My reports is that Luca is far from being a newcomer or a carpetbagger in the domain. I let people knowing who he is report the precise facts to support what have been reported to me. Luca have a past, a good past.
this is painful to me, but the credibility of DGT compared to Luca was much lower even before the report... Since I'm a young ape it took time for me to get informed. now if you can find a credible story where everybody is honest, I will be happy for defkalion people. Today accusing Luca is far from being credible. The best hypothesis I have is based on only awfully unethical behavior, and the worst is punishable. This is not our war as Rambo would say. 2014-07-14 0:50 GMT+02:00 Axil Axil <janap...@gmail.com>: > I have heard rumors that Gamberale is a thief and a liar. To the validity > of this rumor, I cannot hold an informed opinion. At this juncture I cannot > really know who to believe. This uncertainty in the motives of any single > source is why reliable news organization must get multiple conformations > from highly trusted sources who are known to have no apparent agenda > toward the news item in question before they spread any news derived from > those trusted sources. > > On point that is troubling is news that Gamberale is still working in the > LENR field. This implies a continuing conflict of interest regarding his > opinions and assertions. > > Do you now have other reliable sources who will go on the record to > confirm what Gamberale asserts? > > > On Sun, Jul 13, 2014 at 6:21 PM, Jed Rothwell <jedrothw...@gmail.com> > wrote: > >> Axil Axil <janap...@gmail.com> wrote: >> >> >>> Why is Rossi so worried about Defkalion? It seems that Rossi's Defkalion >>> concerns are transcendent far above all other competitors. >>> >> >> I think he is upset by them, but not worried. He feels that he was misled >> and abused by them. I do not think he considers them competitors. He does >> not think they have anything. Based on the Gamberale report, I do not think >> they have anything either. Maybe some other report I have not seen shows >> they have something after all. But, so far, only Gamberale has published, >> and he is totally negative. >> >> Rossi is worried that a bad reputation for the field will make it harder >> for him. I get that. To some extent, opposition to cold fusion is good for >> him. It gives him a chance to work without competition. But, when the >> opposition ramps up too high, and there is too much hysteria in the mass >> media, that hurts him. For example, if the Swedish television reporter had >> her way, the second ELFORSK test would be abandoned. That would be bad for >> Rossi. He needs that test. He needs some degree of credibility. >> >> - Jed >> >> >
