>I think it should definately come down to the gape size. Shank size doesn't >matter nearly as much. For fly tying purposes, a larger hook shank allows >more room to tie. However, for actual fishing purposes, which is actually why >we tie (maybe not true for all), it is the gape size that alters hook ups. >Just what I think. > >Happy tyin,' >Bryan
I agree Bryan...but that means we best pay attention when ordering hooks. For instance, if you buy some wide-gape 16's you are actually getting short-shank 14's...right...;^)) I have a Reddich Hook scale here in front of me...compliments of friend R Ross, and it states sizes by shank length. Now that's totally different from my educational inputs. Don't we measure hackle sizes by gape...ie...a size 16 hackle has barbules equal to 1.5x the gape of a size 16 standard dry fly hook? food for thought... keep tyin'...byard
