At 08:29 PM 5/10/2010, Jed Rothwell wrote:
Shanahan's arguments are pretty much the same as Morrison's circa 1990. There has been no change in the skeptical camp; no learning, and argument worth discussing. These people understand nothing about conventional electrochemistry or cold fusion. In a sane world, Shanahan would not be able to publish this rubbish anywhere but his own blog.
Well, we don't know that it's been accepted, and it might not be. It's pretty bad.
It does appear, though, that Shanahan may have been funded to write this by the DoE. Now, there's a project for Krivit. What happened? Why Shanahan?
