Would you please send me this script, I am willing to try SOGo again if this will work..
Thanks PK On 07/07/2013 01:32 PM, Szládovics Péter wrote: > Yes, it's true too. > But the sogo not a complete system, it's only the part of a system. > Sogo just a frontend for any imap server, authenticate from any ldap > and stores the card/calendar informations any database. > > Sogo works with cyrus? Yes. Works with dovecot? Yes. Works with > courier? Yes. Works with postgres? Yes. Works with mysql? Yes. Works > with openldap? Yes. Works with MS AD? Yes. Works with alternate user > sources? Yes. > > What about zimbra in this context? (LOL) - Easy docs... > > Exchange in 4 hours? Yes, I installed some exchange in AD forest with > replication. > But I can build a sogo about 30 minutes from booting Ubuntu setup cd > till first incoming/outgoing mail with the fresh installed system. > How? I created a script for that. It's get some data at start (mail > domain, admin passwords, ldap parameters, etc.), and then install > needed packages, and set them up it automatically - next-next finish. > > And the result? > > Samba4 LDAP + OpenChange + Sogo + Dovecot (quota, shared dirs, sieve) > + mysql + postfix + sogosync + Outlook anywhere compatibility + multi > domain support + phpldapadmin + phpmyadmin - and everything over SSL > for secure remote clients. > > 30 minutes, and not few hours with exchange - btw exchange... what > about the updates? My 30 minutes contains all of the updates. > > So... > If you want to try my install script, I can share it, but not for > cyrus/courier/postgres/openldap - you could use it too, but you'll > need an x509 CA, certificate and key in pem format. I need to remove > from it some private parts and translate it for English. > And no, I won't modify the script for other ldap/imap/sql backend, if > you need another, feel free to modify it - just please reshare ;) > > Please give me about a few days for it. > OK? > > 2013-07-07 21:43 keltezéssel, Schmitt, Christian írta: >> I know that it is not a problem of sogo, but i'm a developer and not >> a system administrator. I mean if I really want to make use of sogo i >> wouldn't want to go through thousands of documentations, just to have >> a good and working installation. >> >> i mean, you configured your apache right? i don't think so. i mean >> i've spent a week, fulltime to make the best available configuration, >> just for a python deployment with mod_wsgi. it contains only the >> things that are needed to work. also i've spent hours with mod_proxy >> and nginx as a proxy pass or haproxy. >> i've did this since i needed it. >> >> I've currently doing the same with Postgresql and 389 Directory >> Server. But still it's a lot of stuff and I could do that in >> fulltime. But how much people have that much time in their company? >> Most people won't they need to show some things and than deploy it or >> even the people who want it for their home servers, they want to make >> things work, not to spent their whole life by configure and evolve >> the process of deployments. >> >> You ever used Microsoft Exchange? >> I Could configure and install / deploy it in under 4 hours, fully >> configured and working (without used it before). Do you really think >> that ANYBODY could do that with sogo? >> I mean you ever seen a good documentation? Look at the Zimbra >> Documentation. In the Single Server install guide you could install >> Zimbra from Zero to Working and Zimbra still uses OpenLDAP, Postfix >> and Apache. >> Could you do that with sogo? No. The Documentation won't have the >> required things. >> Or take a look at the FreeIPA Docs here: >> > >> http://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/Fedora/18/html/FreeIPA_Guide/index.html >> There is a shitload of stuff but it's organized and you could easily >> use freeipa. >> >> Trust me sogo is great. But to deploy it you need a really really >> long time. Especially in good enviroments. >> >> >> >> >> >> 2013/7/7 Szládovics Péter <[email protected] >> <mailto:[email protected]>> >> >> 2013-07-07 19:59 keltezéssel, [email protected] >> <mailto:[email protected]> írta: >> >> It's true what you are saying, currently i'm planning some >> sogo deployments, >> one with a LDAP (FreeIPA) Backend and one with a postgresql >> Backend. Currently >> I'm playing around with postgresql and it isn't really easy >> with this >> documentation to bring up SOGo. (But btw. other Groupware >> Documentations are >> painful aswell) >> I mean SOGo is really really good. It's very fast and it >> works on my VPS that >> has 512MB Memory even with LDAP installed. (Currently Zimbra >> needs way more 2GB >> Memory or above, that makes it painful to use, but easy to >> install / >> configure). >> >> I think the problem with the documentation is not the >> configuration steps, Some >> things are just missing. I mean when I want to configure >> SOGo, I wan't to know, >> how I configure Cyrus with any SOGo Backend aswell and >> Postfix also with any >> Backend. I mean I'm confident with Apache and i wouldn't even >> needed the config >> file that you deployed with sogo. But I'm a total newbie with >> ldap / postfix / >> cyrus and I think many people are new to this feature aswell, >> since most of the >> groupware people coming from other enviroments where you >> didn't need to >> configure your own imap or mta. >> >> Nothing against you sogo guys, since you gave us one of the >> best, groupware's >> that are completly free and there aren't good alternatives. I >> mean kolab3, is >> really not production ready, zimbra is not really good since >> the nice features >> are only in the network edition and it uses way to much >> ressources, horde is >> cool and good, but it's old and still uses more than sogo >> uses. there are >> plenty of examples why sogo is better, but since you gave us >> 1 Document with >> like 60 sites which only includes the options that i could >> configure about sogo >> and not a complete document HOW TO INSTALL sogo it's really hard. >> >> I mean rename the document from SOGo installation to SOGO >> Configurable Options >> and make a new Guide which says Install Sogo which includes >> nearly every >> configuration option for real world deployments. >> >> >> Guys, it's absolutelly right! >> But... If anybody newbie in postgres/mysql or in any ldap, or >> dovecot/cyrus/courier or postfix/sendmail/exim or _wathever what >> is not sogo, just a backend_ - is this problem of documentation >> of sogo? I dont think so... >> At the begin of this year I never yet used Dovecot. I didn't >> install and use any OpenLDAP/Samba 4 instances. I knew postfix >> (but not in ldap auth), and knew mysql, and I knew apache. >> Understanding some dovecot mechanism was a little bit hard - >> quota+ldap, folder sharing+ldap, sieve (pigeonhole). Samba 4 and >> openchange was absolutelly new for me. >> AFAIK I did 30-40 installs with failed or almost worked status, >> and reinstalled them, and again, and again - and learn. >> You need to know, everybody thinks otherwise. My config is >> probably won't good for you, and your problem is probably not >> similar to my problem. >> So, I can't help - not 'don't want', just 'can't'. >> But when your problem is same or similar with one of my problems, >> I can help, and I will help. >> >> I think this community is helpful, when it can. >> >> /Sorry my bad English/ >> -- >> [email protected] <mailto:[email protected]> >> https://inverse.ca/sogo/lists >> >> > -- [email protected] https://inverse.ca/sogo/lists
