Hi, I had a crack at it, without luck. Here's my set up: https://gist.github.com/kinow/f391be7036b63f8ac0c08b9832e8bfa7
I started with a Spatial only, using a configuration turtle file from Jena Spatial tests (see gist's spatial1.ttl). Loaded the dataset (also from tests), a query with spatial:nearby worked (geoarq-data-1.ttl & geoarq-data-1-query.ttl in the gist above). Then started by modifying the spatial Lucene Index, adding the properties necessary for a Jena Text dataset (see gist's spatial-text.ttl). Tried to make both, the spatial lucene index and the text lucene index point to the same directory. Once I started Fuseki (see comments in gist for rest of set up), the spatial query was still working, but even though I had a text:index pointing to an index, when the query was executed, it would be delegated to the DatasetGraphSpatial. This dataset knows nothing of text, and when the TextQueryPF is executed, the textIndex is null. My logs have: [2018-12-23 21:03:57] TextQueryPF WARN Failed to find the text index : tried context and as a text-enabled dataset [2018-12-23 21:03:57] TextQueryPF WARN No text index - no text search performed So alas I couldn't post a working example. Hope that helps anyway Bruno ps: Lucene locks its indexes, so I **guess** if you tried a different approach of having another Fuseki pointing to the same directory, it would probably raise an exception at some point ________________________________ From: Jean-Marc Vanel <jeanmarc.va...@gmail.com> To: Jena users <users@jena.apache.org> Sent: Saturday, 22 December 2018 10:03 PM Subject: Re: Build by program a Dataset that is both textual and spatial I reverted to trying configuration by code, with 2 more tries: https://github.com/jmvanel/semantic_forms/blob/master/scala/forms/src/main/scala/deductions/runtime/jena/lucene/LuceneIndex.scala#L109 : add to textual Dataset's Context a spatialIndex key to the spatialIndex. and line 135 : Use same Lucene directory for both indexes (not forgetting to spatially index the existing textual index). WARN org.apache.jena.query.spatial.pfunction.SpatialOperationWithCircleBase - Failed to find the spatial index : tried context and as a spatial-enabled dataset Both fail! My best hope is to look into Fuseki code, but can someone confirm that Fuseki does spatial WITH textual Indexing? I already looked into Fuseki code, but could not find calls to spatial or textual factory in jena-fuseki1/src/main/java/org/apache/jena/fuseki/ . Le ven. 21 déc. 2018 à 11:29, Jean-Marc Vanel <jeanmarc.va...@gmail.com> a écrit : > I'm still clueless about how to configure Jena for textual AND spatial > indexes. > I tried yet another assembler file: > > https://github.com/jmvanel/semantic_forms/blob/master/scala/jena.spatial%2Btext3.assembler.ttl > but even less good as > > https://github.com/jmvanel/semantic_forms/blob/master/scala/jena.spatial%2Btext2.assembler.ttl > reported just before. > > It seems that nobody uses both indexes by program; > otherwise I'd like to know how you do; you can send me privately your > assembler files. > > Fuseki claims to "incorporate Jena text query > <https://jena.apache.org/documentation/query/text-query.html> and Jena > spatial query > <https://jena.apache.org/documentation/query/spatial-query.html>" in this > documentation: > https://jena.apache.org/documentation/fuseki2/ > So there is a way to configure Jena for textual AND spatial indexes! > In absence of other help, I'll have to look into Fuseki code. > > NOTE: the error message "*tried context and as a text-enabled dataset*" > maybe hints at a solution, but the word "context" is not clear. > > > > > > Le lun. 17 déc. 2018 à 14:51, Jean-Marc Vanel <jeanmarc.va...@gmail.com> > a écrit : > >> >> >> Le lun. 17 déc. 2018 à 13:24, Andy Seaborne <a...@apache.org> a écrit : >> >>> ... >>> :spatial_dataset rdf:type spatial:SpatialDataset ; >>> rdf:type text:TextDataset ; >>> ... >>> >>> Not sure but I think the system will create this twice. >>> >>> It would be better to have two declarations, one for spatial, one for >>> text. I'm not sure what happen if they share the same :directory - it >>> might work, it might not. >>> >> >> So, if one want to make queries that are both textual and spatial, >> having two declarations, one for spatial, one for text, sharing the same >> directory, appears as the only solution . >> I tested and report here. >> The current assembler file: >> >> https://github.com/jmvanel/semantic_forms/blob/master/scala/jena.spatial%2Btext2.assembler.ttl >> Results: >> >> - spatial query works, textual query has empty result, but no >> message in log, when *calling with spatial Dataset* in call >> to DatasetFactory.assemble() >> - spatial query works, textual query has result independant of the >> string searched, and messages in log "Failed to find the text index" , "No >> text index - no text search performed : tried context and as a >> text-enabled >> dataset", when *calling with textual Dataset *in call to >> DatasetFactory.assemble() >> >> The query tested for text: >> PREFIX text: <http://jena.apache.org/text#> >> PREFIX rdfs: <http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#> >> SELECT * >> WHERE { >> ?s a <http://dbpedia.org/ontology/Garden> ; >> text:query (rdfs:label 'Gardens' ) ; >> } LIMIT 11 >> >> The spatial query tested: >> >> PREFIX spatial: <http://jena.apache.org/spatial#> >> PREFIX rdfs: <http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#> >> SELECT DISTINCT ?placeName ?place >> WHERE { >> ?place spatial:nearby ( >> 45.750000 4.85 # Lyon >> 1000 'km') . >> ?place rdfs:label ?placeName >> FILTER( LANG( ?placeName) = 'en' ) >> } LIMIT 111 >> >> Data: the 2600 dboGarden in dbPedia endpoint. >> >> >> >>> Andy >>> >>> On 16/12/2018 16:41, Jean-Marc Vanel wrote: >>> > Sorry , I sent a bad link on the list, my assembler file is really >>> this: >>> > >>> https://github.com/jmvanel/semantic_forms/blob/master/scala/jena.spatial%2Btext.assembler.ttl >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> > Le dim. 16 déc. 2018 à 13:40, Marco Neumann <marco.neum...@gmail.com> >>> a >>> > écrit : >>> > >>> >> you are missing the text index in the assembler. >>> >> >>> >> On Sun, Dec 16, 2018 at 12:08 PM Jean-Marc Vanel < >>> jeanmarc.va...@gmail.com >>> >>> >>> >> wrote: >>> >> >>> >>> Yes indeed, >>> >>> exactly with this assembler file: >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >> >>> https://github.com/jmvanel/semantic_forms/blob/master/scala/jena.spatial.assembler.ttl >>> >>> >>> >>> And, when the Jena based application is started with this same >>> assembler >>> >>> file, the spatial queries work , as said above in this thread. >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> Le dim. 16 déc. 2018 à 12:18, Marco Neumann <marco.neum...@gmail.com> >>> a >>> >>> écrit : >>> >>> >>> >>>> did you create the text index with jena.textindexer >>> >>>> --desc=/<path>/config.ttl? >>> >>>> >>> >>>> >>> >>>> On Sun, Dec 16, 2018 at 8:48 AM Jean-Marc Vanel < >>> >>> jeanmarc.va...@gmail.com> >>> >>>> wrote: >>> >>>> >>> >>>>> I fixed a stupid error in text index URI, resulting from pasting, >>> in >>> >>> new >>> >>>>> file jena.spatial+text.assembler.ttl: >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>> >>> >>> >>> >> >>> https://github.com/jmvanel/semantic_forms/blob/master/scala/jena.spatial%2Btext.assembler.ttl >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> Now, it reads: >>> >>>>> :spatial_dataset rdf:type spatial:SpatialDataset ; >>> >>>>> rdf:type text:TextDataset ; >>> >>>>> spatial:dataset <#dataset> ; >>> >>>>> spatial:index <#indexLucene> ; >>> >>>>> text:dataset <#dataset> ; >>> >>>>> text:index * <#indexLuceneText>* ; >>> >>>>> . >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> But still it says "Failed to find the text index" . >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> Le dim. 16 déc. 2018 à 09:34, Jean-Marc Vanel < >>> >>> jeanmarc.va...@gmail.com> >>> >>>> a >>> >>>>> écrit : >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>>> So I tried a new file jena.spatial+text.assembler.ttl with >>> >> separate >>> >>>>>> Lucene indices for spatial and text: >>> >>>>>> >>> >>>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>> >>> >>> >>> >> >>> https://github.com/jmvanel/semantic_forms/blob/master/scala/jena.spatial%2Btext.assembler.ttl >>> >>>>>> >>> >>>>>> It defines a Dataset with both Dataset types and both Lucene >>> >> indices: >>> >>>>>> >>> >>>>>> :spatial_dataset rdf:type spatial:SpatialDataset ; >>> >>>>>> rdf:type text:TextDataset ; >>> >>>>>> spatial:dataset <#dataset> ; >>> >>>>>> spatial:index <#indexLucene> ; >>> >>>>>> text:dataset <#dataset> ; >>> >>>>>> text:index <#indexLucene> ; >>> >>>>>> . >>> >>>>>> >>> >>>>>> Alas , when querying , it says "Failed to find the text index" : >>> >>>>>> >>> >>>>>> WARN org.apache.jena.query.text.TextQueryPF - Failed to find the >>> >>> text >>> >>>>>> index : tried context and as a text-enabled dataset >>> >>>>>> WARN org.apache.jena.query.text.TextQueryPF - No text index - no >>> >>> text >>> >>>>>> search performed >>> >>>>>> >>> >>>>>> Is it because rdf:type spatial:SpatialDataset is asserted first in >>> >>>>>> assembler file? >>> >>>>>> So, defining a hybrid Dataset does not work anymore by TTL >>> >>>> specification >>> >>>>>> than by JVM code specification. >>> >>>>>> I definitely need more experts' advice . >>> >>>>>> >>> >>>>>> >>> >>>>>> >>> >>>>>> Le sam. 15 déc. 2018 à 21:10, ajs6f <aj...@apache.org> a écrit : >>> >>>>>> >>> >>>>>>>> On Dec 15, 2018, at 9:59 AM, Marco Neumann < >>> >>> marco.neum...@gmail.com >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>>>> wrote: >>> >>>>>>>> >>> >>>>>>>>> *Question*: does that make sense to have a unique Lucene index >>> >>> for >>> >>>>>>> text and >>> >>>>>>>>> space ? >>> >>>>>>>>> It is possible at all? If yes, is it good in terms of disk >>> >> space >>> >>>> and >>> >>>>>>>>> performance? >>> >>>>>>>>> Like this: >>> >>>>>>>>> <#indexLucene> a text:TextIndexLucene ; >>> >>>>>>>>> a spatial:SpatialIndexLucene ; >>> >>>>>>>>> # etc ... >>> >>>>>>> >>> >>>>>>> I'm sure that would be ideal for many cases, but I'm not at all >>> >> sure >>> >>>>> that >>> >>>>>>> the same index can answer queries of both kinds. Perhaps we can >>> >>>> combine >>> >>>>>>> fields from both, but are the relationships between tuple and >>> >> index >>> >>>>> record >>> >>>>>>> the same in both cases? >>> >>>>>>> >>> >>>>>>> Otherwise, I know we had a conversation at some point in the past >>> >> on >>> >>>> one >>> >>>>>>> of the lists about trying to factor out commonalities between >>> >>>>> jena-spatial >>> >>>>>>> and jena-text, but it didn't go very far at that time and I don't >>> >>> know >>> >>>>> what >>> >>>>>>> the intervening years have done to make it more or less feasible. >>> >>>> There >>> >>>>>>> have been many changes to jena-text in that time and the new >>> >> spatial >>> >>>>> module >>> >>>>>>> is a whole new story. I'd put a link here but searching >>> >>>>> lists.apache.org >>> >>>>>>> hasn't brought it up for me. >>> >>>>>>> >>> >>>>>>> ajs6f >>> >>>>>>> >>> >>>>>>> >>> >>>>>> >>> >>>>>> -- >>> >>>>>> Jean-Marc Vanel >>> >>>>>> >>> >>>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>> >>> >>> >>> >> >>> http://www.semantic-forms.cc:9111/display?displayuri=http://jmvanel.free.fr/jmv.rdf%23me#subject >>> >>>>>> < >>> >>>>> >>> >>>> >>> >>> >>> >> >>> http://www.semantic-forms.cc:9111/display?displayuri=http://jmvanel.free.fr/jmv.rdf%23me >>> >>>>>> >>> >>>>>> Rule-based programming, Semantic Web >>> >>>>>> +33 (0)6 89 16 29 52 >>> >>>>>> Twitter: @jmvanel , @jmvanel_fr ; chat: irc:// >>> >>>> irc.freenode.net#eulergui >>> >>>>>> Chroniques jardin >>> >>>>>> < >>> >>>>> >>> >>>> >>> >>> >>> >> >>> http://semantic-forms.cc:1952/backlinks?q=http%3A%2F%2Fdbpedia.org%2Fresource%2FChronicle >>> >>>>>> >>> >>>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> -- >>> >>>>> Jean-Marc Vanel >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>> >>> >>> >>> >> >>> http://www.semantic-forms.cc:9111/display?displayuri=http://jmvanel.free.fr/jmv.rdf%23me#subject >>> >>>>> < >>> >>>>> >>> >>>> >>> >>> >>> >> >>> http://www.semantic-forms.cc:9111/display?displayuri=http://jmvanel.free.fr/jmv.rdf%23me >>> >>>>>> >>> >>>>> Rule-based programming, Semantic Web >>> >>>>> +33 (0)6 89 16 29 52 >>> >>>>> Twitter: @jmvanel , @jmvanel_fr ; chat: irc:// >>> >>> irc.freenode.net#eulergui >>> >>>>> Chroniques jardin >>> >>>>> < >>> >>>>> >>> >>>> >>> >>> >>> >> >>> http://semantic-forms.cc:1952/backlinks?q=http%3A%2F%2Fdbpedia.org%2Fresource%2FChronicle >>> >>>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>> >>> >>>> >>> >>>> -- >>> >>>> >>> >>>> >>> >>>> --- >>> >>>> Marco Neumann >>> >>>> KONA >>> >>>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> -- >>> >>> Jean-Marc Vanel >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >> >>> http://www.semantic-forms.cc:9111/display?displayuri=http://jmvanel.free.fr/jmv.rdf%23me#subject >>> >>> < >>> >>> >>> >> >>> http://www.semantic-forms.cc:9111/display?displayuri=http://jmvanel.free.fr/jmv.rdf%23me >>> >>>> >>> >>> Rule-based programming, Semantic Web >>> >>> +33 (0)6 89 16 29 52 >>> >>> Twitter: @jmvanel , @jmvanel_fr ; chat: irc:// >>> irc.freenode.net#eulergui >>> >>> Chroniques jardin >>> >>> < >>> >>> >>> >> >>> http://semantic-forms.cc:1952/backlinks?q=http%3A%2F%2Fdbpedia.org%2Fresource%2FChronicle >>> >>>> >>> >>> >>> >> >>> >> >>> >> -- >>> >> >>> >> >>> >> --- >>> >> Marco Neumann >>> >> KONA >>> >> >>> > >>> > >>> >> >> >> -- >> Jean-Marc Vanel >> >> http://www.semantic-forms.cc:9111/display?displayuri=http://jmvanel.free.fr/jmv.rdf%23me#subject >> <http://www.semantic-forms.cc:9111/display?displayuri=http://jmvanel.free.fr/jmv.rdf%23me> >> Rule-based programming, Semantic Web >> +33 (0)6 89 16 29 52 >> Twitter: @jmvanel , @jmvanel_fr ; chat: irc://irc.freenode.net#eulergui >> Chroniques jardin >> <http://semantic-forms.cc:1952/backlinks?q=http%3A%2F%2Fdbpedia.org%2Fresource%2FChronicle> >> > > > -- > Jean-Marc Vanel > > http://www.semantic-forms.cc:9111/display?displayuri=http://jmvanel.free.fr/jmv.rdf%23me#subject > <http://www.semantic-forms.cc:9111/display?displayuri=http://jmvanel.free.fr/jmv.rdf%23me> > Rule-based programming, Semantic Web > +33 (0)6 89 16 29 52 > Twitter: @jmvanel , @jmvanel_fr ; chat: irc://irc.freenode.net#eulergui > Chroniques jardin > <http://semantic-forms.cc:1952/backlinks?q=http%3A%2F%2Fdbpedia.org%2Fresource%2FChronicle> > -- Jean-Marc Vanel http://www.semantic-forms.cc:9111/display?displayuri=http://jmvanel.free.fr/jmv.rdf%23me#subject <http://www.semantic-forms.cc:9111/display?displayuri=http://jmvanel.free.fr/jmv.rdf%23me> Rule-based programming, Semantic Web +33 (0)6 89 16 29 52 Twitter: @jmvanel , @jmvanel_fr ; chat: irc://irc.freenode.net#eulergui Chroniques jardin <http://semantic-forms.cc:1952/backlinks?q=http%3A%2F%2Fdbpedia.org%2Fresource%2FChronicle>
