Re: [Wiki-Medicine] BMJ Wikipedia reviews

2015-09-12 Thread Anthony Cole
4:08 AM, "Anthony Cole" wrote: > >>>>> > >>>>> Ah. Sorry Hilda, wrong term. I mean we should offer the reader a > really > >>>>> nice-looking presentation of the reviewed version of the article, > rather > >>>>> than som

Re: [Wiki-Medicine] BMJ Wikipedia reviews

2015-09-11 Thread Daniel Mietchen
about this, the less important I think it is. The >>>>> main thing to achieve is a really prominent link at the top of the current >>>>> version of a reviewed article linking the reader to the reviewed version. >>>>> >>>>> There should

Re: [Wiki-Medicine] BMJ Wikipedia reviews

2015-09-11 Thread Daniel Mietchen
want it. >>>> >>>> Whether they link to a nicely-presented, journal style edition or just >>>> the plain old Wikipedia history page is fairly trivial. >>>> >>>> Apart from a really prominent link to the reviewed version at the top of >

Re: [Wiki-Medicine] BMJ Wikipedia reviews

2015-09-11 Thread Lane Rasberry
k to the reviewed version at the top of >>> the current page, there should also be *a prominent link to a nice, >>> readable diff between the reviewed and current versions* - so the >>> reader can see how the topic/article has evolved since the last review. >>> &g

Re: [Wiki-Medicine] BMJ Wikipedia reviews

2015-09-11 Thread Anthony Cole
Bastian, Hilda (NIH/NLM/NCBI) [C] < >> hilda.bast...@nih.gov> wrote: >> >>> G'day! >>> >>> I'm happy to support this - but can't come to London. Hoping to be at >>> the USA meeting though. >>> >>> Not sure what you mean

Re: [Wiki-Medicine] BMJ Wikipedia reviews

2015-09-08 Thread Sydney Poore
; USA meeting though. >> >> Not sure what you mean by a fair copy. >> >> Hilda >> >> >> -- >> *From:* Anthony Cole [ahcole...@gmail.com] >> *Sent:* Tuesday, August 18, 2015 9:48 PM >> *To:* Wiki Medicine discussio

Re: [Wiki-Medicine] BMJ Wikipedia reviews

2015-08-25 Thread Francesco Tarantini (francesco.tarantini)
Great news! Well done!!! Francesco Tarantini (https://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utente:Franciaio) Il 14/08/15 19:05, Anthony Cole ha scritto: > > I've just come out of the second teleconference with fellow WPMEDF board > member Jake Orlowitz, and Fiona Godlee and Peter Ashman of BMJ.

Re: [Wiki-Medicine] BMJ Wikipedia reviews

2015-08-25 Thread Anthony Cole
hony Cole [ahcole...@gmail.com] > *Sent:* Tuesday, August 18, 2015 9:48 PM > *To:* Wiki Medicine discussion > *Subject:* Re: [Wiki-Medicine] BMJ Wikipedia reviews > > Lodewijk, Sydney, Hilda, I think I'm going to need lots of support to pull > this off. BMJ are not publishing th

Re: [Wiki-Medicine] BMJ Wikipedia reviews

2015-08-19 Thread Bastian, Hilda (NIH/NLM/NCBI) [C]
cine discussion Subject: Re: [Wiki-Medicine] BMJ Wikipedia reviews Lodewijk, Sydney, Hilda, I think I'm going to need lots of support to pull this off. BMJ are not publishing the reviewed version - we are, by pointing to the relevant diff in the article's history. I'd like us to

Re: [Wiki-Medicine] BMJ Wikipedia reviews

2015-08-18 Thread Anthony Cole
Lodewijk, Sydney, Hilda, I think I'm going to need lots of support to pull this off. BMJ are not publishing the reviewed version - we are, by pointing to the relevant diff in the article's history. I'd like us to offer the reader a much nicer presentation of the reviewed article than that, which me

Re: [Wiki-Medicine] BMJ Wikipedia reviews

2015-08-15 Thread Sydney Poore
This fantastic news! Sydney Sydney Poore User:FloNight Wikipedian in Residence at Cochrane Collaboration On Fri, Aug 14, 2015 at 1:05 PM, Anthony Cole wrote: > I've just come out of the second teleconference with fellow WPMEDF board > member Jake Orlowitz, and Fiona Godlee and Peter Ashman of

Re: [Wiki-Medicine] BMJ Wikipedia reviews

2015-08-15 Thread Anthony Cole
Wonderful news! Congratulations! > > Hilda > > > From: Lodewijk > Reply-To: Wiki Medicine discussion > > Date: Friday, August 14, 2015 at 5:38 PM > To: Wiki Medicine discussion > Subject: Re: [Wiki-Medicine] BMJ Wikipedia reviews > > This is great news! This s

Re: [Wiki-Medicine] BMJ Wikipedia reviews

2015-08-14 Thread Daniel Mietchen
o: Wiki Medicine discussion > Subject: Re: [Wiki-Medicine] BMJ Wikipedia reviews > > This is great news! This seamlessly fits in with some good discussions I've > had/heard at Wikimania, and a good step towards the future! > > I hope that this experiment is successful, and that it

Re: [Wiki-Medicine] BMJ Wikipedia reviews

2015-08-14 Thread Bastian, Hilda (NIH/NLM/NCBI) [C]
ikimedia.org>> Subject: Re: [Wiki-Medicine] BMJ Wikipedia reviews This is great news! This seamlessly fits in with some good discussions I've had/heard at Wikimania, and a good step towards the future! I hope that this experiment is successful, and that it finds repetition. Lodewijk On

Re: [Wiki-Medicine] BMJ Wikipedia reviews

2015-08-14 Thread Lodewijk
This is great news! This seamlessly fits in with some good discussions I've had/heard at Wikimania, and a good step towards the future! I hope that this experiment is successful, and that it finds repetition. Lodewijk On Fri, Aug 14, 2015 at 7:05 PM, Anthony Cole wrote: > I've just come out of