Hi Lars,

In a message dated 2010.07.22 12:40 -0500, Lars Nooden wrote:

...Mail lists are one place where return receipts should *NEVER* be used.

James, maybe he's stupid, maybe he's just trolling, maybe he's collecting business intelligence for one of our competitors. But you are right, the using of Message Disposition Notification should never be used on mailing lists.

Continued abuse, either accidental or intentional, can be prevented by pruning that header from the message before it goes out to all subscribers:

    http://www.openoffice.org/issues/show_bug.cgi?id=113372

It's a machine's job and, for good quality mailing list software, very quick to implement.

You are right - and thanks for filing the issue - but that last condition ("good quality mailing list software") may be the catch: Months ago, in discussion about another mailing list problem, Paul said that the list manager software is really beyond community control - but that IAC change is on the way, which should address many of these problems. In the meantime, one might hope that courtesy would prevail.


The notification appears to be a holdover from MS Exchange / Outlook combinations which cause large volumes of messages to be lost without even an error message.

Interesting!  Could you provide a little more detail, or a link?

Thanks,
John

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]

Reply via email to