> Ist ja schön dass es ein relicensing geben soll. Aber dennoch ist es mit der > momentanen Lizenz nicht eindeutig legal, OSM für irgendwas zu benutzen ohne > *alle* Autoren zu nennen.
> Das nur als Quintessenz für Presse-Anfragen, habe ich bisher falsch > verstanden gehabt und auch falsch weiter gegeben. Ich zitiere aus: http://lists.wikimedia.org/pipermail/foundation-l/2007- December/035571.html Gregory Maxwell gmaxwell at gmail.com Sat Dec 1 20:50:38 UTC 2007 [quote on] 3) Speaking of 'attribution', the Creative Commons cc-by and by-sa licenses at version 2.5 and beyond contain a serious issue with their attribution. The attribution clauses in these licenses reads, in part, "If you distribute, publicly display, publicly perform, or publicly digitally perform the Work or any Derivative Works or Collective Works, You must (...) provide, reasonable to the medium or means You are utilizing: (i) the name of the Original Author (...), and/or (ii) if the Original Author and/or Licensor designate another party or parties" (...) (through) terms of service or by other reasonable means" So these by-attribution licenses don't actually provide attribution if a service provider specifies so in their terms of service. Jamesday (en User:Jamesday), a Wikimedian old-schooler, wrote a lot about this back when these terms came out. Obviously the issue of attribution for collective works in a space limited medium is important, but it can be addressed without giving service providers the ability to take attribution for all freely licensed content distributed through their systems. The exact implications of that text aren't entirely clear: If the clause only takes effect at the first point of submission it breaks the right to fork, and fails to resolve the collective attribution problem (i.e. you end up with "This article contains material by Wikia(tm), WikiHow(tm), Wikipedia(tm), GregPedia, Planet Math ..."). Or, alternatively, if any down stream service provider can invoke it .. it allows anyone who could claim to be a service provider to remove attribution at any time... which many consider to be morally offensive, and which present practical problems for people trying to keep works free. [quote off] Geht seitens des Autors in die völlig gegenteilige Richtung, zeigt habe,r wie weit man die CC auch verbiegen kann. -jha- _______________________________________________ Talk-de mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-de
