Hi I second the comments of Topographe below. Continuous improvement is a major challenge.
Le dim. 18 oct. 2020 à 23:09, Martin Koppenhoefer <[email protected]> a écrit : > And once we have done it, we could do it again and again, for all kinds of > reasons. > Not all kinds of reasons: once the change has been reviewed, voted, discussed by the community for a significant amount of time. Providing a technical efficiency or a given tool doesn't mean we should overuse that tool. > The problem is not the data at the origin, it is the system around the > database. > If the system isn't suitable enough, let's improve it. For instance: among other things, versions keep a record of a manual edit of a particular user and allow change reversal. Once a big change like man_made => human_made has been reviewed and acknowledged by the community, do we need a formal version to reverse it? How many DWG changesets have been reversed in the past? I think the need to create versions for this particular kind of change is very low. All the best François Le lun. 19 oct. 2020 à 08:55, Topographe Fou <[email protected]> a écrit : > Putting appart this 'man' vs 'human' debate... > > This reminds me a thinking I regularly have in minds: OSM shall have a way > to tell all (registered) data users that "starting from yyyy/mm/dd > following major change in the database will be applied following vote xxx > from OSM community. Please see drawbacks, workarounds and recommandations > for editors in wiki page www" . The idea would not be to trigger this > mechanism every week but to be able to schedule few data scheme > improvements in concertation with (and supervized by) a dedicated Working > Group (DWG ? Or a contiunuous improvement wg ?). I think OSM already did it > in the past and the wellspreading of its data shall not block us for > improvements. Keys can be seen as arbitrary strings from a sw point of view > but I think there is a benefit to have consistent keys, which may imply > from time to time to review 10 years old tagging schemes. It can even > simplify life of editors and data consumers. > > > LeTopographeFou >
_______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list [email protected] https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
