On 2012-08-31 14:27, Kurt Zeilenga wrote:
On Aug 31, 2012, at 4:09 AM, Dave Cridland <[email protected]> wrote:
I'm still concerned that replacing any but the author's last message is likely
to cause problems with accurately presenting the data.
I generally think it best to separately display the corrected text (as a new
message) in the presentation stream with annotations that it is a replacement
for a previously presented text, whether it's the last message or not. This
not only for security reasons, but to maintain conversational flow.
-- Kurt
It has been silent around XEP-0308 some time now.
XEP-0301 In-Band Real-time text is about to be published in a new
version. It refers to XEP-0308 for editing earlier messages.
I have not yet seen a conclusion on the issue in XEP-0308, if it will
enable correction of only the last message or any previous.
The decision influences language in XEP-0301, so I would appreciate to
know the decision.
I have no strong argument for any specific decision, but I can express a
slight preference for the "any previous" option.
It would of course also be good to see XEP-0308 move on through a
successful Last Call.
/Gunnar
