Abd ul-Rahman Lomax <[email protected]> wrote:

> TheNextFuture, 5RR. I predict a block any day for TheNextFuture. This is
> an SPA, likely the sock of a banned user. New users don't file AfDs in
> their first few edits. . . .


All these arcane acronyms: SPA, AfD, blah, blah. As I said, Wikipedia is
too complicated. It has too many rules. Only fanatics will bother to master
this complex set of rules and procedures.

Conventional academic publishing does have rules. It has procedures based
on long established traditions. They are simpler than Wikipedia's rules.
Granted, Wikipedia's rules are partly about the Internet. Things like
"three revisions." But I get the impression that most of the rules are
about the administrative structure of Wikipedia, which I think is too
complicated and opaque.

- Jed

Reply via email to