > Rossi was more specific in a message he sent to Mats Lewan today. He "his lawyer won’t let him" publish the Penon report, because if