Re: [TruthTalk] Ad Hom Farce

[Kevin Deegan]

Sanity Check...

Thank you Terry

Terry Clifton <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

David Miller wrote:

Kevin wrote:
  

This moderation stuff is a farce, it is never applied
even handedly ...
    

Kevin, please be patient.  Gary has just taken over the moderation of the 
list, and he has not issued any reprimand yet, so lighten up.  He solicited 
discussion of his perspective concerning Izzies post and I hope that we can 
perhaps do that.  My perspective is like yours, that Izzy was simply 
applying a Biblical passage to your activity with the Mormons.  I don't see 
anything ad hominem about it, and I hope to be given the opportunity to 
discuss why.  In a nutshell, she did not attack the character of any 
specific TruthTalk member.  She referred to "hardened Mormons."

Kevin wrote:
  

The Ad Hom Rule causes more problems
than it fixes.  Puke makes me sick
    

I have been communicating on electronic forums since before there was a 
public internet, back when we had dial-up Bulletin Board Systems and 1200 
baud modems was considered fast.  I have had two lists that were unmoderated 
during the last five years.  I ended up having to take them down.  My 
experience leads me to appreciate light moderation and the no ad hominem 
argument rule.

I believe that the "no ad hominem rule" is helpful, but it must be even 
handedly applied.  This is VERY difficult for any moderator.  It takes work 
and practice.  Furthermore, the distinction between attacking the personal 
character of a member and attacking a religious sect or doctrine is 
sometimes difficult for some people to grasp.  Without this distinction, it 
creates some confusion, which is what we are experiencing now.  Please be 
patient and give our new moderator some time.  Thanks.

Peace be with you.
David Miller. 
========================================================================
  

Izzy quoted the Bible.  She gave her opinion as to how that quote applied to a cult.  That is not ad hominem.  The moderator and the ex pastor are too easily offended by the truth.
Terry

---

Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Search presents - Jib Jab's 'Second Term'