Moi je partage enti�rement l'opinion exprim�e l�: Enterprise est extr�mement d�cevante. C'est vrai que l� encore, dans le dernier �pisode voil� les Ferengis qui d�barquent et Archer sait d'instinct qu'ils sont des commercants inv�t�r�s. Jamais entendu dire que les Ferengis avaient �t� d�couverts aussi t�t. T'Pol elle m'�nerve carr�ment avec ses grosse l�vres: Autant Seven of Nine �tait parfaitement cr�dible en tant qu'ex-borg � la plastique superbe, autant T'Pol donne l'impression que les vulcains ont choisi un top model un peu concon pour envoyer sur le vaisseau terrien repr�senter Vulcain et c'est ridicule �bidemment. Tout �a pour refaire Spock qui aurait de nouveaux arguments pour faire avaler sa "logique". Bakula, dont j'attendais beaucoup est d�cevant dans le sens o� il n'est pas assez fort pour porter la s�rie. Mais le pire, ce sont quand m�me les histoires (m�me si j'en ai d�ja parl�): Carr�ment incroyables de simplicit� pour une s�rie de SF. J'ai d�ja dit que j'ai vu un �pisode dans lequel l'Enterprise rencontre des extra terrestres qui sont m�chants. Mais Archer a une autre opinion: Peut-�tre sont-ils gentils? Et paf, il s'av�re qu'il a raison, une fois de plus! Tout le monde se dit au revoir, fin de l'�pisode. D�sol�, mais Roddenberry nous avait habitu� � des surprises, pas seulement raconter des histoires simplistes sous pretexte que le traitement plus "r�aliste" donne un autre �clairage. Seule chose que j'aime bien: le vaisseau mais c'est loin d'�tre suffisant.
Ils ont inter�t de se ressaisir, sinon il est clair qu'il n'y aura pas d'autre saison. :-( Herv� ------------------------------------------ Stardate: Unknown ----------------------------------------- http://www.tourmen.net [EMAIL PROTECTED] ICQ:36734634 CUseeme user --------------------- Picard: No, Will, we can't! We have to save humanity!! le 28/03/02 20:45, Alary Paul s'exprimait ainsi: > > Copier coller d'un mess qui est pass� sur le forum americain ou je suis. > Desole c'est en anglais, mais c'est interessant et il y a des traducteurs > pour ceux qui ne parlent pas anglais: > http://babelfish.altavista.com/ > http://www.reverso.net/textonly/default.asp > babylon, etc... > > Paul > > > > <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >> going to be cancelled, please list a few of the things that you >> would change about the show if you could to make it more watchable >> by other Trekkies. This isn't really an essay question but more > of >> a survey of how we as a Trek unit feel about something. If you >> haven't seen the show I'm sure you've heard everyone griping about >> it. If you don't like it here's your chance to let loose. If you >> do like it here's your chance to let loose. Remember while open >> debate is welcome here, we won't argue over any points. >> >> T'Kuht > > Well, I guess I'll lead off since I'm already logged on here. > Overall I enjoy the show. There are things that don't gel with the > original series or even TNG, but the original series didn't gel with > the original series on more than numerous occasions. For example, > the animated episodes are more canonical to me than Star Trek V. > Oh, in case people aren't aware of what is considered Trek canon. > If it has been put on film, except the animated episodes, it is > supposed to be considered to be canon by those that know and shape > the show. I think that is one thing that people don't like about > Enterprise. It has taken what we previously knew or thought of and > either changed it or completely disregarded it. Some of this is > necessary in order to perpetuate the series, i.e. the technology. > Unless we want Enterprise to look as campy and dumb as The Munsters > or The Monkees, we've got to understand that the technology area was > a major problem. The main problem I have is T'Pol. I don't dislike > the way Jolene Blalock portrays her as such. We've never seen a > full Vulcan female in a long term role such as this. I object to the > makeup and costume people behind the set who decided what she is > supposed to look like. I do not believe the cat suit would be what > she would normally wear on Vulcan. It is a desert planet and > therefore she would roast quickly in that outfit. All the other > clothing we've seen has been loose and flowing, with the exception > of Spock's wedding, but that was ceremony. I object to her outward > appearance I suppose versus her inward appearance. Anyway, that's > what I can think of for now...have to go to work so I'll think about > it some more... > > T'Kuht > > > > StarTrek-fr, la mailing list francophone - inscription, d�sinscription, > informations : www.unification-online.org (rubrique mailing list) > StarTrek-fr, la mailing list francophone - inscription, d�sinscription, informations : www.unification-online.org (rubrique mailing list)
