Jed,
There are several reasons why Penon might have declined to answer Murray.
Your theory that the flow meter was reading significantly high has been
shot down.
As the flow rate was controlled downstream of the meter, one would
expect it not to vary much.
Exhibit 5 has errors as pointed out earlier.
If the customer had a strongly endothermic process you would not get 1
MW released into the building
I don't know who is telling the truth, but is not yet proven that IH is.
The theory (not yours) earlier about vapor in the line effecting the
flow meter neglects that the return from the customer is into a holding
tank @ 60 - 70C. Water drawn from that would not have free vapor.
On 8/9/2016 9:38 AM, Jed Rothwell wrote:
David Roberson <[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>> wrote:
I would hope that you could be convinced that Rossi is telling the
truth if he were to present a solid scientific proof to that
fact. Is that not giving him the benefit of the doubt? Can
anyone be 100% confident that he is completely lying?
Yes, I am 100% confident he is lying. Take Exhibit 5. If Rossi or
Penon had legitimate answers to the issues raised in that document,
they would have answered them. They had a contractual obligation to
answer, and it would have been in their interests to do so. They did
not respond at all. That tells me they have no answers and the damning
assertions made in that document are correct. I have other proof of
that. Independent observers told me these assertions are correct.
I am also certain there was not 1 MW of waste heat coming out of the
customer site.
I have seen Penon's data, and I confirm it has 36,000 kg in every day,
for weeks. As I explained here, that is impossible. If you reset the
counter to zero every day it might go past 36,000 every day, for
example, to 36,410, 36,228, etc., and with this meter that would show
up as 36,000 every day. Except when daylight savings changes. But that
is not what happened.
32,000 may be a reasonable approximation of what the meter showed, but
it is definitely made-up data that was stuffed into the tables.
- Jed
