On 7/25/07, John Beckett <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I looked through 'candidates for deletion' recently and saw that > ipkiss has put a couple of tips in there. On at least one tip that I > noticed, he had put a rationale at the top of Comments. I think that's > an excellent strategy. It's easier for the person recommending the > page for deletion, and it's easier for people to review. > > Similarly, in tip 1 I have put a comment 'TODO: merge with tip 5' (and > vice versa in tip 5). Ipkiss has recently pointed out that I should > have a Duplicate template to handle that ... I'll probably do that > within a week. But just putting the comment where everyone can see it > makes sense to me.
For both the candidates for deletion and the TODO items, the person making the edit expresses a clear opinion on what should happen next. It is not done immediately because of a peers review in the first case, or because of lack of time in the second case. For these, I agree that keeping the comments in the page is a good thing (even though it is not necessary for the candidates for deletion, now that we centralize the discussions on the talk page of the category). However, when the remark expresses uncertainty about what should be done, it should go directly to the Talk page. Cheers, -- Olivier _______________________________________________ Vim-l mailing list Vim-l@wikia.com http://lists.wikia.com/mailman/listinfo/vim-l
