Axil Axil <[email protected]> wrote: > > Like all Lenr reactions, the Rossi reactor show natural abundance in it’s > ash product. This should lend credence to the claim that the Rossi reaction > is real and that it is a valid Lenr Reaction. >
Others have already pointed this out, but in every case so far, LENR transmuted elements have unnatural abundance. The abundance ratios are the same as those of the starting element. See Iwamura. That has been the rule for Pd-D and other deuterium systems. It is at least conceivable that H systems work differently, functioning as a microscopic supernova, producing elements with natural isotopic ratios. Jones Beene said that different supernova produce elements with different ratios. That is not my understanding. I believe the ratio at creation is the same throughout the universe. Different isotope ratios exist within the solar system, especially for light elements, such as the ratio of D to H on Mars, but that is not because the material that makes up Mars came from a different supernova than earth. I note there are studies of things like "Interstellar isotope ratios from mm-wave molecular absorption spectra" where the ratios are for heavy elements such C, N and S. If the ratios varied considerably at creation, more or less at random, I do not see how studies could reach a conclusion. This study found ratios the same as in the solar system, except C-13. The authors propose a reason for the discrepancy: fractionation. It wasn't that way at creation. If creation varied by supernova, the numbers would be all over the place I suppose. - Jed
