At 11:34 AM -0500 10/3/01, Ayers, Mike wrote:
>       Pinyin still has similar problems (Xi'an/Xian), but, yes, they're
>less frequent.  Nevertheless, W-G had the advantage of presenting words that
>were at least pronounceable (albeit pronounced incorrectly) by the average
>English speaker, unlike Pinyin, which leaves us to puzzle out how to prounce
>"qun" and "xue", while still mispronouncing "cun" and "peng".  In my eyes,
>it's a tie.
>

Yeah, well, they're both based on the wrong dialect, anyway. 
Barbaric Mandarin-speaking northerners.  :-)

-- 

John H. Jenkins
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://homepage.mac.com/jenkins/

Reply via email to