On 17/04/2009 16:20, Dave Post wrote:
On Apr 17, 2009, at 10:36 AM, Harold Fuchs wrote:

In Thunderbird's *mail* component, which is what I use on one of my
computers, it is possible to set up a "filter" that, for example, highlights
in red in the Inbox all moderated messages i.e. those from unsubscribed
users. I have done this and obviously it makes life simpler. Thunderbird's *news* component does not allow one to do this and one has to examine the headers "by eye". So using TB to reply to this list via Gmane is that little
bit more awkward.

I've done the same sort of thing with OSX Mail, but haven't sorted out yet how to do more sophisticated things like replying automatically.

You might post instructions for creating your Thunderbird rule. (I did that earlier for OSX Mail.) I've received a note from one of our subscribers, saying he'd like to do that but doesn't know how, and I believe many subscribers use Thunderbird's mail component.
I'll do this in a separate post.


Firefox also does not allow the creation of an appropriate filter. Haven't tried Internet Explorer. Some other *mail* programs allow the creation of an appropriate filter, others don't. I don't know about other *news* programs.

I suspect it would be difficult for a browser to implement filters for webmail. It would be easier to provide that sort of capability in the interface at Yahoo's, Google's, whomever's server.

I misspoke. I shouldn't have accused Firefox (or any browser) of this shortcoming. It's not a function of the browser. Instead it's a function of the particular webmail service. What I should have said is that Google mail doesn't allow one to filter on the relevant header although it does allow one to filter on some headers.

A newsreader is a different matter because it should "know" everything it's dealing with is essentially email. It's a bit surprising to learn, then, that Thunderbird's newsreader doesn't support filters.
TB's news reader does allow some filtering. It doesn't allow one to create a filter on the relevant header. I simply don't understand how these people write code; how can you make the headers available in one part of the program and not in another part of the same program? It was *more* work to do it that way than to have made all the headers available in both parts.

Not sure what to expect when something like Gmane's in the middle of things.
Gmane doesn't actually cause any additional problems. The relevant header is there if appropriate and absent otherwise, so you can do it by hand. If you could find a newsreader that lets you filter on the right header you could use it.


Dave



--
Harold Fuchs
London, England
Please reply *only* to [email protected]


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]

Reply via email to