a.ashfield <[email protected]> wrote: >
> "I refer to first-hand statements by I.H., especially in their press > release:" > > I thought you were more interested in facts than what people said. Obviously, I assume these people are reporting a fact. They are saying they evaluated the calorimetry, and they do not think it shows excess heat. I do not think they are lying, or mistaken. I think Rossi is wrong. I do not know whether he is lying or mistaken, but I think he is wrong, just as he has been wrong so often in the past. Seems that facts are thin on the ground right now. > Not a bit. They are certain of their conclusion. Either of us could be right. But, based on the track records of Rossi and I.H., it is much more likely I.H. is right. That's my point. The point is we don't know yet. > We know what both sides said, and I know which side usually does a better job. When an incompetent person with a track record of making idiotic mistakes argues with experts, usually the incompetent person is wrong. - Jed
