On 5/30/05, Peter Hampf <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

> The unread tab is located under the account/folder window and is ment to be
> "show only folders that contain unread messages".
> 
> It must NOT hide the read messages inside these folders.

I don't want to start a flamewar about this, but I have to disagree
with you.  Knowing what folders have unread messages is practically
useless.  The combination of only showing folders with unread messages
& the messages themselves is far more useful (and really, the former
would be a byproduct of the latter).  What good is knowing a folder
has unread messages if I need to hunt them down?  Not all unread
messages are new or have proper timestamps, etc.; I have a lot of
unread messages located all over the place.  The current "unread" tab
doesn't offer me much more than the "unread" column in the account
view.

Even if you want to contend that this is the correct behavior, then
there is still something wrong with this UI.  Apparently it has caused
confusion.  "Unread" here clearly means to me "unread messages",
probably because messages are the only thing I think of in terms of
having been read and not read.  Even if the location of the tab would
indicate otherwise, then it would indicate unread folders, which
doesn't make very much sense.  This concept of only folders with
unread messages is neither intuitive nor supported by the tab's
context.  But, like I said, if this is the correct behavior, then the
tab should be renamed at the very least.

Now, to add something new, I don't like how the "Unread" tab does not
group folders by account.  I have three accounts I use, so I see three
"Inbox" folders in the "Unread" tab, without  any indication. other
than location (seems to correlate to the same order in the account
tree), of which folder is which.

-- 
Kevin

________________________________________________________
 Current beta is 3.5.21 | 'Using TBBETA' information:
http://www.silverstones.com/thebat/TBUDLInfo.html
IMPORTANT: To register as a Beta tester, use this link first -
http://www.ritlabs.com/en/partners/testers/

Reply via email to