Bob,

 

Did you blow the image up?  (thanks to Alan for having all of this info
handy)

 

I could be wrong, but the tube in question still looks to be far too thick
to be blackened stainless - and there is no sign of metal at all - it looks
black all the way in. Plus there is no sign of the markings of a hammered-in
fitting which would cause metal damage. I think its thickness and color is
consistent with SiC and the stainless capsule has been removed. 

 

The lack of an end cap (or evidence that one was ever there) also makes me
think that this tube is not steel.

 

 

From: Bob Higgins 

 

Jones,  I believe you are mistaken.  The bottom picture shows the thick
alumina (probably not high purity, but rather an AlSiMag blend) with the
slots for the resistor wires in the middle.  Inside this is only the
stainless tube - blackened by the refractory sealant they put over that
whole end in that vintage of HotCat (the ends are different on the new
design of the "Independent Test".  Then there is the outer tube about 4-5mm
thick which we are told is SiN (plausible).  I don't think there is anything
between the alumina resistor assembly and the stainless tube.

 

On Thu, Jul 4, 2013 at 5:10 PM, Jones Beene <[email protected]> wrote:



                From: Jed Rothwell

                If Rossi was using corundum, then carborundum would seem
like an improvement, but it is important to track down the actual
composition of what was used in the December test.

                I asked about this while correcting typos in the paper. One
of the authors told me it was "corundum, corindone in Italian."


Thanks - it is a bit of a surprise. It is true that the fluted cylinder with
the slots - which holds the resistance wire could easily be corundum which
is light-colored. Carborundum is blacker than black.

This picture on Alan's site shows the proper coloration of corundum

http://lenr.qumbu.com/web_hotcat_pics/130531_penon_07A.png

But this picture, below it - shows a black cylinder inside the HotCat where
another separate cylinder should be, and it is not light colored and not
stainless.

http://lenr.qumbu.com/web_hotcat_pics/130531_penon_08A.png

Therefore I am still of the opinion - but without any real evidence other
than this picture, that the ceramic which holds the stainless steel capsule
is carborundum or SiC.

Jones

Reply via email to