My 2 cents
shop=fashion is subjective & wide ranging. Remember when some considered
the shell suit the thing to be seen in? it needs deprecating.
shop=boutique. Shops in my locale who describe themselves as 'boutiques'
("for the discerning and stylish woman.") are primarily based around
clothing, but often have a side-lines of other products, such as
jewellery, handbags, beauty products & even homeware. Would
shop=clothes. clothes=boutique clarify?
shop=shoes is a standalone shop & should not be amalgamated into
'clothes'. Point out a shop with shoes in the window & ask "What's
that"? 99% of people will say "it's a shoe shop".
DaveF
On 31/08/2017 13:07, marc marc wrote:
Le 30. 08. 17 à 19:19, Daniel Koć a écrit :
deprecate shop=fashion
I agree that shop=fashion is a "no meaning" tag
shop=boutique as part of making things clear in this field.
for shop=boutique, I think you are wrong.
A shop=boutique (except from the translation+wiki being corrected)
is something totally different from a shop=clothes.
You can define the additional tags needed to have a shop=boutique
(handmade, high range), but even so, in my opinion it is not
enough to move all shop=boutique to shop=clothes.
I think that shop=boutique must continue to exist
> My feeling is that my wallet will know the difference
> between shop clothes and boutique.
> Shop boutique relates to shop clothes like restaurant
> relates to fast food
I agree with that for shop=boutique
but can your wallet, your wife or a fashion addict explain
a difference between shop=fashion and shop=clothes
If all shop=fashion are also shop=clothes and vice versa,
perhaps the merger is usefull
>> a member of
>> https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haute_couture#Liste_des_membres
>> or same for worldwide shop
> Shop types are not members of anything like that
I think that in France, the term "haute couture" is protected,
in the same way that you can not claim to be an architect
without formalities in certain countries. I'll check that out.
Of course on a world level, it must be more flexible but there are
still some notions that makes that Wallmark had no shop=boutique
department even if it creates a ray of high quality handmade
> what about tagging exclusive/luxury goods? Do we need it?
all your additional tag are useull and I agree to create them.
but even so, I do not think shop=boutique must be depreciated
_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
