On Sun, 28 Jun 2020 at 18:51, Gábor Fekete <[email protected]> wrote:
Me too. A cukrászda is definitely not a cafe in my opinion. A cukrászda > surely offers a wide variety of self-made sweets, probably coffee too. A > cafe, tagged with cuisine=cake, probably has a limited selection of cakes > (from unknown source). > So one offers home-made cakes and the other may offer home-made cakes (the few cake-only cafes I'm aware of around here offer home-made cakes) or may not. I'm not sure that merits a different value of main tag. They both sell cakes. > And what about the tourist, who makes a 30-minute side trip to go to a > coffee shop to eat some sweets, and finds only two kinds of marlenka in a > paper box? > That's what cuisine=* is for. That's what Google is for. That's what Yellow Pages is for. That's what TripAdvisor is for. > > I share the opinion that some cukrászda*s* are not shops, they should be > tagged as amenity (but not amenity=cafe). > >From where I'm sitting, they quack like cafes. Cafes with very limited choices of cuisine, but still cafes. Some of them are cafes selling home-made products, but they still quack like cafes. They are cafes I would avoid (diet-controlled diabetes) just as I would avoid vegetarian cafes (I don't like their menus) so I would be delighted to find those things specified by cuisine=* so I could avoid them. I still don't see them as being not-cafes. I like Indian food, so I think it would be great if Indian restaurants had special tagging and icons to let me find them more easily. But they're just restaurants with a special type of cuisine. So if I'm in a strange town and feeling hungry I can look for restaurants on the map and check their cuisines. You've not convinced me that these things are anything other than cafes with a special cuisine. They're not even unique to your part of the world, we have them here: cafes that serve home-made cakes, some beverages and nothing else. You've not convinced me that this is a square peg/round hole situation. It seems more like a square peg/square hole situation. Is there anything sold in cukrászdas that isn't sold in cafes/pastry shops? Is there anything sold in cafes that only sell pastries/pastry shops that isn't sold in cukrászda *s?* -- Paul
_______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list [email protected] https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
