Hi Thibaud:

you suggested the following following solution to the Azimuthal gnomon
height problem:

>How about making concentric rings for each declination, the innermost for
>+23.44 and the outermost for -23.44

I thought about this ring order also and have not rejected it.  If you look
at Mayall's azimuthal dial on page 181, you will see that he does something
similar to what you propose, by combining two months in each ring. (In his
version, however, he places the summer months on the outside instead of the
inside and he doesn't correct for the EOT or longitude).

Someone wrote you back and said that your idea wouldn't work because it
would produce the traditional analemma shaped hour lines.  But I'm not so
sure he was correct, because that kind of dial requires a nodus and an
azimuthal dial does not.

John C.

Reply via email to