Thanks for sending this along, Piergi, your troubleshooting is very helpful. It sounds like there is still some kind of issue here, although it may be slightly different than what we fixed in 0.11.1. I'll let Lucas look into this and report back to the list.
-- Jim On Mon, Sep 12, 2011 at 4:40 PM, pt <[email protected]> wrote: > On 13 September 2011 00:18, Lucas Beeler <[email protected]> wrote: > > Adam & pt: > > > > How did you guys manage to reproduce this? I've tried, tried, and > > tried again. What's more, when I look at my log file, I see this: > > > > L 31408 2011-09-12 15:12:23 [DBG] knocking out flat tag 'carol' from > > file '/home/lucas/Pictures/Photos/2011/08/27/red.jpg' because it's > > already known as a hierarchical tag component > > > > which indicates to me that the tag knockout code is doing what it's > > supposed to. The role of the tag knockout code is to remove flat tags > > that are merely duplicates of hierarchical tag components so as to > > prevent child tags from re-appearing as top-level tags during f-spot > > import -- i.e., the knockout code should've closed #4081. When you run > > Shotwell with logging turned on, do you see similar messages? > > > I ran shotwell with logging on, and importing those same photos I got > the exact same result as you, and a correct tag tree (no duplicates). > So initially I was as puzzled as you, because nothing changed in my > configuration, then I remembered the computer rule #1: 'the problem is > between the keyboard and the chair'. > > My guess is you have to delete the 'LastKeywordXMP' and 'TagsList' > fields added by shotwell to the test photos: my photos were 'after > import' so they included hierarchical tags information added by > shotwell. > > I did 'exiftool -all:all= *jpg' on those files, then imported in > f-spot and tagged, then imported from s-spot to shotwell and I got the > same results as the other day (i.e. duplicate tags). > > The relevant screenshot is: > > http://traversin.org/shotwell-test/AfterImportScreenshot2.png > > (This time I didn't put the top-level tags 'blue, red, green', just > the friends' names.) > > The worst part is that my shotwell.log *does* say it is knocking out > the flat tags, but eventually the tags are duplicated as top-level > tags. > > The log file is: > > http://traversin.org/shotwell-test/shotwell.log > > The photos in the directory are 'after import', if you want to use > them for a test remember to strip the tags added by shotwell, or, even > better, all tags. > > Ciao, > Piergi > -- > Web: http://traversin.org > GNU/Linux user 190604 > _______________________________________________ > Shotwell mailing list > [email protected] > http://lists.yorba.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/shotwell > _______________________________________________ Shotwell mailing list [email protected] http://lists.yorba.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/shotwell
