On 20.03.2017 22:32, Dave Cridland wrote: > Loosely, this is OK, but, in order: > > 1) Section 6 must go. I don't believe that the XSF has the required > expertise to adequately review a SASL mechanism. I'm saying this > without commenting on the mechanism described in Section 6. This needs > to go through the IETF (this document can reference any particular > SASL mechanism for MTI it likes, including this one). The right > working group is - probably - Kitten, though traditionally XMPP itself > works through the ART area, and we might want to give an ART AD or two > a heads-up. This issue is a blocker for me.
Section 6. was written in mind being probably factored out. So I'm happy to bring this to the IETF. Anyone who wants to shepherd me? What is MTI? > 2) I don't think §5.2.3 is right - I don't think ISR should be placing > any requirements on the upper layer. You might think - correctly - > that a server requiring 2FA on a resume is not behaving very sensibly, > but I don't think it's behaving in a way that would cause > interoperability problems. I'm sorry, but I'm confused (maybe it is already to late for me :)). You mean ISR should not allow 2FA on resume? Why not? Care to elaborate what you mean with "placing any requirements on the upper layer"? If ISR is based on SASL2, why shouldn't it also support <continue/> XEP-0388 § 2.6.3? > 3) My usual distaste for the made-up term "Nonza" remains. Given you > clearly understood XEP-0388, which does not use the term, I remain > mystified as to its purpose. I tired to motivate a clear definition for Nonzas in XEP-0360 § 1. and like to point out that I receive many positive feedback for doing so. I also note that I asked for suggestions for the exact term back then. Anyway, I assume that 3) is no blocker for you? - Florian
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
_______________________________________________ Standards mailing list Info: https://mail.jabber.org/mailman/listinfo/standards Unsubscribe: [email protected] _______________________________________________
