Hi John

Thursday, October 16, 2003, 12:37:44 AM, you wrote:

JM> Sorry if I scared you, but this really is from me, here is my phone
JM> number too If you would like to verify that I sent this message.
JM> 573-222-2483

Ok, I bite the bait and jump in :) The reason digital signatures are so useful
is that they can really authenticate you in a near categorical manner. To fake a
digital signature is very difficult due to the mathematical properties and trust
mechanisms it is based on.

On the other hand, how can I be sure that the person at the phone number you
mentioned is really John Morse? For a reasonably skilled attacker, creating an
email message apparently from John Morse is easy. This spoofed message can be
made to look VERY convincing. Putting a phone number of his choice in the email
is easy too, since he's writing the email in the first place. I call the number
and talk to the attacker. All he has to say is "Yep this is John. Told ya!". How
would I know if I were really talking to you?

If you had signed that message digitally, however, the reader could be very sure
that the sender was indeed John Morse. Work is in place to have digital
signatures granted the same legality as handwritten signatures. It's rather
interesting actually if you'd like to read up on it somewhere.

I don't agree with the person who called you ignorant and refused to explain
further. Many people don't know how PGP really works and what its benefits could
be. To them it just gets in the way. Very understandable. Brushing them off isn't
going to help increase mass acceptance, though. A major stumbling block is that
most people don't know others who're using PGP, so they're hesitant to adopt it.
Once it becomes more widespread, however, people will grow to like the
confidentiality and, as we call it, "non-repudiation" that things like PGP can
provide. Check it out sometime, you might like it too.

Cheers,

-- 
Vishal 


________________________________________________
Current version is 2.01 | "Using TBUDL" information:
http://www.silverstones.com/thebat/TBUDLInfo.html

Reply via email to