So I wonder if an argument could be made that a mother that kisses their crying child's "boo-boo" and makes it stop hurting and the child stop crying could be classified as a very primitive form of placebo. I wonder what could be deduced or extrapolated from human nature into understanding the placebo effect from this - scans of a child's brain patterns for instance.

Kind of out of the box but this scenario occurred to me while reading the thread.


On 04/22/2013 01:56 PM, Jed Rothwell wrote:
I am not critical of them. As far as I know, based on recent research, there is no evidence they exist. That's all there is to it. They might exist. I do not know of any theoretical reason why they shouldn't, given the complexity of biology. But there is no evidence they do exist.

A placebo appears to be exactly the same as no treatment at all. That isn't surprising.

Reply via email to