Connie, A couple of thoughts come to mind:
The stirrer does not mix too well. You are trying for too high a concentration. The bubbler introduces CO2 gas to the water, which will ionise and give a false (high) reading. If you are finding a change in the CS when exposed to light then it is possibly due to the quality of your water. Regards Ivan. > -----Original Message----- > From: Connie [mailto:[email protected]] > Sent: Friday, 18 January 2002 11:48 a.m. > To: silver- list > Subject: CS>questions: stir vs. bubble > > > > I have the SG6-very happy with my generator. > I have done some experiementing with the way I make my CS. > > I would like to compare my brew with stirring vs. bubbling and please > comments as too the differences. > > I use a 64 fl. oz. coffee creamer container to make my CS. > > Some days...using the stir....it seems to take longer. Not > observant enough > to say why one day is different vs. another. > > Here are the comparisons of the last two batches made: > > --First brew: > Stirred batch. > Seeded, ppm per Hanna PWT 4ppm. > I cleaned electrodes (with heavy build up) 3 x's during the brew. > > After 36 hours of generation...the ppm per Hanna was about > 18ppm. Indicator > light, indicating that the brew had not reached 20pppm (as > dialed) was still > on. > My stirred CS ALWAYS reads a lower number the next day, when > retested. Often > I will turn the generator back on, let it run again until the > indicator > light goes off. > > Allowed the brew to sit overnight. A lot of precipitate in > the container. > Did not bother to retest the ppm. ( I expected it to be lower > than what > measured the night before) > I gave up on that brew...used it in the bathwater.... > > --Second brew: > Bubbled batch-stirrer removed. > > Seeded DW ppm at start 4ppm. > 10 hrs. later: indicator light off. > I did not clean the electrodes at all. > I shut down the generator. > Did not test the ppm. > left til this AM, testing ppm with Hanna, the ppm is 26ppm. > (set at 20ppm) > > Some, but little precipitate....electrodes with little build up. > > > My observed main points > > -bubbled CS consistently more stable after brew sits (ppm's > do not fall from > one day to the next) > -bubbled CS consistently has less build up on the electrodes, less > precipitate in the container. > -bubbled CS consistently able to achieve higher ppm (per Hanna) > -occassionally will get pale yellow CS with stir, never with bubbled > -consistently stirred CS will turn ashen with even minimal exposure to > light, bubbled does not seem to (I have not specifically > ''tested'' this.) > -brew time for higher ppm's consistenly quicker with bubbler. > (this case 36 > hours for less than 20ppm stirred vs. 10 hrs. for 26ppm bubbled) > > I have no clue why such a difference. I know Ole Bob you do > not like the > bubbler, I believe also Trem that you prefer stir.... > > Could someone explain some of these differences for me...in > terms I could > understand.... > and if bubbling is not good, why....when it appears to make a better > product? > > TIA > Connie -- The silver-list is a moderated forum for discussion of colloidal silver. To join or quit silver-list or silver-digest send an e-mail message to: [email protected] -or- [email protected] with the word subscribe or unsubscribe in the SUBJECT line. To post, address your message to: [email protected] Silver-list archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>

