Sorry for the late reply, but I'd like to discuss about the pros and cons of each name before the final vote. I've set a summary of what has been said on the mailing list:
http://ubuntume.com/newname

and added which domain names are unavailable.

Mehdi

Administrator of the Ubuntu Muslim Edition project
http://www.ubuntume.com



fadi al-katout wrote:
Assalam alaykom,

new poll is ready with only the first five option.... only one vote and one option also registration is required,
votes are open form 13/02/09 15:00 to 20/02/09 15:00


please inform if there are any suggestions :)

wassalam

On Wed, Feb 4, 2009 at 1:28 PM, Abdelmonam Kouka <[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>> wrote:



    2009/2/3 عبدالرحيم دوبيلار <[email protected]
    <mailto:[email protected]>>

        Assalamu aleikum

    Wa alaykom assalem,


        First, I suggest we set a specific time for the poll to close.
        We all live in different time zones, so on Friday, for some it
        will already be early Saturday and for others it will still be
        late Thursday. Let's close the poll on Friday at 15:00 (3
        p.m.) Makkah time. That is exactly noon UTC/GMT.

        Second, leave the results visible on the website for two days
        and invite the brothers and sisters to comment on the pro's
        and con's of the top five, if they wish to do so. Close this
        opportunity on Sunday at 15:00 Makkah time and then set up and
        launch the run-off poll as soon as Fadi is ready. For this
        round, everybody has only one vote, of course. In my opinion,
        during the run-off poll the results should not be visible. We
        want the brothers and sisters to go for what they really think
        and not be influenced by the voting of others. The current
        round is for doing just that and when it is closed on Friday,
        the influencing will also stop.

        Third, close the run-off poll on Friday 20 February, again at
        15:00 (3 p.m.) Makkah time and announce the result.

        Just a few comments on Fadi's observations, if I may:

        Fajr is actually not that easy. The 'j' in it is pronounced
        differently in different languages. For example, in Spanish it
        is more like a ghain (غ), making it sound almost like faqer
        (فقير), which is not what we want. In Dutch and German, two
        languages that I speak fluently, the 'j' is pronounced like
        the 'y' in Yousef and because there is no vocal between the
        'j' and the 'r' it is a bit of a tongue-twister in those
        languages.

        Sabili. You are right in questioning whether we are inviting
        people to Islam or helping them embrace it. Although it is a
        noble aim, it is not the objective of an operating system. But
        the objective of having an operating system specially for
        muslims is the wish to protect ourselves against the
        influences of misguided people, who engage in actions that
        cause sickness and degradation. To protect ourselves against
        the influences of alcohol and loose morals, is that not our
        way? To further the good and forbid the evil. It certainly is
        may way:  هذه يبيلي (hadhihi sabili).

    The translation of this ayah is:
    Say (O Muhammad SAW): "This is my way; I invite unto Allâh (i.e.
    to the Oneness of Allâh - Islâmic Monotheism) with sure knowledge,
    I and whosoever follows me (also must invite others to Allâh i.e
    to the Oneness of Allâh - Islâmic Monotheism with sure knowledge).
    And Glorified and Exalted is Allâh (above all that they associate
    as partners with Him). And I am not of the Mushrikûn (polytheists,
    pagans, idolaters and disbelievers in the Oneness of Allâh; those
    who worship others along with Allâh or set up rivals or partners
    to Allâh)." (108)

    And I think that by giving "Minbar" to remember Salat times we
    invite Muslims unto Allah, by adding "Zekr" to give Muslims
    opportunity to read Quran and listen it and read its translation
    we invite Muslims unto Allah, by adding "Zekr" to give non-Muslims
    opportunity to read Quran in their languages and know more about
    Quran and Islam we invite non-Mulims unto Allah... and by giving
    all what we have in ubuntuME (design and software) we are inviting
    people (Muslims and non-Muslims) unto Allah, and this is our way...

    That's all...

    Salem


        Ethaar also has a pronunciation issue. The 'th' sound does not
        exist in many languages. In Dutch and German it would be
        pronounced Etaar, the 'h' being omitted.

        AlifOS. You are right, Fadi. In English and other languages
        the alif stand for 'A' and not 1 (one). Moreover, people
        probably see the name of our fourth khalifa, Ali (may Allah be
        pleased with him) in it. And that might send the wrong signal
        to certain groups.

        Linux Muslim Edition is straight and to the point. LME also
        stands for London Metal Exchange, where non-ferrous metals are
        traded.

        These are just a few thoughts.


        Salam


        *AbdulRahiem Dubelaar*
        PO Box 67363
        43764 Bayan, Kuwait
        /+965 9901 9051/

        |


        Op dinsdag 03-02-2009 om 20:20 uur [tijdzone +0200], schreef
        fadi al-katout:
        Assalam alaykom,

        Then our next vote will start on 13th?

        our first five names now vary very much,

        I think we don't need a very general name like Fajr because
        it is every where and it is abstract it is not related
        directly to Islam and Muslims!

        AlifOS I believe when thinking hard the translation does not
        apply Alif in arabic meets the "A" letter in english and not one!

        Sabili is very good and I like the sound of it, but do we
        realy invite people to Islam when making "UbuntuME" or do we
        help Muslims to emprase it?

        Linux Muslim Edition is very profissional and stratight
        forward to me and I can not say anything more!

        Ethaar is closer to what we do (in my opinion of course) and
        it is easy to be sayed in any language!

        I hope to keep this thread alive and active even brothers who
        talked already lets hear from you again...

        wassalam alaykom
PS. I voted the first time for sabili, Muslim Linux Edition
        and Ethaar.

        On Mon, Feb 2, 2009 at 8:16 PM, Mehdi <[email protected]
        <mailto:[email protected]>> wrote:

            assalamu alaykum,

            I think we should tell the maximum of people to vote (for
            example in muslim forums), then we could wait until next
            week (say friday 13th?)
            Before doing the second vote we could list the pros and
cons of every name.


            Mehdi

            Administrator of the Ubuntu Muslim Edition project
            http://www.ubuntume.com



            fadi al-katout wrote:

                Assalm alaykom,

                Thank you all my brothers for your comments and I
                need to take an action regarding to the poll:


                  1. The first top 5 options in the current one will
                be moved to the
                     new one.
                  2. only registered people can vote (we will check
on the user name)

                     either people care enough to vote or not!

                  3. only one option can be selected(I have chosen
more than one of

                     the top five but I have a favorite).

                  4. Please brother Mehdi advise me on the time that
will close the

                     poll(to have enough time to make the changes
                before the next
                     release 9.04).

                Am waiting response on point 4 from Mehdi, and as
                always all suggestions are welcomed :)

                wassalam alaykom.


                On Sun, Feb 1, 2009 at 5:31 AM, عبدالرحيم دوبيلار
                <[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>
                <mailto:[email protected]
                <mailto:[email protected]>>> wrote:

                   Assalamu aleikum



                   In my view, relevance of the name would be
                important in Arabic.
                   Only! In other languages it should merely be easy
                to pronounce,
                   but it need not have meaning. Therefore, sounds
                like 'kha' (خ)
                   'qaf' (ق), "zza" (ظ), "ghain" (غ), etc, should be
                avoided.

                   If any of the names on the list have a negative
                connotation in any
                   of the languages of the people in the group, let
                them speak out
                   now, please.

                   Most people, who are interested in Linux, know, or
                at least
                   quickly know about Debian, Fedora, Mandriva,
                openSUSE, Xandros,
                   Knoppix and, indeed, Ubuntu. None of them have
                "Linux"in the name.
                   Anyone considering installing Linux is at least
                slightly
                   computer-literate and will do some research in
                advance, so as not
                   to break their existing (Windows) installation.

                   For marketing purposes the word "Linux" could be
                added as a label
                   or (meta)tag. What I mean is, the name could be
                just <UbuntuME> (I
                   use this as an example, so as not to influence the
                voting.) But on
                   distribution sites, in brochures and other
                marketing materials it
                   could be presented as <UbuntuME>, Linux for
                Muslims, or better
                   still <UbuntuME>, *The* Linux for Muslims. That
                should also take
                   care of Google and other spiders.

                   And actually the abbreviation "ME" should be
                avoided, because many
                   people take it as standing for "Middle East"
                instead of "Muslim
                   Edition".

                   With regard to the poll, I believe there should be
                date set in
                   advance for the poll to close and a definitive
                period for the
                   run-off vote. It's February, so the majority of
                people are not on
                   holiday, etc. Thus, the voting period need not be
                very long. It is
                   best to get a firm decision quickly and then close
                the subject.

                   This is just my opinion, but I am always ready to
                accept other
                   opinions.


                   Salam

                   *AbdulRahiem Dubelaar*
                   PO Box 67363
                   43764 Bayan, Kuwait
                   /+965 9901 9051/



                   Op zaterdag 31-01-2009 om 22:45 uur [tijdzone
                +0100], schreef Mehdi:


                       I agree, we could for example take the 5 first
                    names and do a second    vote with only one option.
                       But we should also carefully think about the
                    relevance of the name, its    results on google,
                    the domain name, the "communication" relevance etc.
                       On a French Muslim forum they don't like
                    Arabic names because they are    not relevant,
                    they prefer "linux muslim edition", they think,
                    for    example, that Fajr is meaningless for
                    end-users.

                       Mehdi

                       Administrator of the Ubuntu Muslim Edition project
                       http://www.ubuntume.com



                       fadi al-katout wrote:
                       > For the poll, I think next step is that we
                    should minimize the options    > and only
                    registered people can vote, also only one option
                    is allowed!
                       >
                       > what do you think!
                       >
                       >


                       > On Sat, Jan 31, 2009 at 1:12 PM, fadi
                    al-katout <[email protected]
                    <mailto:[email protected]>
                    <mailto:[email protected]
                    <mailto:[email protected]>>    >
                    <mailto:[email protected]
                    <mailto:[email protected]>>> wrote:
                       >
                       >     Assalam alaykom,
                       >
                       >         * When I logged in it said: Hi, أحمد
                    المحمودي
                       >
                       >          I think it should say: as-salamu
                    alaykom.
                       >
                       >
                       >     Done for english and it is already
                    السلام عليكم in arabic
                       >
                       >
                       >          * At the bottom of poll results,
                    the dates were in gregorial.
                       >         Btw,
                       >            jazak Allahu khairan for fixing
                    the date on top right of
                       >         the pages.
                       >
                       >
                       >     I managed to make the date for the
                    Articles in Hijri, but not the
                       >     polls date :-/ am on it...
                       >
                       >
                       >         * The link for "new name poll" on
                    the frontpage needs to be
                       >            highlighted somehow, since this
                    is an important decision (I
                       >         think).
                       >
                       >
                       >     I did put it in a menu alone!
                       >
                       >
                       >         For the Arabic web site, in the
                    menu, it is written:
                       >           ابونوتو
                       >         (ubunutu!!!)
                       >         but it should be أوبنتو
                       >         BTW: The web site is note translated
                    yet into Arabic, there is
                       >         no one to do it? the most part is
                    translated but in the old one...
                       >
                       >     changed it to ابونتو and I think brother
                    Osama is translating it
                       >     to Arabic now!
                       >
                       >
                       >         Jazak Allah kheir, ya Fadi
                       >
                       >         It is excellent. Well done.
                       >
                       >     Thanks borther :)
                       >
                       >     jazakom allah kaeran jamee3an.
                       >
                       >     wassalam
                       >
                       >
                       >     On Thu, Jan 29, 2009 at 11:01 AM, Usama
                    <[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>
                    <mailto:[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>>
                       >     <mailto:[email protected]
                    <mailto:[email protected]>>> wrote:
                       >
                       >
                       >         Alsalam Alikom
                       >         I want to help translating the site
                    into Arabic, how ever I
                       >         think that
                       >         some of the contents are already
                    translated. but need to be copied
                       >         from the old site.
                       >
                       >         my user name is
                       >         Damascene
                       >
                       >         2009/1/29 عبدالرحيم دوبيلار
                    <[email protected]
                    <mailto:[email protected]>
                    <mailto:[email protected]
                    <mailto:[email protected]>>
                       >         <mailto:[email protected]
                    <mailto:[email protected]>>>:
                       >         > Jazak Allah kheir, ya Fadi
                       >         >
                       >         > It is excellent. Well done.
                       >         >
                       >         > Salam
                       >         >
                       >         >
                       >         > AbdulRahiem Dubelaar
                       >         > PO Box 67363
                       >         > 43764 Bayan, Kuwait
                       >         > +965 9901 9051
                       >         >
                       >         > Op woensdag 28-01-2009 om 23:11
                    uur [tijdzone +0200],
                       >         schreef fadi
                       >         > al-katout:
                       >         >
                       >         > Assalam alaykom,
                       >         >
                       >         > The poll is ready and I was the
                    first one to make a vote :),
                       >         it does not
                       >         > allow multiple times voting but it
                    does allow you to select
                       >         multiple
                       >         > choices.
                       >         >
                       >         > I hop it is good enough!
                       >         >
                       >         > http://www.ubuntume.com/website
                       >         >
                       >         > wassalam
                       >         >
                       >         >
                       >         > On Wed, Jan 28, 2009 at 11:48 AM,
                    ProDevStudio

                       >         <[email protected]
                    <mailto:[email protected]>
                    <mailto:[email protected]
                    <mailto:[email protected]>>
                    <mailto:[email protected]
<mailto:[email protected]>>>

                       >         > wrote:
                       >         >
                       >         > Salaam All,
                       >         >
                       >         > The voting system must allow us to
                    vote for more then one
                       >         name and also vote
                       >         > only once.
                       >         >
                       >         > Also we should looking to adding
                    services similar to/from

                       >         uservoice.com <http://uservoice.com>
<http://uservoice.com> <http://uservoice.com>.

                       >         >
                       >         > Really looking forward to the poll.
                       >         >
                       >         > Wa-Salaam,
                       >         >
                       >         > Azizur Rahman
                       >         > ProDevStudio
                       >         >
                       >         > Do you need cost effective web
                    hosting solution and Domain
                       >         name try
                       >         > http://www.prodevstudio.net
                       >         >
                       >         > Do you need a new web site try
                    http://www.cgandc.net
                       >         >
                       >         > Missed the last Friday Khutbah,
                    try catchup a Khutbah
                       >         on-line now at
                       >         > http://www.fridaykhutbah.com
                       >         >
                       >         >
                       >         >
                       >         > On Wed, Jan 28, 2009 at 7:14 AM,
                    عبدالرحيم دوبيلار

                       >         <[email protected]
                    <mailto:[email protected]>
                    <mailto:[email protected]
                    <mailto:[email protected]>>
                    <mailto:[email protected]
<mailto:[email protected]>>>

                       >         > wrote:
                       >         >
                       >         > Assalamu aleikum
                       >         >
                       >         > Actually, it is not even Macca.
                    The official Saudi rendering
                       >         is 'Makkah'.
                       >         >
                       >         > I am looking forward to seeing the
                    poll.
                       >         >
                       >         > Salam
                       >         >
                       >         >
                       >         > AbdulRahiem Dubelaar
                       >         > PO Box 67363
                       >         > 43764 Bayan, Kuwait
                       >         > +965 9901 9051
                       >         >
                       >         > Op woensdag 28-01-2009 om 08:42
                    uur [tijdzone +0200],
                       >         schreef fadi
                       >         > al-katout:
                       >         >
                       >         > Assalam alaykom,
                       >         >
                       >         > I can add a poll to our new
                    website with the names to make a
                       >         vote!
                       >         >
                       >         > but I have a comment on one of the
                    names...
                       >         > MeccaOS : it is not Mecca at all
                    it is Macca and this is not
                       >         even
                       >         > negotiable!
                       >         >
                       >         > wassalam
                       >         >
                       >         > On Wed, Jan 28, 2009 at 3:21 AM,
                    nasrullah chinnarassen

                       >         > <[email protected]
                    <mailto:[email protected]>
                    <mailto:[email protected]
                    <mailto:[email protected]>>
                    <mailto:[email protected]
<mailto:[email protected]>>>


                       >         wrote:
                       >         >
                       >         >  Wa laykus mus salam, Brother Mehdi,
                       >         > jazak Allah for the great work you
                    are doing to maintain our
                       >         great OS. May
                       >         > Allah bless us all .
                       >         >
                       >         > On Wed, Jan 28, 2009 at 4:30 AM,
                    Mehdi <[email protected]
                    <mailto:[email protected]>
                    <mailto:[email protected]
                    <mailto:[email protected]>>
                       >         <mailto:[email protected]
                    <mailto:[email protected]>>> wrote:
                       >         >
                       >         >
                       >         > assalamu alaykum,
                       >         >
                       >         > Here is the complete list of all
                    suggested names:
                       >         >
                       >         > * Afaq (Horizons)
                       >         > * AlifOS ("OneOS" --- One Allah,
                    One Ummah, One OS. And the
                       >         slogan being
                       >         > "OneOS for the Ummah".)
                       >         > * Almoyassar (The simplified, simple)
                       >         > * Ayah (Miracle)
                       >         > * Badr (Moon (also it is the name
                    of the famous islamic
                       >         foray (incursion) of
                       >         > Badr))
                       >         > * Ethar (being selfless and give
                    others)
                       >         > * Fajr (could symbolise a new dawn
                    for the ummah...the
                       >         revival and rise of
                       >         > Islam technologically,
                    scientifically, economically,
                       >         politically,
                       >         > militarily)
                       >         > * Himma (Mettle, Spirit, Courage)
                       >         > * Hydeya (Guidance)
                       >         > * Ilm (arabic for knowledge)
                       >         > * Iqrah or IqrahLinux (the 'first'
                    word of quran that
                       >         revealed to our
                       >         > beloved prophet (saw)... as far as
                    I know UbuntuMe is the
                       >         'first' and only
                       >         > linux distro developed especially
                    for Muslims)
                       >         > * Isbuntu (Islam + Ubuntu)
                       >         > * IslamUx
                       >         > * Islamix (Islam + Linux)
                       >         > * Linux muslim edition
                       >         > * Linux Muslim
                       >         > * Majd (Glory, Laurel)
                       >         > * MeccaOS
                       >         > * Mouaamen ("believer")
                       >         > * Munix (Muslim + Linux)
                       >         > * Muntu (Muslim + Ubuntu)
                       >         > * Muslim Linux
                       >         > * MuslimTux
                       >         > * Noortux
                       >         > * Sabili ("This is my way; I
                    invite unto Allah with sure
                       >         knowledge, I and
                       >         > whosoever follows me...")
                       >         > * Salahoddin" (Means: The famous
                    Muslim commander
                       >         "Salahoddin Al Ayoubi"
                       >         > (1138-1193), who libirate Al-Qods
                    in 11xx. In French they
                       >         call him
                       >         > "Saladin".)
                       >         > * Tareaq alhideya (The way of
                    guidance / Guidance way )
                       >         > * Ummahtux (Ummah meaning
                    "nation", ux for Linux (al ummati
                       >         islami, the
                       >         > Islamic nation) )
                       >         > * Wamidh (Flash, Glimmer, Light)
                       >         >
                       >         > Please tell me if I have forgot
                    some names.
                       >         >
                       >         > --
                       >         > Mehdi
                       >         >
                       >         > Administrator of the Ubuntu Muslim
                    Edition project
                       >         > http://www.ubuntume.com
                       >         >
                       >         >
                       >         >
                       >         >
                    _______________________________________________
                       >         > Mailing list:
                    https://launchpad.net/~ubuntume.team
                    <https://launchpad.net/%7Eubuntume.team>
                    <https://launchpad.net/%7Eubuntume.team>
                       >         <https://launchpad.net/%7Eubuntume.team>
                       >         > Post to     :
                    [email protected]
                    <mailto:[email protected]>
                    <mailto:[email protected]
                    <mailto:[email protected]>>
> <mailto:[email protected]
                    <mailto:[email protected]>>
                       >         > Unsubscribe :
                    https://launchpad.net/~ubuntume.team
                    <https://launchpad.net/%7Eubuntume.team>
                    <https://launchpad.net/%7Eubuntume.team>
                       >         <https://launchpad.net/%7Eubuntume.team>
                       >         > More help   :
                    https://help.launchpad.net/ListHelp
                       >         >
                       >         >
                       >         >
                    _______________________________________________
                       >         > Mailing list:
                    https://launchpad.net/~ubuntume.team
                    <https://launchpad.net/%7Eubuntume.team>
                    <https://launchpad.net/%7Eubuntume.team>
                       >         <https://launchpad.net/%7Eubuntume.team>
                       >         > Post to     :
                    [email protected]
                    <mailto:[email protected]>
                    <mailto:[email protected]
                    <mailto:[email protected]>>
> <mailto:[email protected]
                    <mailto:[email protected]>>
                       >         > Unsubscribe :
                    https://launchpad.net/~ubuntume.team
                    <https://launchpad.net/%7Eubuntume.team>
                    <https://launchpad.net/%7Eubuntume.team>
                       >         <https://launchpad.net/%7Eubuntume.team>
                       >         > More help   :
                    https://help.launchpad.net/ListHelp
                       >         >
                       >         >
                       >         >
                       >         >
                       >         >
                       >         >
                       >         >
                       >         >
                       >
                       >
                       >



                
------------------------------------------------------------------------

                _______________________________________________
                Mailing list: https://launchpad.net/~ubuntume.team
                <https://launchpad.net/%7Eubuntume.team>
                Post to     : [email protected]
                <mailto:[email protected]>

                Unsubscribe : https://launchpad.net/~ubuntume.team
                <https://launchpad.net/%7Eubuntume.team>

                More help   : https://help.launchpad.net/ListHelp

            _______________________________________________
            Mailing list: https://launchpad.net/~ubuntume.team
            <https://launchpad.net/%7Eubuntume.team>

            Post to     : [email protected]
            <mailto:[email protected]>

            Unsubscribe : https://launchpad.net/~ubuntume.team
            <https://launchpad.net/%7Eubuntume.team>


            More help   : https://help.launchpad.net/ListHelp






-- عبد المنعم كوكة
    Abdelmonam Kouka
    Software Engineer
    GNU/Linux user #450141
    GPG Fingerprint: EC21 1E4E 5B0C E4E7 0D64  3305 0D62 75C9 2C15 16E0
    ================================================
    "Some people see things as they are and say why.
    I dream things that never were and say why not?"
                              [George Bernard Shaw]
    ================================================
    http://www.ubuntume.com/
    http://arabeyes.org/
    http://www.ubuntu-tn.org/



_______________________________________________
Mailing list: https://launchpad.net/~ubuntume.team
Post to     : [email protected]
Unsubscribe : https://launchpad.net/~ubuntume.team
More help   : https://help.launchpad.net/ListHelp

رد على