Yeah, I've seen the pattern of route=piste for ways, I guess it is a case of newbies over-gardening. Don't specifically exclude route=piste from your proposal: my point was to completely omit 'other recreational routes' if you don't master them to avoid unnecessary discussion. When the proposal is accepted, you can have a look at taginfo and reach out to those route=* wiki page to inform that the new accepted proposal may be of interest.
Le 20 mai 2020 18:27:24 GMT+02:00, Peter Elderson <[email protected]> a écrit : >Thanks, I see that route=piste was approved and has its own role >definition. Strangely enough, the tag is applied more often to ways >then to >relations, that does not seem to fit in the tag definition. > >I meant the roles proposal to be generic, but I'll include the >route=piste >relation as an exception. Any other exceptions? > >Peter Elderson > > >Op wo 20 mei 2020 om 17:37 schreef Yves <[email protected]>: > >> "Applies to >> >> All  and  part of a relation tagged >> withtype=route and route=hiking or route=foot or route=bicycle or any >other >> recreational route type." >> >> I was thinking of route=piste, used for cross-country skiing or >> snowshoeing. I'd better leave out this part unless discussed in the >context >> of other recreational routes. I don't see in the current proposal any >> showstopper, but who knows? >> Once accepted, it will be easy enough to extend to other route=* >relations >> as fit. >> Yves >> >> >> >> Le 20 mai 2020 13:33:26 GMT+02:00, Peter Elderson ><[email protected]> a >> écrit : >>> >>> Please review and comment on this proposal: >>> >>> >>> >https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/Recreational_route_relation_roles >>> >>> >>> Definition: specification of role values for members of a >recreational >>> route relation >>> >>> The status has changed to proposed as of today >>> >>> Comments can be placed on the talk page and/or here. Please note >that >>> this proposal is meant to get a basic role set approved and >documented. >>> >>> Thanks for helping to finally get this done! >>> >>> Best, Peter Elderson >>> >>
_______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list [email protected] https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
