There certainly are facts involved namely could the boiling be caused by the heat stored in the metal, etc. of the E-Cat to last 15 minutes. The answer is a definitive yes. It is not speculation. We know enough about the E-Cat to posit this as the only significant source of heat known in a powered-off reactor. To call it impossible (as you have done) shows a bias toward disbelief of the facts and a hint to us, I presume, that you think Rossi's reactor is producing anomalous heat. Certainly I have elucidated the source of this heat and that it is not speculation whereas you bid us into a speculative denial of the heat source on the grounds of your bad math. ----- Original Message ----- From: Jed Rothwell To: [email protected] Sent: Friday, August 26, 2011 3:52 PM Subject: Re: [Vo]:The Krivit Videos Part 3
Joe Catania <[email protected]> wrote: The facts are in. There are no facts in this discussion; only speculation. As it stands it is a given that thermal inertia could easily explain the 15 minute boiling. Your arguments are unsubstatiated. And your arguments would require the metal to be over a thousand degrees, if we are to believe the engineering tables of specific heat. I suggest you demonstrate this with ~10 kg of metal not particularly well insulated. - Jed
