--- In [email protected], Joseph Singer <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
>
> The G1 is nice, but it's not got the "buzz" that the iPhone has had.   
> I sing in a men's chorus and since the iPhone came out it's incredible  
> that lots and lots of them now have iPhones and many of these people  
> were on Verizon.
>

I believe that the "buzz" the iPhone has was due to the look and innovations it 
had at the 
time it came out (like the accelerometer, which the G1 also has). I remember my 
friend 
calling me up all excited about the iPhone release, citing most of the reported 
features. I 
wasn't impressed, my Treo 600 (which I refer to as the "Grandaddy" of 
smartphones) could 
already do most of the things he mentioned as "awesome" with the iPhone. The 
look (ooh, 
pretty sleek shiny thing...!) was the only real selling point to me, I didn't 
care about having 
an "iPod phone". I certainly wasn't (and stlll am not) a fan of Cingular/AT&T, 
and I didn't 
care to buy one and try to "jailbreak" it to T-Mo.

As to the G1:

PROS:

It's rubberized on it's exterior (The keys aren't rubber, they're plastic, but 
look like rubber. 
They're plenty durable.). In the time I've had the G1 (over a month now), I've 
NEVER 
dropped it. Not ONCE. Not even ALMOST. Ask iPhone users about accidents they've 
had 
over slipping or dropping phones. 

The apps (more so now than at launch) are comparable to apps on the iPhone 
(Apple 
markets them better). Case in point - Apple promotes SHAZAM in it's ads. It's 
an app that 
"listens" to songs on the radio or TV or in a club, and allows you to download 
the song 
from iTunes. G1 HAS THE EXACT SAME APP. Instead of iTunes, you go to Amazon's 
mp3 
store for downloads AND allows you to view the video on YouTube (which you 
CAN'T do 
on the iPhone version). The G1 has the BEST eBay app I've ever seen on any 
smartphone. 
There is now even an app that allows you to accept credit cards on your phone 
through the 
Authorize.net gateway (if you already have a merchant account, or plan to get 
one).

All my eMail comes to the phone, all my IM's, all my social networking. Other 
than not 
being able to "see" Flash (apparently common with smartphones, and this is 
rumored to be 
being worked on), the Internet experience is great. I can input my contacts and 
calendar 
online at my Gmail account from any Internet terminal (my laptop, my desktop, 
etc), and it 
syncs that information to my phone. If I lose my phone or damage it, I don't 
lose that 
information.

CONS:

The Look. When I first saw it, I thought, "That's It?" It's a brick. But it's 
so basic looking, I 
don't think I have to worry about anyone stealing it. That may be a "plus".

Battery Life. Bring your chargers with you when you go forth. If you use your 
phone as 
extensively as I do, you'll be recharging every 3-4 hours. You CAN shut off 
GPS, and 
certain other non-essential functions to save battery life, but you're still 
looking at every 
6-8 hours between charges. The good news is that you can charge your phone 
through 
your laptop, an outlet or your car pretty easily. Energizer even makes a mini 
USB portable 
battery charger so you can use regular batteries to recharge anywhere.

The Keyboard. While there is now an app that has a touchpad keyboard for the 
search 
function, if you need to type most information, you have to use the flip open 
keyboard. It's 
annoying initially, but you get used to it. I'm used to using my Treo 600 
one-handed, and 
now I have to use both hands to type.

That's it. With new apps arriving literally daily, it improves constantly. The 
marketing for 
the G1 is cute, but not informative. They're promoting it as an "information 
phone", but it 
really is much more. It does go head to head with iPhone in most areas. I love 
it, and until 
Palm catches up and gets with the program again, this will be my phone of 
choice.


------------------------------------

- -
T-Mobile-US on Google Groups:
http://groups.google.com/group/T-Mobile-US
_ _
     
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/T-Mobile-US/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/T-Mobile-US/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to