On 20 September 2017 at 00:56, Frederik Ramm <frede...@remote.org> wrote:

> On 09/19/2017 10:03 PM, Yuri Astrakhan wrote:

>> I would like to auto-add all the
>> corresponding wikidata based on wikipedia, for all remaining objects,
>> using  JOSM's "Fetch Wikidata IDs".
> If the Wikidata ID can be fetched automatically based on the Wikipedia
> tag, can we delete the Wikipedia tags from everything that has Wikidata
> afterwards because it is redundant?

Technically, yes, but some in the community have objected to that being done.

>> This way, we will be able to quickly find all the objects that are
>> problematic with the Wikidata+OSM service.
> Adding problematic data to OSM in order to have it fixed is never a good
> idea.

That is not what is proposed. It will highlight bad data (Wikipedia
links) that is *already* in OSM.

>> For example, thanks to the
>> community, we already fixed over 600 incorrect links to wiki
>> disambiguations pages,
> But this would have been possible without importing the data first?

Not as easily, nor as quickly.

>> We will be
>> able to fix when things are tagged as people (e.g. wikidata -> person,
>> instead of subject:wikidata -> person),
> I don't understand; you say that you want to add the wikidata tag to OSM
> and only afterwards can you find problems like this?

Again, this is where OSM already has a bad Wikipedia link.

>> find location errors (e.g.
>> wikidata and OSM point to very different locations, implying that its an
>> incorrect link).
> Again, OpenStreetMap is not a workbench for importing and then fixing
> non-OSM data (even if it may look convenient). Please build a QA process
> based on the un-imported data and import it once you have fixed the
> problems.

And again; this is for bad data that is already in OSM.

Andy Mabbett

talk mailing list

Reply via email to