What is supposed to happen and what may happen can be two completely different things. And as Russ points out in his #25 Seminar, when you do a lot of work, it's not a matter of IF something will happen, but WHEN something does happen.
We upgraded the supply for an ex industrial building for a new addition with K25's at 60 PSI, new diesel pump, ex 8" loop. Due to the one addition with the high flow being around the back, we ended up with a system we knew would be about 175 at normal settings, but ends up sitting- with the permission of the AHJ and Owner- at 180~ 185 PSI. Prior to installing the fire pump, we went in and hydro'd the 6 existing (circa 1968 thru 1985+/-) systems with the written agreement that the owner was responsible for water damage resulting from us testing HIS existing systems. The repairs took about 20 minutes total for all 6 systems- band on a couple grooved couplings, take a couple lines a turn around, and tighten the packing on an ITC valve. No big deal. Once the pump was installed we did discover (well, maybe "create" would be more descriptive) a handful of UG leaks which were dug up and replaced. But overall, there was a lot more potential for damage and expense than occurred. But the understanding was very simple- the OWNER had liability for what happened to HIS system when we tested it at high pressure (which was 250 PSI, btw). We are blessed that this Owner is both extremely knowledgeable in sprinklers and pumps, and understands and applies fairness in contracting. Heck, they even pay within 30 days, and want SCV's around a loop where they make sense, just like the good old days of HPR accounts being protected appropriate to their risk and value, rather than to the cheapest interpretation of minimum concensus standards. When you have operations that require K25s at 60 PSI, it is good to understand what ya got and how to use it. We enjoy the high-testosterone water supplies, our 2nd project with these guys has another 2500 gpm diesel on order (different location, not a redundant supply). So its possible, hopefully probable, that you can test an existing system at high pressure, but its not necessary, even foolhardy, to think you should expose yourself or your insurance carrier to the potential losses. Its not your risk to assume if others installed it and the monkey is on the owner's back. glc -----Original Message----- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Joe Hankins Sent: Thursday, March 08, 2007 10:01 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Re: What I'm Hearing About Hydrostatic Testing There was nothing to suggest water hammer. Water hammer resulting from a pump start is unlikely in sprinkler system piping. Even if there is a water hammer problem, it's something you want to know because it's easy to fiz.When you do see water hammer from a fire pump, it usually happens in underground. Also, starting fire pumps with the discharge valve open is by far the most common way weekly runs are made. I've seen many sprinkler systems that have held up to weekly pump starts for more than 30 years without incident. If you truly beleive that a sprinkler system can be blown apart by a fire pump, you have a very low opinion of the quality of sprinkler installations! Joe _______________________________________________ Sprinklerforum mailing list [email protected] http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum
